5 versions from 2 sites

Pumpkin Pie

Nana's pick

Pumpkin Pie

Why this one: ★ 4.0 from 3.7k cooks; from NYT Cooking.

★ 4.0 (3.7k) 1 hr 11 ingredients NYT Cooking
Cook this one →

Or try

How cooks make it

What 5 versions agree on. The bar is how much of the recipe each ingredient makes up by weight, leaving out water and salt.

  • milk 19% 80% of versions
  • egg 9% 80% of versions
  • cinnamon a little every version
  • ginger a little every version
  • ground a little 80% of versions

Some add: pumpkin purée (40%), nutmeg (40%), molasses (40%), heavy cream (40%)

See all 5 versions
  1. Pumpkin Pie Nana's pick ★ 4.0 (3.7k) 1 hr 11 NYT Cooking
  2. Gluten-Free Pumpkin Pie ★ 4.6 (59) 25 min 11 Epicurious
  3. Vegan Pumpkin Pie ★ 4.0 (702) 1 hr 15 min 11 NYT Cooking
  4. Classic Pumpkin Pie ★ 4.3 (78) 45 min 12 Epicurious
  5. Gluten-Free Pumpkin Pie ★ 4.0 (206) 1 hr 15 min 14 NYT Cooking