Nana's bread school
Sourdough
Real bread from just flour, water, salt and a jar of wild yeast you grow yourself. It sounds fussy. It isn't. Learn a few ideas, follow one recipe, and let the dough tell you when it's ready.
- 30 minhands-on
- ~24 hrstart to finish, mostly waiting
- 1 loafabout 2 lb
Your bake
Lesson 1 · five minutes of reading
How sourdough works
Four ideas explain almost everything that happens to your bread. Once they click, the steps make sense on their own.
-
1
Wild yeast makes it rise
Your starter is full of wild yeast. It eats the sugars in flour and breathes out gas. Those bubbles are what lift the bread, just like store-bought yeast, only slower.
-
2
Bacteria make it taste good
Friendly bacteria live in the starter alongside the yeast. They make the gentle sour tang and help the loaf stay fresh for days.
-
3
Gluten holds the gas
When flour gets wet, its proteins link into stretchy gluten. Folding the dough makes that net stronger, so it holds the gas like a balloon instead of letting it escape.
-
4
Warmth sets the pace
Warm dough rises fast and cool dough slowly. A few degrees can change the timing by hours, which is why you watch the dough, not the clock.
The whole bake at a glance
Most of it is waiting. Start in the morning, bake the next morning.
- Wake up the starter4–8 hours before mixing
- Mix flour and water30 minutes
- Add starter and salt5 minutes, then the first rise begins
- Stretch and fold (4 times)2 hours: a set every 30 minutes
- Let it rise (hands off)Until the rise jar hits your target
- Pre-shape20–30 minutes
- Shape and put it in the basket5 minutes
- Proof in the fridge overnight8–16 hours
- Heat the oven and pot45–60 minutes before baking
- Score and bake40–45 minutes
- Let it cool. Really.At least 2 hours
Nana's one rule
Recipes give times, but your kitchen decides. Use the times as a guide and look for the signs in each step: how the dough looks, feels and grows.
What you'll need
Must have
- A kitchen scale in grams. Cups can't measure flour closely enough for bread.
- A large bowl, and a jar for the starter
- A lidded pot that can go in a hot oven (a Dutch oven)
- A kitchen towel and a bowl, or a proofing basket
- A razor blade or very sharp knife
Nice to have
- A small straight-sided jar, for the rise jar
- An instant-read thermometer
- A bench scraper
- Rice flour for dusting (nothing sticks to it)
Lesson 2 · about a week, only once
Grow your starter
A starter is just flour and water that wild yeast has moved into. It takes about a week of two-minute feedings, and then it lives for years. Already have one? Skip ahead.
-
Mix flour and water
In a clean jar, stir 50 g whole wheat (or rye) flour with 50 g lukewarm water into a thick paste. Scrape the sides, cover loosely (a lid set on top, not screwed down) and put a rubber band at the level of the paste.
What you'll see: Nothing yet. That's normal.
-
Just look and stir
Stir it once. Don't feed it yet.
What you'll see: Maybe a few bubbles. It may smell like flour, cheese, or nothing at all.
-
First feeding
Keep 25 g of the starter and throw the rest away (or compost it). Add 50 g flour (half whole wheat, half bread or all-purpose) and 50 g water. Stir, scrape down, move the rubber band to the new level.
What you'll see: It may suddenly foam up and smell odd, like gym socks or nail polish. Bacteria that won't stay are having a party. Keep going.
-
The quiet day
Same feeding as day 3: keep 25 g, add 50 g flour and 50 g water.
What you'll see: Often it goes completely flat and quiet today. This is the step where most people give up — don't. The good yeast is still waking up.
-
Feed again
Same feeding: keep 25 g, add 50 g flour and 50 g water.
What you'll see: Small bubbles through the jar and a slightly sour, yogurty smell.
-
Twice a day if it's waking up
If it rose at all since yesterday, start feeding twice a day, about 12 hours apart. Same amounts.
What you'll see: It starts to rise and fall on a rhythm. Note how many hours it takes to peak.
-
Test for ready
Feed in the morning and watch the rubber band.
What you'll see: Ready when it at least doubles within 4–8 hours of feeding, three days in a row, and smells pleasantly sour. In a cold kitchen this can take 10–14 days. That's fine.
How do I know it's ready?
Your starter is ready to bake with when it at least doubles within 4 to 8 hours of a feeding, three days in a row, and smells pleasantly sour.
- Doubled or more: the top is at least twice as high as the rubber band you set at feeding time.
- Bubbles all the way through the jar, not just on top, and a rounded, domed top at its highest point.
- A sour, yogurty or green-apple smell. Nail polish or gym socks means it's hungry or still settling in.
- It does it on schedule three days running. One great day can be a fluke; three means the yeast has taken over.
The float test
Still not sure? At its peak, drop a teaspoon of starter into a glass of water. If it floats, it's full of gas and ready to raise bread. If it sinks, give it a few more feedings. A very wet or whole-grain starter can sink even when it's ready, so trust the doubling first.
After each feeding, set the rubber band at the top of the starter and check it every hour or two once it gets going. Note the time it peaks: that's how long your levain will take on baking day. Most starters peak in 4 to 8 hours in a 75 °F (24 °C) kitchen; slower in the cold, faster in the heat.
Not ready yet?
Day 7 and it still won't double
That's very common, especially in a cool kitchen. Keep feeding twice a day and move it somewhere warmer (75–80 °F / 24–27 °C, like an oven with only the light on). Use some whole wheat or rye in each feeding and filtered or boiled-and-cooled water if your tap water is heavily chlorinated. It can take 10 to 14 days.
There's gray or brown liquid on top
That's hooch, alcohol the starter makes when it's hungry. It isn't harmful. Pour it off (or stir it in for more tang) and feed it. If it happens often, feed it more often or a little more flour.
It rose fast and fell before I checked
Good news: it's active. Look for the dried streaks on the jar wall above the paste; that's how high it got. If it peaks in under 4 hours, it's warm and lively, so feed it with a little less starter (15 g instead of 25 g) to slow it down.
Pink, orange or fuzzy spots
That's mold or unwanted bacteria. Don't scrape it off: throw it all out, wash the jar well with hot soapy water and start again. Keeping the jar clean and feeding on time prevents it.
It smells like nail polish or vinegar
It's hungry. Feed it twice a day for a couple of days and the smell mellows into a pleasant yogurt tang.
Keeping your starter alive
Every day (on the counter)
Keep 25 g, add 50 g flour + 50 g water once or twice a day. Use it when it has risen and is domed or just starting to flatten (its peak).
A few days a week (in the fridge)
Feed, wait 1–2 hours, then refrigerate. It's happy for about a week. To bake, take it out, feed it once or twice at room temperature, and use it at its peak.
Going away
Feed it stiffer (25 g starter + 50 g flour + 25 g water), refrigerate, and it will keep 2–3 weeks. Or smear a thin layer on parchment, dry it fully and keep the flakes in a jar for months.
Make the levain for baking
The night before or morning of baking, mix 20 g starter + 50 g flour + 50 g water. In 4–8 hours (warm = faster) it's at its peak and ready. This gives you exactly the 100 g you need, with a little left over to keep.
Lesson 3 · one recipe
Nana's everyday loaf
Four ingredients, weighed in grams. Learn this one loaf well before you try anything fancier.
- Flour is the structure. Its proteins become gluten.
- Water wakes up the flour. More water makes a more open crumb, but a stickier dough.
- Starter brings the yeast for rise and the bacteria for flavor.
- Salt is flavor, and it makes the dough stronger.
Lesson 4 · bake
Step by step
Every step says what to do, why it matters, and what the dough should look like. In the kitchen, use for one step at a time with timers.
-
1
Wake up the starter
4–8 hours before mixing
- Mix 20 g of your starter with 50 g flour and 50 g lukewarm water in a jar. Mark the level.
- Leave it on the counter until it has at least doubled and the top is domed. That takes about 4 hours in a warm kitchen and up to 8 in a cool one.
- Don't start mixing until it peaks: a sleepy levain gives a slow rise and a dense loaf. Not sure? Drop a teaspoon in water. If it floats, it's ready.
Why: Starter straight from the jar is sleepy. Feeding it and waiting for its peak means the yeast is at full strength when it meets the dough.
It should look like this: Bubbly all through, domed on top, smells like yogurt and fruit. A spoonful pulls up in stretchy strands.
It didn't double
Give it more time, or move it somewhere warmer (an oven with only the light on is about 78–80 °F). If it's still sluggish after 10 hours, it needs a few more days of regular feedings before it can raise bread.
It rose and already fell
That's fine for today if it collapsed within the last hour or two. If it fell long ago and smells sharply sour, feed it again and wait for the next peak.
-
2
Mix flour and water
30 minutes
- In a big bowl, mix 450 g bread flour and 50 g whole wheat flour.
- Add 330 g lukewarm water (about 80 °F / 27 °C) and mix with your hand until no dry flour is left. It will be shaggy. Keep the other 20 g of water.
- Cover and rest 30 minutes. The flour soaks up the water and the dough starts to get stretchy on its own.
Why: Letting flour and water sit alone first lets the flour soak up the water and start building gluten on its own, so you do less work later.
It should look like this: A rough, sticky lump with no dry flour.
It's very dry and stiff
Some flours drink more. Add the reserved water now, a splash at a time.
-
3
Add starter and salt
5 minutes, then the first rise begins
- Add 100 g of the ripe starter, 10 g salt and the reserved 20 g water on top of the dough.
- Wet your hand and squeeze the dough through your fingers, then fold it over itself, for 3–4 minutes until everything disappears into it.
- Take a small spoonful of dough, drop it into a small straight-sided jar or a tall glass, press it flat and mark the level with tape. This is your rise jar: it shows how much the whole dough has grown, without guessing.
- Write down the time and the dough's temperature if you have a thermometer. The first rise starts now.
Why: Salt seasons the bread and tightens the dough. The rise jar matters because a big bowl of dough is hard to judge by eye, but a small jar with a mark never lies.
It should look like this: Sticky and uneven at first, smoother after a few minutes. Wet hands keep it from sticking.
It's soupy and won't hold together
Normal right after mixing. It firms up a lot during the stretch-and-folds. If it's still soup after the second set, next time use 30 g less water.
-
4
Stretch and fold (4 times)
2 hours: a set every 30 minutes
- With a wet hand, grab the side of the dough farthest from you, stretch it up until it resists, and fold it over to the other side.
- Turn the bowl a quarter turn and repeat, 4 times in all. That's one set. Cover again.
- Do a set every 30 minutes, 4 sets in total.
Why: Each fold lines the gluten up into a stretchy net. That net traps the gas the yeast makes. Folding does the job of kneading, with much less effort.
It should look like this: Each set the dough holds its shape a little better. By the last set it's smooth, slightly domed, and stretches far before it tears.
It tears right away
Be gentler and stretch only until you feel resistance. Wait the full 30 minutes; the dough relaxes and gets stronger between sets.
I missed a set
No harm. Do it when you can. Three sets is plenty; two still makes good bread.
-
5
Let it rise (hands off)
Until the rise jar hits your target
- Leave the dough covered. Don't touch it.
- Watch the rise jar, not the clock. Check the table for how much it should grow at your kitchen temperature (about 50% in a 76 °F kitchen).
- Use the rise checker below: enter the starting and current marks and it tells you how close you are.
Why: This is when the starter does its work: the yeast fills the dough with gas and the bacteria build flavor. Stop too early and the bread is dense; too late and it slumps.
It should look like this: Bigger, puffy, domed at the edges, with some bubbles on the top and sides. It jiggles like set gelatin when you shake the bowl.
Photo: Ruth Hartnup, CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons It's taking forever
The kitchen is probably cooler than you think. Move the bowl somewhere warm (oven with the light on, top of the fridge). Bread is ready when the jar says so; this is the step that's never on schedule.
It grew way past the target
Shape it right away and give it a shorter fridge proof (6–8 hours). It will be a little flatter but still good. Next time use less starter or start later.
Lots of big bubbles and it smells boozy
It's over-risen. Shape it gently and bake it in a loaf pan; it'll make lovely sandwich bread.
-
6
Pre-shape
20–30 minutes
- Lightly flour the counter. Tip the dough out, sticky side down.
- Fold the edges into the middle like an envelope, flip it seam-side down, and gently drag it toward you a few times so it rounds up.
- Leave it uncovered for 20–30 minutes.
Why: A loose first shape gathers the dough and lets it relax, so the final shape can be tight without tearing.
It should look like this: A loose round that slowly relaxes and spreads a little.
It spreads into a puddle
It needs more strength: do the pre-shape again and rest 15 more minutes. Next time, add a fifth set of folds or a little less water.
-
7
Shape and put it in the basket
5 minutes
- Dust a proofing basket or a bowl lined with a clean kitchen towel generously with rice flour (it doesn't stick the way wheat flour does).
- Flour the top of the dough, flip it over, and fold it into a tight package: bottom up to the middle, sides in, then roll from the top down toward you, pressing the seam closed.
- Place it seam-side up in the basket. Pinch the seam shut.
Why: A tight skin on the outside holds the loaf up in the oven, so it rises tall instead of spreading flat.
It should look like this: A tight, smooth ball or log with taut skin on the bottom (which will be the top).
Photo: Wald1siedel, CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons It sticks to everything
Flour your hands and the top of the dough, not the counter under it. A bench scraper (or a thin spatula) helps lift it.
-
8
Proof in the fridge overnight
8–16 hours
- Cover the basket (a shower cap or plastic bag works) and put it in the fridge.
- Anywhere from 8 to 16 hours is fine. The cold makes it easy to score and fits your sleep.
Why: The cold almost stops the yeast while the bacteria keep building flavor. A cold loaf is also firm, which makes it easy to score.
It should look like this: Slightly puffed and firm from the cold.
I need to bake later than 16 hours
Up to 24 hours usually works; it gets a bit more sour and may spread more.
-
9
Heat the oven and pot
45–60 minutes before baking
- Put a lidded Dutch oven (cast iron, 4–6 quarts) with its lid in the oven and heat to 475 °F (245 °C) for at least 45 minutes.
- No Dutch oven? Heat a baking sheet, and put a metal pan on the rack below to pour a cup of boiling water into when the bread goes in.
Why: A screaming-hot pot hits the dough with heat from every side. That burst of heat gives the big final rise, called oven spring.
It should look like this: The pot is screaming hot. Use thick oven mitts from here on.
Photo: Virtual-Pano, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons -
10
Score and bake
40–45 minutes
- Take the dough straight from the fridge. Put a piece of parchment over the basket and flip it out onto the parchment.
- With a razor blade or your sharpest knife, make one confident slash about ¼ inch (½ cm) deep along the top, at a shallow angle.
- Lift by the parchment into the hot pot. Lid on. Bake 20 minutes.
- Remove the lid, lower the oven to 450 °F (230 °C) and bake 20–25 minutes more, until deep brown.
Why: With the lid on, steam from the dough keeps the crust soft so the loaf can keep growing. With the lid off, the crust dries and turns deep brown.
It should look like this: Risen high, with the cut opened into a ridge (an 'ear'). Deep chestnut brown. It sounds hollow when you tap the bottom; inside reads 205–210 °F (96–99 °C).
Photo: SueRostvold, CC BY 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons It came out pale
Bake longer with the lid off; color is flavor. Check your oven with an oven thermometer — many run 25 °F cool.
The bottom is burning
Put a baking sheet on the rack under the pot for the lid-off part.
-
11
Let it cool. Really.
At least 2 hours
- Cool it on a rack for at least 2 hours before cutting.
Why: The inside is still cooking and setting as it cools. Cut it early and the crumb turns gummy.
It should look like this: The crust crackles as it cools. That sound is the bread finishing.
Photo: Nutrition, Food Safety & Health, CC0 · Wikimedia Commons But I want to eat it now
The inside is still cooking from its own heat. Cut it hot and the crumb turns gummy. Two hours, mija.
Plan your bake
Tell Nana how warm your kitchen is and when you want to bake. She'll give you a clock time for every step, and keep the overnight rest so you're never up at 3 AM.
Start the bake and Nana follows along: a reminder at every step, rise checks until the dough is ready, and the oven and cooling times. Run early or late and the rest of the plan moves with you. Log in to get reminders with the page closed.
How much should it rise?
This is the step that decides everything. Warmer dough keeps rising after you shape it, so it should stop earlier. Find your kitchen temperature:
| Dough temperature | Stop when it's grown | Roughly |
|---|---|---|
| 68 °F / 20 °C | 100% bigger | 9–11 hours |
| 70 °F / 21 °C | 75% bigger | 8–9 hours |
| 72 °F / 22 °C | 65% bigger | 7–8 hours |
| 74 °F / 23 °C | 55% bigger | 6–7 hours |
| 76 °F / 24 °C | 50% bigger | 5–6 hours |
| 78 °F / 26 °C | 40% bigger | 4½–5 hours |
| 80 °F / 27 °C | 35% bigger | 4–4½ hours |
| 82 °F / 28 °C | 30% bigger | 3½–4 hours |
Rise checker
Measure from the bottom of your rise jar to the starting mark, then to the top of the dough now, in any unit.
Enter both marks.
Lesson 5 · learn from your loaf
Read your loaf
Once it's cool, cut it down the middle. The holes tell you exactly what to change next time.
Under-fermented
Dense, tight areas (often at the bottom) with a few huge holes near the top. Shiny, gummy streaks. The loaf may have burst open on the side instead of along the cut.
Next time: Let the first rise go longer, to the target on the table. Make sure the starter is at its peak when you use it.
Just right
Holes of many sizes spread evenly from top to bottom. Soft, glossy, springy crumb. A tall loaf with an open cut.
Next time: Write down what you did — temperature, rise, hours — and do it again.
Over-fermented
A flat, wide loaf. Small, even holes, a sticky dough that was hard to shape, a strong sour or boozy taste. The cut barely opened.
Next time: End the first rise earlier (a lower target, or check sooner). In a warm kitchen use 10% starter instead of 20%.
Lesson 6 · when something goes wrong
Fix it
My bread is flat
Nine times out of ten the first rise went too long or not long enough — check the crumb pictures above to tell which. Then check that the shaping made a tight skin and that the oven was fully heated.
The inside is gummy
Cut too early (wait 2 hours), under-baked (it should read 205 °F inside) or under-fermented (dense bottom).
It's too sour
Use your starter right at its peak, not after it falls. Shorten the fridge proof. Feed the starter more often.
It isn't sour enough
Proof in the fridge longer (up to 24 hours), add more whole wheat, and use the starter a little after its peak.
The crust is too thick and hard
Bake with the lid on the full 20 minutes so steam keeps the crust soft while it rises; take it out as soon as it's deep brown.
There's grey liquid on my starter
It's called hooch: the starter is hungry. Pour it off (or stir it in for more sourness) and feed it.
There's fuzz on my starter
Pink, orange or fuzzy spots are mold. Throw it out and start over in a very clean jar. A dry crust or grey liquid is not mold.
Do I need a Dutch oven?
It's the easiest way to trap steam. A hot baking sheet plus a pan of boiling water underneath works too.
Can I use all-purpose flour?
Yes. Use 325 g water (65%) instead of 350 g, because it absorbs less. The loaf will be a little softer and flatter.
Things people get wrong
Your starter has to double to be ready.It has to rise predictably. Some starters triple, some rise 75%. Use it at its own peak.The float test tells you the starter is ready.It often fails with ready starters, especially whole grain ones. Watch the rise instead.Recipe times are the times.Your kitchen temperature changes them by hours. The rise jar is the real timer.Salt must go in later or it kills the yeast.In a normal 2% amount it's fine to add it with the starter, as this recipe does.You need to feed 1:1:1.Feeding more flour and water than starter (like 1:2:2 here) keeps it strong, less sour and on a steadier schedule.
Words you'll hear
- Starter
- Flour and water full of wild yeast and friendly bacteria, kept alive by feeding. It replaces store-bought yeast.
- Levain
- A portion of starter fed just for today's bread.
- Peak
- The moment a fed starter has risen the most, right before it starts to fall. Its strongest.
- Hydration
- Water as a percentage of flour weight. 350 g water ÷ 500 g flour = 70%.
- Bulk fermentation
- The first rise, after mixing and before shaping. The step that decides everything.
- Rise jar
- A small sample of the dough in a marked jar, so you can see exactly how much the whole batch has grown. (Bakers call it an aliquot.)
- Proof
- The second rise, after shaping, here done in the fridge.
- Score
- The cut on top that lets the loaf open where you want.
- Ear
- The raised, crunchy flap along a well-opened cut.
- Crumb
- The inside of the bread.
Kosher notes
- Sourdough is chametz: put it away before Passover. A starter can be dried and given to a non-Jewish friend to keep, or sold with your chametz; ask your rabbi.
- If you bake with about 2½ lb (1.2 kg) of flour or more at once (3 loaves of this recipe), many follow the custom of separating challah. The amount for a blessing is larger and customs vary; see Cooking for Shabbat.
- This loaf is parve: flour, water, salt and starter.
Keep learning: Gluten & kneading · Flour · Why we rest dough · Baking troubleshooting
Nana's method draws on decades of home baking and on The Sourdough Framework by Hendrik Kleinwächter, a free, open book (CC BY-SA 4.0) worth reading when you want the science. All writing here is our own. Reviewed 2026-11-15.