Buttermilk
Photo: Ukko-wc, CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Buttermilk

Also called cultured buttermilk

Nice to have
What it is
Today's buttermilk is low-fat milk cultured with bacteria until thick and tangy (it used to be the liquid left from churning butter).
Tastes like
Tangy and sour, like thin yogurt.
Use it for
Pancakes, biscuits, soda bread, cakes, ranch dressing, marinating chicken.

Out of it? Swap in

  • 1 cup milk plus 1 tablespoon lemon juice or vinegar, rested 5 minutesThe classic. Right acidity for baking soda, thinner and less tangy.
  • ¾ cup plain yogurt plus ¼ cup milkThicker and tangier; the closest in flavor.

Diet & allergens

Milk / dairy
StoreBack of the fridge.
KeepsAbout 2 weeks once opened. Freezes well in ½-cup portions; shake after thawing.
Toss whenPink or fuzzy mold, or a smell that's off rather than simply sour.

BuyingFull-fat if you can find it; it makes richer biscuits.

Nana's tip: Its acid is what makes baking soda rise in a recipe; don't swap in plain milk without adding acid.

Cook with it

357 recipes on Nana's Fogón use buttermilk.

See all 357 →