Baking is cooking with less room for guessing, so the shelf matters more. The good news is that a short list covers almost everything: one flour, white and brown sugar, baking soda and baking powder, vanilla, salt, butter (or oil) and eggs. Buy those, keep them fresh, and you can bake most of the cookies, cakes, muffins and quick breads on this site.
This builds on The Everyday Pantry. For the why behind each ingredient, see Baking Soda vs. Baking Powder, Gluten & Kneading and Creaming & Folding.
Why the baking shelf is different
- Ratios are chemistry. In a stew, an extra handful of onion is fine. In a cake, an extra tablespoon of baking soda is inedible. Bake by weight when you can; a $20 scale fixes more bakes than any recipe.
- Freshness is invisible. Old baking powder looks exactly like new baking powder; it just doesn’t rise. Old flour smells fine until it’s rancid. Date your containers.
- Substitutions cascade. Swapping natural cocoa for Dutch-process, or oil for butter, changes acid, fat and water at once. The cards below say what you lose.
The essentials
All-purpose flour
Also called AP flour, plain flour
- What it is
- Milled from the starchy heart of the wheat kernel, blended from hard and soft wheats to land in the middle at about 10 to 12 percent protein.
- Tastes like
- Mild and wheaty once baked; raw, it tastes like paste and shouldn't be eaten.
- Use it for
- Cookies, cakes, pie crust, quick breads, challah, pancakes, thickening gravy, and dredging cutlets.
The kinds you'll see
- Unbleached — Aged naturally. Creamy color, slightly more flavor. The default.
- Bleached — Whitened with a chemical treatment. A little softer and whiter in cakes; otherwise interchangeable.
- Self-rising — Lower-protein flour with baking powder and salt mixed in. Don't use it where a recipe doesn't call for it.
Out of it? Swap in
- Bread flour, same weightChewier and taller; cookies spread less, cakes get tougher.
- Cake flour plus 2 teaspoons per cup moreSofter, more tender; weaker for bread.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA 5-pound bag at a time unless you bake every week. Brands vary in protein; pick one and keep it.
Nana's tip: Measure by weight whenever you can, 125 g per cup. If you must use cups, spoon the flour in and level it; scooping packs in up to 25 percent too much.
The one flour to start with. It handles cookies, cakes, pie crust, pancakes, quick breads and even decent sandwich bread. Unbleached and bleached work the same in most recipes; bleached gives slightly softer cakes. Keep a 5-lb (2.3-kg) bag. Flour: Which Bag for Which Bake explains when the others are worth it.
Granulated sugar
Also called white sugar, sugar, caster sugar, superfine sugar
- What it is
- Refined sucrose from sugarcane or sugar beets, in fine, dry crystals.
- Tastes like
- Pure, clean sweetness with nothing else behind it.
- Use it for
- Nearly all baking, creaming with butter, meringue, caramel, syrups, jam, and balancing acid in tomato sauce and dressings.
The kinds you'll see
- Granulated — The everyday crystal. 200 g per cup.
- Superfine (caster) — Finer crystals that dissolve fast. Best for meringue and cocktails. Pulse granulated in a food processor for 30 seconds to make it.
- Turbinado or demerara — Large golden crystals with a light molasses flavor. For crunchy tops on muffins and challah, not for mixing in.
Out of it? Swap in
- Light brown sugar, packed, same weightSofter, chewier, more caramel flavor, slightly darker.
- Honey, about 3/4 the amountSee the sweeteners guide; you need to cut liquid and lower the oven.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA 4- or 5-pound bag. Store-brand cane or beet sugar works the same.
Nana's tip: Creaming butter and sugar for a full 3 to 5 minutes, until pale, is what makes a cake light; the sharp crystals punch air into the fat.
Sweetens, but also tenderizes, browns, and helps butter trap air when you cream them. Don’t cut it by more than about a quarter in a cake recipe without expecting a drier, paler, tougher result. More in Sugars & Sweeteners.
Brown sugar
Also called light brown sugar, dark brown sugar
- What it is
- White sugar with molasses mixed back in, about 3.5 percent for light and 6.5 percent for dark. The molasses makes it moist, soft and slightly acidic.
- Tastes like
- Caramel and toffee; dark brown tastes deeper and slightly bitter, like a mild molasses.
- Use it for
- Chewy cookies, sticky glazes for salmon and chicken, barbecue sauce, oatmeal, crumb toppings and spice cakes.
The kinds you'll see
- Light brown — The default. Measure it firmly packed, about 213 g per cup.
- Dark brown — Twice the molasses. Gingerbread, baked beans, rich glazes.
Out of it? Swap in
- DIY brown sugar1 cup granulated plus 1 tablespoon molasses for light, 2 for dark. Mix with a fork or your fingers until even.
- Granulated sugar, same weightCrisper, paler, flatter cookies with less flavor.
- Coconut sugarSimilar caramel flavor, drier and grainier.
Diet & allergens
BuyingLight brown is enough for most kitchens; add dark if you make gingerbread or barbecue sauce.
Nana's tip: Rock-hard brown sugar softens overnight sealed with a slice of bread, or in 20 to 30 seconds in the microwave under a damp paper towel.
White sugar plus molasses. It makes cookies chewy and moist and adds a caramel note. Light brown is the all-purpose one. Pack it firmly into the cup when measuring.
Baking soda
Also called bicarbonate of soda, sodium bicarbonate, bicarb
- What it is
- Pure sodium bicarbonate, a base. Mixed with an acid and moisture it releases carbon dioxide, which lifts batter; it also helps browning.
- Tastes like
- Salty and soapy-metallic on its own; too much leaves a bitter, soapy taste and a yellowish crumb.
- Use it for
- Recipes with an acidic ingredient (buttermilk, yogurt, brown sugar, honey, molasses, natural cocoa, lemon) — pancakes, quick breads, chewy cookies, gingerbread, chocolate cake.
Out of it? Swap in
- About 3 times as much baking powder (1 tsp powder per ⅓ tsp soda)Rises fine, but the recipe's acid is left unbalanced, so it tastes tangier and browns less.
Diet & allergens
BuyingThe smallest box. You use a teaspoon at a time.
Nana's tip: Baking soda is about four times stronger than baking powder; measure it with a level spoon, never heaped, or you'll taste it.
Needs an acid in the recipe (buttermilk, yogurt, brown sugar, honey, natural cocoa) to work. It also boosts browning, which is why a pinch is in so many cookie recipes.
- What it is
- Baking soda premixed with dry acids and a little starch to keep it dry. "Double-acting" releases some gas when wet and the rest in the oven's heat.
- Tastes like
- Faintly salty and a bit metallic; too much tastes bitter and makes cakes rise and then collapse.
- Use it for
- Cakes, muffins, biscuits, scones, pancakes and waffles, especially recipes without much acid of their own.
The kinds you'll see
- Double-acting — The standard in American stores and recipes. Gives you a few minutes' grace before baking.
- Aluminum-free — Uses only acids that avoid the faint metallic taste some people notice. Works the same.
- Kosher-for-Passover — Made with potato starch instead of cornstarch. Weaker for some bakers; test it before Pesach.
Out of it? Swap in
- ¼ tsp baking soda + ½ tsp cream of tartar per 1 tsp baking powderSingle-acting, so bake it right away.
- ¼ tsp baking soda per 1 tsp powder, plus swap ½ cup of the recipe's milk for buttermilk or yogurtThe acid in the dairy does the work; slightly tangier.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA small can, and write the opening date on the lid.
Nana's tip: Too much powder is as bad as too little; the bubbles grow too big, merge and escape, and the cake sinks in the middle.
Baking soda with its acid already mixed in. Many recipes use both: powder for most of the lift, soda to balance acid and brown the crust. Baking Soda vs. Baking Powder has the full story.
Nana's tip
Test your leaveners before a big bake. Baking powder: ½ tsp in ¼ cup hot water should bubble hard. Baking soda: a pinch in a spoonful of vinegar should fizz right away. No fizz, no rise.
Vanilla extract
Also called vanilla, vanilla sugar, vanilla bean paste
- What it is
- Cured vanilla orchid pods soaked in alcohol and water until the alcohol draws out their flavor. Imitation vanilla is synthetic vanillin.
- Tastes like
- Warm, floral, creamy and sweet-smelling; it rounds out sugar, chocolate and eggs and makes desserts taste "finished."
- Use it for
- Nearly every cake, cookie, custard, whipped cream, frosting and French toast; a drop in hot chocolate or fruit compote.
The kinds you'll see
- Pure extract — The everyday choice; best in uncooked or lightly cooked things like whipped cream and custard.
- Imitation / vanillin — Cheaper and honestly fine in cookies and cakes baked at high heat, where the subtle notes bake off anyway.
- Vanilla bean / paste — Speckled and most aromatic. For ice cream, panna cotta, crème brûlée. 1 bean ≈ 1 Tbsp paste ≈ 1 Tbsp extract.
- Vanilla sugar — Sugar flavored with vanilla, sold in small packets. Common in Israeli and European recipes; one 10-g packet ≈ 1 tsp extract plus 2 tsp sugar.
Out of it? Swap in
- Imitation vanilla, same amountFlatter in custard and cream; hard to tell apart in baked goods.
- Vanilla sugar (one 10-g packet per tsp extract; reduce sugar by 2 tsp)Works well in batters and doughs.
- Bourbon, brandy or dark rum, same amountA different warmth, but it fills the gap in a pinch.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA 4-oz (118-ml) bottle of pure extract with a hechsher. Prices swing with the vanilla harvest; imitation is a reasonable backup for cookies.
Nana's tip: Add vanilla once a custard or sauce is off the heat; its aroma is volatile and boils away.
Pure extract for custards and whipped cream; imitation is honestly fine in cookies and cakes. Many recipes on this site call for vanilla sugar in little packets, which is the Israeli and European habit. One 10-g packet stands in for about 1 tsp extract.
Table salt
Also called fine salt, iodized salt, pickling salt
- What it is
- Fine, dense cubic crystals of salt, usually with an anticaking agent, and often with added iodine.
- Tastes like
- Sharp and quick. The tiny grains dissolve instantly, so it hits the tongue harder than coarse salt spoon for spoon.
- Use it for
- Baking, where it disperses evenly through dough and batter; brines and soups where it dissolves anyway; the shaker on the table.
The kinds you'll see
- Iodized — Has potassium iodide added. You can't taste it in normal cooking.
- Plain (non-iodized) — Same salt without the iodine.
- Pickling or canning salt — Fine pure salt with no iodine or anticaking agents, so pickle brine stays clear.
Out of it? Swap in
- Diamond Crystal kosher salt, twice the volumeSame saltiness; slightly slower to dissolve in a stiff dough.
- Fine sea salt, about the same volumeClosest match; most fine sea salts weigh nearly the same per teaspoon.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne round canister lasts most households a year. Iodized or plain is your call; they taste the same.
Nana's tip: When a baking recipe just says "salt," it almost always means table salt. Use kosher salt instead and you'll need about twice the volume.
A pinch of salt makes sweet things taste more like themselves. Baking recipes usually mean fine table salt, which disperses evenly in a dough. If you use Kosher salt instead, use about 1¼ times the volume of Morton or twice the volume of Diamond Crystal. See Salt: Kosher, Table, Flaky & Sea.
Unsalted butter
Also called sweet butter, sweet cream butter
- What it is
- Churned cream, about 80 to 82 percent fat, 16 to 18 percent water, and a little milk solids, with no added salt.
- Tastes like
- Sweet, creamy and milky; browned, it turns nutty and toffee-like.
- Use it for
- Baking, pan sauces, basting steak, scrambled eggs, cookies, pie crust, and finishing vegetables.
The kinds you'll see
- Standard American — At least 80 percent fat. Fine for nearly everything.
- European-style — 82 to 86 percent fat, often cultured. Flakier pastry, richer sauces.
- Salted — Varies by brand, roughly 1/4 teaspoon of table salt per stick. Great on bread; less control in baking.
- Cultured — Made from slightly soured cream. Tangier, more flavor.
Out of it? Swap in
- Salted butterCut the recipe's added salt by about 1/4 teaspoon per stick.
- Parve margarine or butter-flavored sticksThe kosher swap for meat meals. Similar in baking; less flavor, sometimes softer dough.
- Neutral oil, about 3/4 the amountWorks in muffins and quick breads. Can't cream it, so no use in cookies or pastry that need air or flakes.
Diet & allergens
BuyingPick one brand for baking and stick with it. 1 stick = 8 tablespoons = 1/2 cup = 113 g.
Nana's tip: "Room temperature" butter for creaming means about 65°F (18°C): it should dent with a finger but not look greasy or shiny.
Unsalted, always, for baking, so you control the salt. Keep 2 lb (900 g) in the freezer; it keeps for months there and softens on the counter in about an hour.
Eggs
Also called large eggs
- What it is
- Chicken eggs. Recipes assume US "large" eggs, about 50 g out of the shell (about 30 g white, 18 g yolk).
- Tastes like
- Mild and rich; yolks are buttery, whites almost neutral. Diet and freshness matter more than shell color.
- Use it for
- Binding, leavening, emulsifying, glazing, enriching; challah, cakes, custards, mayonnaise, shakshuka, kugel, breakfast.
The kinds you'll see
- Large — The recipe standard. Buy these.
- Extra-large / jumbo — Up to 25% bigger; weigh them in baking.
- Pasture-raised — Often deeper-colored yolks. A matter of taste and values, not safety.
Out of it? Swap in
- 1 tablespoon ground flaxseed plus 3 tablespoons water, rested 10 minutes (per egg)Binds muffins, brownies and cookies. No lift or richness; don't use for more than 2 eggs.
- 3 tablespoons aquafaba (chickpea liquid) per egg, or 2 per whiteWhips like egg white for meringue and mousse.
Diet & allergens
BuyingGrade A or AA large, uncracked, from the back of the cold case.
Nana's tip: Crack eggs on a flat counter, not the bowl's edge, so the shell breaks cleanly instead of pushing shards into the egg.
Large eggs are the baking standard (about 50 g out of the shell). They bind, lift, enrich and emulsify. Room-temperature eggs whip higher and blend smoothly into creamed butter; set them in warm water for 5 minutes if you forgot.
Neutral oil
Also called vegetable oil, canola oil, grapeseed oil, avocado oil
- What it is
- Refined oils from seeds or fruit that have been filtered and deodorized until they taste of almost nothing and can take high heat.
- Tastes like
- Of nothing, which is the point. It carries other flavors without adding its own.
- Use it for
- Searing, stir-frying, deep- and shallow-frying, oil-based cakes, mayonnaise, and any dressing where olive oil would be too loud.
The kinds you'll see
- Canola — Cheap, mild, about 400°F (205°C) smoke point. The best all-rounder.
- Vegetable (usually soybean) — Same job as canola. Fine for frying.
- Avocado (refined) — Highest smoke point of the common oils, around 500°F (260°C). Pricier; worth it for hard sears.
- Grapeseed — Very clean flavor, good for mayonnaise and dressings. Goes rancid fairly fast.
- Peanut — The classic deep-frying oil. Highly refined peanut oil is generally not considered a major allergen in the US, but cold-pressed is; when cooking for someone with an allergy, skip it.
Out of it? Swap in
- Light (refined) olive oilNearly neutral and heat-tolerant.
- Melted refined coconut oilWorks in baking; solidifies when cool.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne big bottle of canola or vegetable oil for most cooking, plus a small bottle of avocado oil if you sear a lot.
Nana's tip: Fry with fresh oil. Strain used frying oil through a coffee filter and reuse it once or twice for the same kind of food, then let it go.
Oil cakes are moister than butter cakes and stay soft for days. In a kosher kitchen, oil is how most cakes served after a meat meal stay parve.
Nice to have
Add these as you start baking more often or reach for specific styles.
Powdered sugar
Also called confectioners' sugar, icing sugar, 10X sugar
- What it is
- Granulated sugar ground to a fine powder, with about 3 percent starch mixed in so it doesn't cake.
- Tastes like
- Sweet with a faint chalky finish from the starch, noticeable in uncooked frosting.
- Use it for
- Frosting and glaze, dusting cakes and rugelach, whipped cream that holds, and tender shortbread.
Out of it? Swap in
- DIY powdered sugarBlend 1 cup granulated with 1 tablespoon cornstarch (or potato starch) in a blender until fine, about 1 minute. Let the dust settle before opening.
- Superfine sugarFor whipped cream only. Doesn't make frosting.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA 2-pound bag. Look for "potato starch" on the label before Passover.
Nana's tip: Always sift it for frosting and glaze. It weighs about 120 g per cup unsifted, so measure by weight if you can.
For frosting, glazes and dusting. It contains a little cornstarch, so don’t swap it 1:1 for granulated in a cake.
Cornstarch
Also called corn starch, cornflour
- What it is
- Pure starch from the corn kernel's endosperm, a fine white powder that thickens liquids and tenderizes baked goods.
- Tastes like
- Nothing. Undercooked, it leaves a chalky, raw-starch feel.
- Use it for
- Thickening fruit pie filling, stir-fry sauce, pudding and custard; crisp coatings; DIY cake flour; tenderizing shortbread.
Out of it? Swap in
- Potato starch, same amountThickens at a lower temperature and turns stringy if boiled hard. The Passover choice.
- Flour, twice the amountOpaque instead of glossy, and must cook a few minutes to lose the raw taste.
- Arrowroot or tapioca starch, about the sameClearer and better with acid; arrowroot turns slimy with dairy.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne box lasts most kitchens a year.
Nana's tip: Always whisk it into cold liquid first (a slurry), then into the hot pot, and bring it to a full boil for a moment. It thickens only near boiling and stays chalky if you don't.
Thickens pudding, pastry cream and fruit pie fillings, and a spoonful makes cookies softer and cakes more tender. Homemade cake flour: 1 cup all-purpose minus 2 Tbsp, plus 2 Tbsp cornstarch.
Cocoa powder
Also called unsweetened cocoa
- What it is
- Roasted cacao beans ground into a paste, pressed to remove most of the cocoa butter, and powdered. Unsweetened.
- Tastes like
- Intensely chocolatey and bitter; natural is fruity and sharp, Dutch-process is mellow, earthy and darker.
- Use it for
- Brownies, chocolate cakes, cookies, hot cocoa, chocolate babka filling, dusting truffles and tiramisu.
The kinds you'll see
- Natural — Light brown, acidic (pH about 5–6). Reacts with baking soda. Most American recipes assume it.
- Dutch-process (alkalized) — Treated to neutralize acid (pH about 7–8). Darker, smoother; pairs with baking powder.
- Black cocoa — Heavily alkalized. Oreo-black and dry-tasting; blend a little with Dutch.
Out of it? Swap in
- 1 ounce (28 g) unsweetened chocolate per 3 tablespoons cocoa, minus 1 tablespoon fatWorks in brownies and cakes.
- The other kind of cocoaFree swap if the recipe uses baking powder only. If it relies on baking soda, stick to what it says or the rise and color change.
Diet & allergens
BuyingThe label tells you which kind. "Dutch-process," "alkalized" or "processed with alkali" means Dutch; otherwise it's natural.
Nana's tip: Bloom cocoa by whisking it into the recipe's hot liquid or melted butter first; the heat releases far more chocolate flavor.
Natural cocoa is acidic and pairs with baking soda; Dutch-process is neutralized, darker and smoother, and pairs with baking powder. Use what the recipe says. Chocolate & Cocoa explains.
Dark chocolate
Also called bittersweet chocolate, semisweet chocolate
- What it is
- Chocolate liquor (ground cacao), cocoa butter and sugar. The percentage is how much of the bar comes from the cacao bean.
- Tastes like
- Deep, bitter-sweet and fruity or earthy depending on the bean; higher percentage means less sugar and more bitterness.
- Use it for
- Ganache, brownies, mousse, chocolate cake, dipping, cookies, hot chocolate.
The kinds you'll see
- Semisweet (about 50–60%) — Sweeter, crowd-pleasing. Most chips.
- Bittersweet (about 60–72%) — The baker's sweet spot. Buy 60–70% bars for most recipes.
- Extra-dark (75–90%) — For eating, or when a recipe asks; it can make baked goods dry and bitter.
- Unsweetened (100%) — Baking chocolate. No sugar at all.
- Chips — Lower in cocoa butter, often with stabilizers, so they hold their shape in cookies. Poor for melting.
Out of it? Swap in
- 1 ounce unsweetened chocolate plus 1 tablespoon sugarApproximates 1 ounce semisweet.
- 3 tablespoons cocoa powder plus 1 tablespoon oil or butter plus 1 tablespoon sugarStands in for 1 ounce semisweet in baking, not for ganache or dipping.
Diet & allergens
BuyingBars, not chips, for melting. Check the percentage, and for parve if you'll serve it after meat.
Nana's tip: Chop it fine with a serrated knife; small, even pieces melt evenly before any of it overheats.
Bars or chips, 60–70% cacao, for cookies, brownies and ganache. Check the label: much chocolate is dairy or made on dairy equipment, which matters after a meat meal.
Yeast
Also called baker's yeast
- What it is
- Living single-celled fungi that eat sugars in dough and give off carbon dioxide and alcohol, which raise and flavor bread.
- Tastes like
- Raw, it smells beery and a little sour; baked into bread, it gives that warm, wheaty, slightly fermented flavor.
- Use it for
- Challah, sandwich bread, pizza and focaccia, rolls, babka, cinnamon buns, doughnuts.
The kinds you'll see
- Instant (rapid-rise, bread machine) — Fine granules you mix straight into flour, no proofing needed. My everyday pick.
- Active dry — Larger granules; traditionally dissolved in warm water (105–110°F / 40–43°C) for 5–10 minutes first.
- Fresh (cake) yeast — Moist, crumbly blocks from the refrigerated case. Beloved by old-school challah bakers; keeps only about 2 weeks.
Out of it? Swap in
- Active dry for instant, 1:1 (dissolve it in some of the recipe's warm liquid first)Rise may take a little longer.
- Fresh yeast, about 2½ times the weight of dry (one 7-g packet ≈ 17–18 g fresh)Same result; crumble it into the warm liquid.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA 4-oz (113-g) jar of instant yeast is far cheaper than packets if you bake bread even monthly. One packet = 2¼ tsp = 7 g.
Nana's tip: Salt and yeast can touch in the bowl, but water over 130°F (54°C) kills yeast; liquid should feel warm, not hot, on your wrist.
Only if you bake bread: challah, pizza, focaccia, babka. Instant yeast in a jar in the freezer is cheaper than packets and lasts a year.
Bread flour
Also called strong flour, high-gluten flour
- What it is
- White flour milled from hard wheat, about 12 to 14 percent protein, so it forms more gluten.
- Tastes like
- Like all-purpose flour, but bakes up chewier with a crisper crust.
- Use it for
- Yeast breads, pizza, bagels, challah with real pull, and chewy cookies.
Out of it? Swap in
- All-purpose flour, same weightSlightly softer, less rise. Challah and sandwich loaves come out fine.
- All-purpose flour plus vital wheat glutenAbout 1 1/2 teaspoons gluten per cup brings AP close to bread flour.
Diet & allergens
BuyingWorth having only if you make bread or pizza often.
Nana's tip: Hydrate bread-flour doughs a little more than AP doughs; the extra protein drinks up more water.
More protein, more gluten, chewier crumb. Worth it once you bake challah or pizza often. All-purpose works in a pinch.
Honey
Also called raw honey
- What it is
- Nectar concentrated by bees into a thick syrup, mostly fructose and glucose with about 17 percent water. Flavor depends on the flowers.
- Tastes like
- Floral and rounded. Clover is mild; wildflower is fuller; buckwheat is dark, malty and almost molasses-like.
- Use it for
- Honey cake and Rosh Hashanah baking, glazes and marinades, dressings, tea, and drizzling on cheese, yogurt or challah.
The kinds you'll see
- Liquid (clover, orange blossom, wildflower) — The everyday kind for cooking and baking.
- Creamed or whipped — Crystallized on purpose into a spread. For toast, not for measuring.
- Raw — Strained but not heated. Crystallizes faster. Save it for drizzling, where its aroma shows.
Out of it? Swap in
- Maple syrup, same amountThinner, less sweet, with a different flavor.
- Silan (date syrup)Darker and fruitier. Traditional on Rosh Hashanah in many Sephardi homes.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA mild clover or wildflower for baking; a small jar of something special for the table.
Nana's tip: Oil or spray your measuring cup first and the honey slides right out. Crystallized honey melts back in a bowl of warm water.
Moist, fragrant cakes (honey cake for Rosh Hashanah), glazes, granola. It browns faster than sugar, so bake honey cakes a little lower.
Buttermilk
Also called cultured buttermilk
- What it is
- Today's buttermilk is low-fat milk cultured with bacteria until thick and tangy (it used to be the liquid left from churning butter).
- Tastes like
- Tangy and sour, like thin yogurt.
- Use it for
- Pancakes, biscuits, soda bread, cakes, ranch dressing, marinating chicken.
Out of it? Swap in
- 1 cup milk plus 1 tablespoon lemon juice or vinegar, rested 5 minutesThe classic. Right acidity for baking soda, thinner and less tangy.
- ¾ cup plain yogurt plus ¼ cup milkThicker and tangier; the closest in flavor.
Diet & allergens
BuyingFull-fat if you can find it; it makes richer biscuits.
Nana's tip: Its acid is what makes baking soda rise in a recipe; don't swap in plain milk without adding acid.
Tender, tangy pancakes, biscuits and cakes, working with baking soda. No buttermilk? 1 Tbsp lemon juice or vinegar plus milk to make 1 cup, rested 5 minutes.
Parve margarine & plant-based butter
Also called pareve margarine, vegan butter, nondairy margarine
- What it is
- A spreadable fat made from vegetable oils and water, made without milk so it can go into meat meals and parve baking.
- Tastes like
- Neutral to mildly buttery, depending on the brand. None taste quite like real butter.
- Use it for
- Pie crusts, cookies, cakes and kugels for a meat meal, sautéing where you want a butter flavor, and spreading on challah at a meat dinner.
The kinds you'll see
- Sticks (baking margarine) — About 80% fat, close to butter. The one to bake with.
- Tubs and spreads — More water and air, sometimes as little as 40% fat. Fine for toast; makes cookies spread and pastry soggy.
- Plant-based butter sticks — Usually blends of coconut, palm and other oils. Behave most like butter in baking; check for a parve hechsher.
Out of it? Swap in
- Refined coconut oilFirm and flaky in crusts, but sets harder when cold and melts faster. Use about 20% less.
- Neutral oil (3/4 cup for each 1 cup margarine)Fine in cakes and muffins; won't cream or make flaky pastry.
Diet & allergens
BuyingSticks with a clear parve symbol and at least 80% fat (check that it's sold as margarine, not "spread").
Nana's tip: For pie crust, cut the sticks into cubes and freeze them for 15 minutes first. Margarine softens faster than butter, and cold fat is what makes flakes.
For kosher bakers who need a parve pastry or cookie dough with a butter-like texture. Stick margarine, not tub, for baking.
Splurges and specialties
- Cake flour for tall, fine-crumbed layer and chiffon cakes.
- Whole wheat flour (or white whole wheat) to swap in for up to a third of the flour in muffins and breads.
- Vanilla bean paste for ice cream and custards, where you’d see the specks.
- Molasses for gingerbread and to make your own brown sugar (1 Tbsp per cup of white sugar for light, 2 for dark).
- Maple syrup, pure, grade A dark, for glazes and pies.
- Almond flour for gluten-free and Passover baking. Keep it in the freezer; it goes rancid fast.
- Good chocolate in bars (rather than chips) for melting; chips contain stabilizers to keep their shape, so they melt less smoothly.
How much to buy
| Item | Keep on hand | Freshness window once opened |
|---|---|---|
| All-purpose flour | 5 lb (2.3 kg) | 6–8 months cupboard, 1 year+ frozen |
| Bread / whole-wheat flour | 2–5 lb | Whole-wheat 3 months cupboard, 6 months frozen |
| Granulated sugar | 4 lb (1.8 kg) | Indefinitely, if dry |
| Brown sugar | 2 lb (900 g) | Indefinitely, if kept soft |
| Powdered sugar | 1–2 lb | Indefinitely, if dry |
| Baking powder | 1 small can | 6–12 months |
| Baking soda | 1 small box | About 6 months for best rise |
| Yeast (instant) | 1 jar | 4 months fridge, longer frozen |
| Vanilla extract | 4 oz (118 ml) | Years |
| Butter | 2 lb (900 g) | 2–3 months fridge (check date), 6+ months frozen |
| Eggs | 1–2 dozen | 3–5 weeks fridge |
How to store it all
- Flour goes in an airtight container with a wide mouth so you can scoop and level. Whole-grain flours, nut flours and cornmeal go in the freezer, because their natural oils go rancid at room temperature. Bring frozen flour to room temperature before baking delicate cakes.
- Brown sugar dries into a brick when air gets in. Store it in an airtight container with a strip of bread or a terra-cotta sugar saver. Already hard? Microwave it with a damp paper towel for 20–30 seconds, or seal it overnight with a slice of bread.
- Leaveners stay closed tight, away from the stove’s steam. Write the opening date on the lid with a marker.
- Chocolate in a cool, dry cupboard, wrapped, not in the fridge, where it picks up odors and can develop a gray bloom. Bloom looks odd but is safe to bake with.
- Butter in its wrapper, in the back of the fridge (not the door, which is warmer), or in the freezer.
- Eggs in their carton on a fridge shelf, not the door.
Food safety
Raw flour and raw eggs can carry harmful bacteria, so don’t taste raw cookie dough or cake batter. Flour is a raw agricultural product; the FDA says it only becomes safe once it’s baked or cooked. Keep raw dough away from ready-to-eat food, wash hands and bowls after handling it, and refrigerate eggs at 40°F (4°C) or below. Egg-based fillings and custards should reach 160°F (71°C).
Shopping strategy
- Buy a scale first. It’s the best baking tool you can own. Most recipes on the site give cups, but 1 cup of all-purpose flour is about 125 g when spooned and leveled, and up to 150 g when scooped, which is enough to turn a moist cake dry.
- Buy leaveners small and replace them twice a year whether they’re empty or not. They’re cheap; a flat cake isn’t.
- Buy flour and sugar big if you bake weekly. They’re the bulk of every recipe and keep well.
- Spend on butter, chocolate and vanilla. They’re what you taste. Generic flour, sugar and leaveners are fine.
- Stock up before the holidays. Flour, sugar, honey and chocolate fly off the shelves before Rosh Hashanah, Hanukkah and Thanksgiving.
What to skip
- Self-rising flour. It’s all-purpose flour with baking powder and salt mixed in, so you can’t control either, and the powder goes stale in the bag. Make it when a recipe needs it: 1 cup flour + 1½ tsp baking powder + ¼ tsp salt.
- Cake mix “enhancers” and pudding-in-the-mix products. The basics do the same job better.
- Salted butter for baking. Salt content varies by brand and you can’t take it out.
- Imitation butter flavoring. Use real butter, or a good parve margarine if you need parve.
- Giant tubs of sprinkles and colored sugars. They fade and clump. Buy small for the occasion.
Kosher note
A kosher baking shelf has a few extra considerations. Many bakers keep parve ingredients (oil, margarine, nondairy creamer, parve chocolate) so a dessert can follow a meat meal; see Building a Kosher Pantry. Many observant cooks sift or check flour for insects before use. When a dough uses a large amount of flour, many follow the custom of separating challah (setting aside a small piece of dough); the amount of flour that triggers it, and whether a blessing is said, depends on the measure your community follows — commonly cited thresholds are roughly 2½ lb (1.2 kg) of flour without a blessing and somewhere between about 3¾ and 5 lb (1.7–2.25 kg) with one. Ask your rabbi.
Passover note
The baking shelf changes most at Passover. Flour and yeast are put away. Regular baking powder contains cornstarch, which most Ashkenazim treat as kitniyot; kosher-for-Passover baking powder uses potato starch. Vanilla extract may be made with grain alcohol, so buy a Passover-certified extract or vanilla sugar. Passover baking leans on matzo cake meal, Potato starch, almond flour and whipped eggs. Customs vary; follow your family’s and see The Passover Kitchen.
Bake from the shelf
The brown sugar and vanilla on this shelf show up in hundreds of the site’s recipes. Start with these.