Pantry Guides

The Spice Drawer

The short version

Twelve fresh spices you actually use beat forty stale ones; buy small, store them cool and dark, bloom them in fat, and replace them about once a year.

Beginner 8 min read ✓ Reviewed November 2026

The Spice Drawer
Photo: Hey Paul Studios, CC BY 2.0 · Flickr

You don’t need a wall of jars. About a dozen spices cover most of what home cooks make, from roast chicken and chili to curry, shakshuka and apple cake. What matters far more than the number is freshness: a spice that’s lost its smell adds color and nothing else. Buy small, store well, and use them up.

Spices are dried seeds, bark, roots, berries and fruits. Dried leafy herbs like oregano and bay live in the same drawer, so they’re here too; fresh ones are in Fresh Herbs. Salt has its own guide: Salt: Kosher, Table, Flaky & Sea.

The core twelve

If you’re starting from nothing, buy these, roughly in this order. Together they cover American, Mediterranean, Middle Eastern, Mexican and a good part of Indian cooking.

Rank Spice Buy it What it does most
1 Black pepper Whole, with a grinder Everything savory
2 Cumin Ground (whole if you cook Indian food) Earthy depth: chili, hummus, curries
3 Red pepper flakes Flakes Heat for pasta, greens, pizza
4 Sweet paprika Ground, Hungarian Color and sweet pepper flavor
5 Smoked paprika Ground, Spanish Smoke without a grill
6 Cinnamon Ground + a few sticks Baking, and warmth in savory stews
7 Dried oregano Crumbled leaf Tomato sauce, Greek and Mexican food
8 Garlic powder Granulated Rubs, breading, quick savory depth
9 Bay leaves Whole leaves Background depth in soups and braises
10 Chili powder US blend Chili, tacos, rubs
11 Cayenne Ground Clean heat in small doses
12 Coriander Whole seed (grind as needed) Lemony warmth; cumin’s partner

Next in line: Turmeric, Nutmeg (whole), and Cardamom. If you cook Middle Eastern food, add Za'atar, Sumac and Aleppo pepper; the The Mediterranean & Middle Eastern Pantry goes deeper.

The essentials

Black pepper
Photo: Ryan Snyder, CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Black pepper

Also called peppercorns, Tellicherry pepper

Essential
What it is
The dried, unripe berries of a tropical vine, fermented in the sun until black and wrinkled.
Tastes like
Freshly ground, it's hot, piney and a little citrusy; pre-ground pepper tastes mostly of dusty heat.
Use it for
Almost everything savory, plus steak au poivre, cacio e pepe, strawberries, and spice cakes.

The kinds you'll see

  • Whole peppercorns (for a grinder) — The only way to buy it. Ground fresh, it's a different spice.
  • Tellicherry — Larger, riper berries from India; more aromatic. A cheap upgrade.
  • Coarse / cracked — For crusting steak or tuna; crush whole corns under a heavy pan.

Out of it? Swap in

  • White pepperHotter, earthier and invisible in pale food; lacks the fruity aroma.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreWhole, in the grinder or a jar, away from heat.
KeepsWhole about 3 years; ground about 6 months before it fades.
Toss whenGround pepper doesn't make you want to sneeze, or whole corns crack with little aroma.

BuyingA bag of whole Tellicherry peppercorns and a good adjustable grinder. Skip the pre-ground tin.

Nana's tip: Grind it over the finished dish too, not only into the pot; pepper's aroma fades with long cooking.

The single biggest upgrade in most kitchens is switching from a tin of ground pepper to a grinder.

Cumin
Photo: Sanjay Acharya, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Cumin

Also called jeera, kammun

Essential
What it is
The dried seeds of a plant in the parsley family, sold whole or ground.
Tastes like
Warm, earthy, musky and a little bitter; toasted, it turns nutty and smoky.
Use it for
Chili, tacos, hummus and falafel, Moroccan and Middle Eastern stews, curries, lentil soup, roasted carrots and cauliflower.

The kinds you'll see

  • Ground — What most recipes mean. Fades fastest of the everyday spices.
  • Whole seeds — Toast in oil for dal, rice and Indian dishes; grind fresh for the best flavor.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Ground coriander plus a pinch of chili powderLighter and more citrusy; much less earthy.
  • Chili powder (which contains cumin)Adds heat and garlic too; good for chili, wrong for desserts or delicate dishes.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight jar, away from the stove.
KeepsGround 6–12 months; whole about 2 years.
Toss whenRubbed between your fingers, it smells faint instead of strongly earthy.

BuyingGround cumin in a small jar, replaced twice a year; whole seeds if you cook Indian food.

Nana's tip: Bloom ground cumin in the hot oil for 30 seconds before adding liquid; its flavor is oil-soluble and goes from dusty to deep.

Bloomed in oil, it’s the earthy base of chili, falafel, hummus, Moroccan stews and Indian dal.

Red pepper flakes
Photo: Takeaway, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Red pepper flakes

Also called crushed red pepper, chili flakes

Essential
What it is
Dried red chiles (usually a cayenne-type blend) crushed into flakes with their seeds.
Tastes like
Bright, dry heat that builds slowly, with a toasty pepper flavor and little fruit.
Use it for
Pasta (aglio e olio, arrabbiata), pizza, sautéed greens, roasted broccoli, marinades, pickles, a pinch in any soup or stir-fry.

The kinds you'll see

  • Crushed red pepper (pizza-parlor style) — The standard. Medium heat.
  • Aleppo, Urfa, Maraş, gochugaru — Milder, fruitier regional flakes. Worth trying once you know the basic one.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Cayenne, about a third as muchSame heat, no texture; distributes fast.
  • Aleppo pepper, about doubleMilder, fruitier and slightly salty.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight jar away from heat and light.
KeepsAbout 1 year before the heat and color fade.
Toss whenThey've faded from red to brown and taste mostly of dust.

BuyingA small jar. If it has gone brown and listless, it's time.

Nana's tip: Warm the flakes in the oil with the garlic; heat carries capsaicin through the whole dish instead of in hot spots.

Heat with a little texture. Warm them in oil with garlic to spread the heat evenly.

Sweet paprika
Photo: GorissM, CC BY-SA 2.0 · Flickr

Sweet paprika

Also called Hungarian paprika, paprika

Essential
What it is
Mild red peppers, dried and ground. Hungarian paprika comes in grades from delicate to hot.
Tastes like
Sweet, fruity and gently peppery when fresh; stale paprika tastes of nothing but red.
Use it for
Goulash and chicken paprikash, roast chicken and potatoes, deviled eggs, fish, rubs and color for nearly anything.

The kinds you'll see

  • Hungarian sweet (édesnemes) — The best all-purpose paprika; rich and fruity.
  • Supermarket "paprika" — Usually mild and mostly for color. Fine on deviled eggs.
  • Hot Hungarian — The same with real heat.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Smoked paprika, half the amountAdds smoke; can overpower.
  • Aleppo pepper or mild chili powderFruitier and warmer, with some heat.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight tin away from light and heat; it fades faster than most spices.
KeepsAbout 6 months to a year once opened.
Toss whenIt's turned from bright red to dull brick and smells faint.

BuyingA tin of Hungarian sweet paprika. Buy small; color is your freshness gauge.

Nana's tip: Paprika is sugary and scorches fast; cook it in fat over medium-low heat for 30 seconds at most, then add liquid.

Fresh paprika is fruity and sweet; stale paprika is red dust. Color is the giveaway.

Smoked paprika
Photo: Ljiljana Sundać, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Smoked paprika

Also called pimentón

Essential
What it is
Red peppers dried slowly over oak smoke, then ground to a powder. Spanish in origin.
Tastes like
Smoky, sweet and earthy, like a campfire without the char.
Use it for
Rubs, roasted potatoes, chickpeas and beans, deviled eggs, shakshuka, and anything you'd grill but can't.

The kinds you'll see

  • Sweet (dulce) — The default. No heat.
  • Bittersweet (agridulce) — Slightly bitter and a touch of heat.
  • Hot (picante) — Noticeable cayenne-like heat.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Sweet paprika plus a pinch of cuminRight color, earthy, but no smoke.
  • Chipotle powder, half the amountSmoky, but much hotter.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight tin or jar away from the stove's heat and light.
KeepsAbout 1 year once opened.
Toss whenThe color has gone brick-brown and it smells like dust instead of smoke.

BuyingLook for "Pimentón de la Vera" on a tin. Smaller containers stay fresher.

Nana's tip: Add it off the heat or with liquid; it scorches and turns bitter in seconds in a hot dry pan.

Use it more lightly than sweet paprika; the smoke takes over quickly.

Cinnamon
Photo: trophygeek, CC BY 2.0 · Flickr

Cinnamon

Also called cassia, Ceylon cinnamon

Essential
What it is
The dried inner bark of tropical trees, rolled into quills (sticks) or ground.
Tastes like
Sweet, woody and warm; cassia is strong and spicy-hot, Ceylon is gentler and floral.
Use it for
Apple cake, babka, rugelach, cinnamon rolls, oatmeal, and savory dishes too — tagines, Persian rice, Greek stews, tzimmes, chili.

The kinds you'll see

  • Cassia (most US supermarket cinnamon) — Bold and spicy. What most American baking recipes assume.
  • Ceylon ("true" cinnamon) — Thin, papery layered quills; delicate and citrusy. Lovely in custards and savory dishes.
  • Sticks — Simmer in rice, stews, mulled wine and poaching liquid, then fish out.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Pumpkin pie spice or apple pie spiceMostly cinnamon already, with nutmeg, ginger and clove.
  • Allspice or nutmeg, about a quarter as muchWarm, but a different spice; easy to overdo.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight jar away from heat; sticks keep longer than ground.
KeepsGround about 1 year; sticks 2–3 years.
Toss whenGround cinnamon smells faint and dusty, or sticks don't release aroma when snapped.

BuyingGround cassia for baking; a few sticks for savory cooking. Ceylon if you love it.

Nana's tip: A pinch of cinnamon in a tomato sauce, meat sauce or chili adds warmth nobody can name.

Not only for baking. A pinch in a meat sauce, a stick in a rice pot, a spoon in a tagine.

Dried oregano
Photo: cogdogblog, CC BY 2.0 · Flickr

Dried oregano

Also called Greek oregano, Mexican oregano

Essential
What it is
Leaves of a Mediterranean herb in the mint family, dried and crumbled. One of the few herbs that is as good dried as fresh.
Tastes like
Pungent, peppery and resinous with a warm, slightly bitter edge.
Use it for
Tomato sauce, pizza, Greek salad and chicken, roasted potatoes, beans, vinaigrettes, marinades and chili.

The kinds you'll see

  • Greek / Mediterranean — Bold and earthy. Buy it dried on the stem if you see it.
  • Mexican — A different plant, more citrusy and grassy. For salsa, beans, pozole and chili.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Dried marjoram, a bit moreOregano's gentler, sweeter cousin.
  • Fresh oregano, 3 times as muchBrighter and milder.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight jar away from heat and light.
KeepsAbout 1 year.
Toss whenRubbed between your palms, it gives off little smell and looks grayish.

BuyingGreek oregano in a small jar; add Mexican if you cook Mexican food often.

Nana's tip: Crumble dried oregano between your palms as you add it; it releases the oils and wakes it up.

One of the few dried herbs that tastes as good as (and different from) fresh.

Garlic powder
Photo: oonhs, CC BY 2.0 · Flickr

Garlic powder

Also called granulated garlic

Essential
What it is
Garlic dehydrated and ground fine (powder) or coarser (granulated).
Tastes like
Sweet, toasty, mellow garlic, closer to roasted than raw. Not a replacement for fresh, but its own useful thing.
Use it for
Dry rubs, breading and spice mixes, popcorn, garlic bread, roast potatoes, burgers, dressings, and anywhere fresh garlic would burn or be lumpy.

The kinds you'll see

  • Powder — Fine; dissolves into sauces and dressings.
  • Granulated — Coarser; clumps less and is better in rubs.
  • Garlic salt — Garlic powder mixed with salt. Skip it and season separately.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Fresh garlic, 1 clove per ⅛–¼ tsp powderSharper and more aromatic; will burn in dry rubs.
  • Onion powderDifferent allium, similar savory role.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight jar away from humidity and stove steam, or it cakes solid.
KeepsAbout 1–2 years.
Toss whenIt's hardened into a brick or smells faint.

BuyingGranulated garlic in a medium jar; it's one of the most-used jars in many kitchens (and in a lot of the site's recipes).

Nana's tip: In a dressing or marinade, let garlic powder sit in the liquid for 5 minutes before tasting; it needs moisture to wake up.

Not a fresh-garlic stand-in but its own useful thing: it won’t burn in a rub and blends smoothly into breading.

Bay leaves
Photo: Eljay, CC BY 2.0 · Flickr

Bay leaves

Also called laurel, bay laurel

Essential
What it is
The dried leaves of the bay laurel tree, used whole and removed before serving.
Tastes like
On their own, subtle — herbal, piney and faintly floral. In a pot they add a background depth you notice only when it's missing.
Use it for
Stocks, soups, braises, brisket, beans and lentils, rice, tomato sauce, pickling brine and poaching liquid.

The kinds you'll see

  • Turkish (Mediterranean) bay — The standard dried leaf. Gentle and well-rounded.
  • California bay — A different tree; much stronger and more medicinal. Use half a leaf.

Out of it? Swap in

  • A sprig of dried thymeDifferent flavor, but fills the same background role.
  • Leave it outThe dish will be slightly flatter, but it won't fail.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight jar or bag; the freezer keeps them green.
KeepsAbout 1–2 years.
Toss whenThe leaves are brown and brittle with no smell when crushed.

BuyingTurkish bay leaves in a small jar or bag.

Nana's tip: Always fish them out before serving; the leaves stay stiff and sharp-edged even after hours of cooking.

Drop one into anything that simmers more than 20 minutes. Fish it out before serving.

Chili powder
Photo: timsackton, CC BY-SA 2.0 · Flickr

Chili powder

Also called chile powder

Nice to have
What it is
In the US, a blend of ground mild chiles with cumin, oregano and garlic. "Chile powder" (with an e) or ancho powder is just the ground pepper.
Tastes like
Earthy, warm, mildly hot and savory, like a pot of chili in a jar.
Use it for
Chili, tacos and fajitas, rubs, roasted sweet potatoes, black beans, cornbread and spiced nuts.

The kinds you'll see

  • American chili powder (blend) — Mild and savory. What American recipes mean.
  • Pure ancho / chile powder — Single-chile powder; fruity, raisiny, no cumin. Use it in place of the blend and add your own cumin and oregano.
  • Chipotle powder — Smoked jalapeño; hot and smoky.

Out of it? Swap in

  • 2 tsp sweet paprika + 1 tsp cumin + ½ tsp oregano + ½ tsp garlic powder + pinch of cayenne (per Tbsp-ish)Close to the blend; adjust the cayenne to taste.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight jar away from heat and light.
KeepsAbout 1 year.
Toss whenIt's dull brown and smells weak.

BuyingOne jar of a good blend, or ancho powder if you'd rather season it yourself.

Nana's tip: Indian recipes that say "chili powder" mean hot ground red chile, not the American blend; use cayenne or Kashmiri chile powder.

In American recipes, a blend. In Indian recipes, plain hot chile. Check which one the recipe means.

Cayenne
Photo: yeowatzup, CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Cayenne

Also called cayenne pepper, ground red pepper

Essential
What it is
Hot red chiles dried and ground to a fine powder.
Tastes like
Clean, sharp, fast heat with little other flavor.
Use it for
Adding heat without changing flavor much — cheese sauces, deviled eggs, rubs, soups, dressings, chili, Cajun dishes.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Hot sauce, a few dashesAdds vinegar and liquid along with the heat.
  • Red pepper flakes, about 3 times as muchSame heat with visible flakes and slower bloom.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight jar away from heat and light.
KeepsAbout 1–2 years; it keeps its heat longer than its color.
Toss whenIt smells of nothing and has dulled to orange-brown.

BuyingThe smallest jar; a pinch at a time.

Nana's tip: Start with ⅛ tsp in a whole pot; heat grows as a dish sits, and you can always add more.

Pure heat. Start with ⅛ tsp.

Coriander seed
Photo: yoppy, CC BY 2.0 · Flickr

Coriander seed

Also called ground coriander, dhania

Nice to have
What it is
The dried, round seeds of the cilantro plant. (In British recipes, "coriander" can mean the fresh leaves too.)
Tastes like
Lemony, floral and gently warm; nothing like the leaves.
Use it for
Curries, falafel, Middle Eastern and North African dishes, rubs for chicken and fish, pickles, rye bread, sausage.

The kinds you'll see

  • Ground — Easy and common; fades in months.
  • Whole seeds — Toast and crush them fresh; they're easy to grind and taste far better.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Ground cumin, about half as muchEarthier and stronger; loses the citrus.
  • Caraway or fennel seed, lessDifferent aromas, but a similar warm-seed role.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight jar away from heat and light.
KeepsGround about 6 months; whole 2–3 years.
Toss whenThe ground spice smells faint rather than lemony.

BuyingWhole seeds plus a cheap spice grinder or mortar; they're the easiest whole spice to grind.

Nana's tip: Coriander and cumin are the classic pair; equal parts toasted and ground is the base of countless spice blends.

Buy it whole; coriander seeds are soft and crush easily even in a mortar.

Nice to have

Turmeric
Photo: Simon A. Eugster, CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Turmeric

Also called haldi

Nice to have
What it is
A rhizome in the ginger family, boiled, dried and ground into a vivid yellow powder.
Tastes like
Earthy, mustardy and slightly bitter, with a peppery warmth. Mostly a background flavor and a powerful color.
Use it for
Curries and dal, yellow rice, Yemenite soup, chicken soup (a pinch for color), lentils, scrambled tofu, pickles, hawaij blends.

The kinds you'll see

  • Ground — The everyday form.
  • Fresh root — Brighter and more gingery; grate it like ginger. Stains everything.

Out of it? Swap in

  • A pinch of saffron (for color in rice)Gives color with a very different, much pricier flavor.
  • Curry powder, which contains turmericAdds a full spice blend, not just color.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight jar away from light; it fades in sun.
KeepsAbout 1–2 years.
Toss whenIt's lost its golden color and smells chalky.

BuyingA small jar of ground.

Nana's tip: Cook it briefly in fat to take away its raw, dusty taste, and keep a damp cloth handy; it stains counters, wooden spoons and fingers bright yellow.

Color and an earthy background. A pinch turns chicken soup golden; a spoonful anchors a curry.

Nutmeg
Photo: katerha, CC BY 2.0 · Flickr

Nutmeg

Also called mace

Nice to have
What it is
The hard seed of a tropical evergreen. Its lacy red covering is sold separately as mace.
Tastes like
Sweet, warm and woody with a slightly piney, almost resinous edge; freshly grated it's far brighter.
Use it for
Béchamel and cream sauces, spinach, mashed potatoes and squash, eggnog, custards, pumpkin pie and spice cakes, kugel.

The kinds you'll see

  • Whole nutmeg — Grate on a rasp as you need it. One nut lasts a year.
  • Ground — Convenient; loses its top notes in months.
  • Mace — Gentler and more delicate; lovely in pound cake and cream sauces.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Mace, same amountSofter and more floral; very close.
  • Allspice or cinnamon, lessWarm, but louder and different.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreWhole nuts in a small jar; ground in an airtight jar away from heat.
KeepsWhole for years; ground about 6 months.
Toss whenGrated, it smells weak; ground, it smells of nothing.

BuyingA jar of whole nutmegs and a fine rasp grater. Skip ground.

Nana's tip: Use a light hand; a few gratings is usually enough, and too much turns a dish bitter and medicinal.

Buy whole and grate it. Ground nutmeg loses most of what makes it worth using.

Cardamom
Photo: Veganbaking.net, CC BY-SA 2.0 · Flickr

Cardamom

Also called hel, hil, elaichi

Nice to have
What it is
Small green pods from a ginger-family plant, each holding sticky black seeds. Sold as whole pods or ground seed.
Tastes like
Intensely aromatic — floral, citrusy, minty and a little like eucalyptus.
Use it for
Arabic and Yemenite coffee, chai, Scandinavian buns, rice pudding, Indian rice and curries, hawaij, babka and holiday cakes.

The kinds you'll see

  • Green pods — The standard. Crack and simmer whole, or remove the seeds and grind.
  • Ground — Convenient, but loses its perfume faster than almost any spice.
  • Black cardamom — Large, smoky and camphor-like; for savory Indian dishes only.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Cinnamon plus a little nutmeg or gingerWarm, but misses cardamom's floral top notes.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StorePods in an airtight jar away from heat.
KeepsPods 1–2 years; ground about 6 months.
Toss whenCrushed pods smell faint and the seeds are pale gray instead of dark and oily.

BuyingGreen pods. It's one spice where grinding your own is clearly worth it. Expect to pay more than for most spices.

Nana's tip: Ten pods give roughly ½ tsp ground seed; crack them with the flat of a knife and rub the seeds out.

The most perfumed spice on the shelf. Essential for Arabic and Yemenite coffee, chai and many holiday bakes.

White pepper
Photo: Fumikas Sagisavas, CC0 · Wikimedia Commons
Nice to have
What it is
The same berries as black pepper, picked riper, soaked so the dark outer skin can be removed, then dried.
Tastes like
Sharper and hotter up front, earthy and a little funky, with less of black pepper's fruity aroma.
Use it for
Chinese soups and stir-fries, mashed potatoes, cream sauces, gefilte fish, white fish and anywhere black flecks would look out of place.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Black pepper, a bit lessFruitier and visible; fine for flavor.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreAirtight jar, away from heat and light.
KeepsGround about 6 months; whole 2–3 years.
Toss whenIt smells faint and dusty rather than sharp.

BuyingThe smallest jar of ground, or whole for a second grinder. You won't use much.

Nana's tip: A pinch goes a long way, and its farmy note grows with long cooking; add it near the end.

For pale sauces, mashed potatoes, gefilte fish and Chinese soups, where its earthy heat belongs.

Whole vs. ground

Whole spices keep their flavor for years; ground ones fade in months.
Whole spices keep their flavor for years; ground ones fade in months.Photo: Friedrich Haag, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Ground spices have far more surface exposed to air, so their aromatic oils escape much faster. Whole spices keep their flavor two to three times longer, and grinding them fresh gives you a noticeably brighter, more complex flavor.

Whole Ground
Keeps its flavor 2–4 years 6–12 months
Flavor Brighter, more layered, especially toasted Convenient; flattens with time
Best for Pepper, nutmeg, coriander, cumin, cardamom, cinnamon sticks, cloves Paprika, cayenne, turmeric, garlic powder, chili powder, ground ginger
Effort Needs a grinder or mortar Ready to measure

Buy whole for black pepper (always), nutmeg (always), and coriander and cardamom if you’re willing to grind. Buy ground for paprikas, chiles, turmeric and garlic powder, which are hard to grind at home and sold ground everywhere.

Nana's tip

A cheap blade coffee grinder kept only for spices is the best $20 you’ll spend on this drawer. Clean it by grinding a spoonful of raw rice or a torn slice of bread, then wipe it out.

Converting whole to ground

For small seeds like cumin and coriander, treat whole and freshly ground as roughly 1:1 by volume, then taste; fresh-ground is stronger, so start a little under. One cinnamon stick (3 in / 7.5 cm) is about ½ tsp ground for flavor; 10 cardamom pods give about ½ tsp ground seed; one whole nutmeg grates to roughly 2–3 tsp.

How to use spices well

Grinding whole spices just before cooking gives the most aroma.
Grinding whole spices just before cooking gives the most aroma.Photo: SammyJayJay, CC BY 2.0 · Flickr
  1. Bloom in fat. Most spice flavors dissolve in fat, not water. Stir ground spices into the hot oil for 20–60 seconds, until fragrant, before adding liquid or vegetables. See Blooming Spices & Toasting Nuts.
  2. Toast whole spices dry. In a dry skillet over medium heat, 1–3 minutes, shaking, until they smell toasty and darken a shade. Cool, then grind. Toasting builds new nutty flavors through browning.
  3. Watch the sugary ones. Paprika, chili powder and garlic powder burn in seconds in a hot, dry pan and turn bitter. Add them with oil over medium heat, or with liquid.
  4. Layer. Some at the start (bloomed, for depth), a pinch at the end (for aroma). This is especially good with pepper, cumin and smoked paprika.
  5. Measure away from the steam. Shaking a jar over a boiling pot lets steam into the jar, which cakes and stales the rest.
  6. Taste, then adjust. Dried spice intensity varies by brand and age. If a dish tastes flat, it more often needs salt or acid than more spice; see Too Salty, Spicy, Sweet or Sour?.

How to store and refresh

Heat, light, air and moisture are what fade spices. So:

  • Keep them away from the stove. The rack above the range is the worst spot in the kitchen; heat and steam rise there all day. A drawer or a cupboard away from the oven is best.
  • Use airtight jars, opaque or in the dark. Clear jars are fine in a closed drawer or cupboard. Shut the lids tightly.
  • Label every jar with the date you opened it. Masking tape and a marker.
  • Don’t refrigerate. Taking jars in and out lets condensation in. The freezer is fine for long-term backup of whole spices in a sealed bag.
  • Buy small, from a busy shop. A store that sells lots of spices turns over its stock; a tiny jar you finish in six months beats a giant one at a bargain price.

The once-a-year check

Pick a date (many people do it before Rosh Hashanah or New Year’s) and go through the drawer:

  1. Look. Faded color (brick-brown paprika, pale turmeric, grayish oregano) means faded flavor.
  2. Smell. Rub a pinch between your fingers. If the aroma doesn’t come right up, it’s done.
  3. Toss anything past its window: most ground spices after a year, whole spices after 2–4 years, anything clumped from moisture or with any sign of bugs.
  4. Make a list of what you used up fastest and buy those in larger jars next time.

Old spices aren’t harmful, just weak. If you must use them, use more and bloom them well.

Blends: buy or make?

Some blends are better bought; some are better made, because you can control the salt and freshness. Here’s my ranking.

Blend Verdict Why
Chili powder Buy (or make) A good jar is cheap and balanced. Make it if you want to control heat and salt.
Za'atar Buy a good one Proper za’atar uses wild thyme-family herbs that are hard to find; good Israeli or Lebanese brands are excellent.
Baharat Either Easy to make from what’s in the drawer: pepper, cumin, coriander, cinnamon, cardamom, nutmeg, clove, paprika.
Curry powder Buy A dozen ingredients; a decent brand is better than a half-hearted homemade one.
Garam masala Make, if you can It’s best made small and toasted fresh; jars fade fast.
Hawaij (Yemenite) Make Soup hawaij is mostly cumin, turmeric, black pepper and cardamom; coffee hawaij is ginger, cardamom and cinnamon. Ten minutes.
Pumpkin pie / apple pie spice Make It’s cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, allspice and clove you already own.
Italian seasoning, herbes de Provence Skip or make Mostly dried oregano, thyme and basil. Use your oregano plus whatever you have.
Everything bagel seasoning Buy Cheap, and the dried garlic and onion bits are hard to make crunchy at home.
Seasoned salt, garlic salt, lemon pepper Skip You’re paying for salt. Season separately.
Chinese five-spice Buy Star anise and Sichuan pepper aren’t worth stocking just for this.

Nana's tip

Quick taco seasoning for 1 lb (450 g) of meat or beans: 1 Tbsp chili powder, 1 tsp cumin, 1 tsp smoked paprika, ½ tsp garlic powder, ½ tsp dried oregano, ¾ tsp kosher salt, pinch of cayenne.

Splurges

  • Saffron. A few threads perfume rice, fish stew or a Shabbat chicken. Buy threads, never powder, which is easy to adulterate. Truffle, Caviar & Saffron: Worth It? covers it.
  • Single-origin peppercorns or Tellicherry, and a really good grinder.
  • Aleppo pepper, Urfa and Maraş chile flakes for fruity, gentle heat.
  • Vanilla beans belong on the The Baking Shelf, but they’re the other spice worth spending on.

What to skip

  • Pre-ground black pepper. Always buy whole.
  • Ground nutmeg. Whole lasts for years and grates in seconds.
  • Giant warehouse jars of anything you don’t use weekly.
  • Dried parsley, chives and cilantro. They taste of hay. Buy fresh or leave them out.
  • The spice rack sold already filled. You’ll get stale spices you’ll never use. Build your own drawer from this list.

Kosher note

Spices are parve, but buy them with a reliable hechsher. Ground spices and blends can contain additives and anti-caking agents, and some dried peppers and herbs are prone to insects. At Passover, buy spices certified kosher for Passover. Some seeds, like mustard, sesame and (by some opinions) cumin and coriander, are treated as kitniyot by many Ashkenazim, while Sephardim generally use them; customs vary, so follow your family’s and ask your rabbi. See Building a Kosher Pantry and The Passover Kitchen.

Cook from the drawer

Smoked paprika and cumin show up across the site’s recipes. Here are some to try.

Try it: recipes with smoked paprika

See all →

Try it: recipes with cumin

See all →

Sources