Fresh herbs come in two kinds, and almost every rule follows from which kind you’re holding. Tender herbs (soft stems, delicate leaves) are fragile, best raw, and added at the end. Woody herbs (stiff stems, tough leaves) are sturdy, need heat to open up, and go in early.
The herbs at a glance
| Herb | Kind | Flavor | Add it | Store | Dries well? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Parsley (flat-leaf) | Tender | Fresh, green, peppery | End, or raw | Jar of water, fridge | No |
| Cilantro | Tender | Citrusy, bright | End, or raw | Jar of water, fridge | No |
| Basil | Tender | Sweet, clove, anise | Very end, or raw | Jar of water, counter | No |
| Dill | Tender | Grassy, tangy, anise | End | Jar of water or damp towel, fridge | Fair |
| Mint | Tender | Cool, sweet | End, or raw | Jar of water, fridge | Yes, good |
| Chives | Tender | Mild onion | Raw, to finish | Damp towel, fridge | No |
| Tarragon | Tender | Licorice, sweet | End | Damp towel, fridge | Fair |
| Thyme | Woody | Earthy, lemony | Early | Damp towel, fridge | Yes, good |
| Rosemary | Woody | Piney, resinous | Early | Damp towel, fridge | Fair |
| Oregano | Woody | Pungent, earthy | Early (fresh) or anytime (dried) | Damp towel, fridge | Yes, better dried |
| Sage | Woody | Musky, savory | Early, or fried crisp | Damp towel, fridge | Yes |
| Bay | Woody | Tea-like, herbal | Start of cooking | Dried, in a jar | Yes, usually used dried |
The three to buy first: flat-leaf parsley, cilantro (if your household likes it) and thyme. Grow basil, mint and rosemary in pots if you can; they’re cheaper and better that way.
Tender vs. woody: when to add them
Tender herbs carry their flavor in fragile aromatic oils that heat drives off in minutes. Chop them just before using and add them:
- raw, in salads, salsas, dressings and sauces (tabbouleh, chimichurri, pesto, zhoug, salsa verde);
- off the heat, stirred into soups, stews, pasta and rice at the last moment;
- as a big handful over the finished plate.
Woody herbs have tougher leaves and oils locked into sturdier cells; they need time and heat (or fat) to release them. Add them:
- at the start of a braise, roast, soup or sauce, as whole sprigs you fish out later (see Braising);
- to the oil or butter early on, so the fat carries the flavor through the dish;
- in rubs and marinades.
Why parsley stems go into soup but basil leaves don't
Parsley, cilantro and dill stems are full of flavor and stand up to simmering, so tie them into a bundle and drop them in early, then add the chopped leaves at the end. Basil and mint leaves turn black and taste cooked within a minute or two in hot liquid, so they always go in last.
How to store them
Most herbs die from one of two things: drying out, or rotting in trapped moisture. Pick the method by kind.
Tender herbs: like flowers
- Untie the bunch, pick out any slimy or yellow stems.
- Trim a half inch off the stems.
- Stand them in a jar with an inch or two of water.
- Cover loosely with a plastic bag (a produce bag is fine) and put the jar in the fridge.
- Change the water every couple of days.
Parsley and cilantro keep 1–2 weeks this way, often more.
Basil is the exception: keep the jar on the counter, out of direct sun. Basil is damaged by cold (below about 50°F / 10°C) and goes black in the fridge within a day or two.
Woody herbs: a damp towel
Wrap thyme, rosemary, sage and oregano loosely in a barely damp paper towel, then put them in a zip-top bag or container in the fridge. They keep 2–3 weeks. Too wet and they mold; too dry and they crisp up (which is fine; then they’re dried herbs).
Chives and tarragon, tender but thin, do best in a damp towel too.
Freezing
- Chopped tender herbs (parsley, cilantro, dill): freeze in ice cube trays covered with olive oil or water. Drop a cube into soup or a sauce.
- Woody herbs: freeze whole sprigs in a bag; the leaves strip off easily frozen.
- Frozen herbs are for cooking, not garnish; they turn limp.
Dried vs. fresh: the ratio
1 teaspoon dried = 1 tablespoon fresh (a 1:3 ratio), because drying removes the water and concentrates what’s left.
That ratio works well for herbs that dry well: thyme, oregano, rosemary, sage, mint, dill (in dips and dressings), and bay. For parsley, cilantro, basil and chives, the dried versions taste like little more than green dust, so no ratio can make them a real substitute. Use a different fresh herb instead, or leave it out.
Tips for dried herbs:
- Add them early in cooking, so they have time to rehydrate and release flavor.
- Crumble them between your palms as they go in, to wake up the oils.
- Replace them every year. Dried herbs that smell of nothing add nothing. See The Spice Drawer.
Prepping herbs
- Wash, then dry thoroughly. A salad spinner is ideal. Wet herbs bruise and turn to paste when you chop them, and they water down dressings.
- Pick or strip. Pull tender leaves off thick stems; for thyme and rosemary, pinch the top of the sprig and run your fingers down against the direction of growth.
- Use a sharp knife. A dull one crushes herbs and blackens them. Chop with a rocking motion and don’t go back over the pile too many times.
- Chiffonade for basil and mint: stack the leaves, roll them tightly like a cigar, and slice across into thin ribbons.
- Chop just before serving. Cut herbs start to darken and lose aroma within half an hour.
The variants
Parsley
Parsley
Also called flat-leaf parsley, Italian parsley
- What it is
- The most useful tender herb. Flat-leaf (Italian) is the cook's choice; curly is milder and mostly garnish.
- Tastes like
- Fresh, green and lightly peppery, a clean bitterness that wakes up rich food.
- Use it for
- Tabbouleh, chimichurri, gremolata, salsa verde, chicken soup, fish, meatballs, and a handful over almost anything at the end.
The kinds you'll see
- Flat-leaf (Italian) — More flavor and easier to chop. Buy this one.
- Curly — Milder, sturdier, crunchier. Fine in tabbouleh, but very hard to check for insects.
Out of it? Swap in
- CilantroSame freshness, very different perfume. Only if the dish can take it.
- Celery leavesA good stand-in for flavor in soups and salads.
Diet & allergens
BuyingPerky, deep green, no yellowing or wet patches in the middle of the bunch.
Nana's tip: Chop the tender upper stems with the leaves; they have plenty of flavor. Save tough lower stems for stock.
The herb Nana uses most. Its clean, slightly bitter freshness cuts through rich food: a fistful of chopped parsley over a stew, chicken soup or roast makes it taste lighter and brighter. Buy flat-leaf.
Cilantro
Cilantro
Also called fresh coriander, coriander leaves, Chinese parsley
- What it is
- The leaves and stems of the coriander plant, whose dried seeds are the spice.
- Tastes like
- Bright, citrusy and green. Some people have a gene variant that makes it taste like soap, so ask your guests.
- Use it for
- Salsa, guacamole, curries, Thai and Vietnamese dishes, zhoug, Yemenite and Mexican food, herb salads.
Out of it? Swap in
- Parsley plus a squeeze of limeFresh and green, without the citrusy perfume. The best choice for cilantro-haters.
- Thai basil or mintIn Southeast Asian dishes. A different but welcome aroma.
Diet & allergens
BuyingBright green, unwilted, no dark wet leaves in the middle.
Nana's tip: The stems are tender and the most flavorful part; chop them in. Add cilantro at the very end, because heat flattens it fast.
Loved and loathed. For people who carry a common gene variant, it tastes of soap; for everyone else it’s bright and citrusy. When in doubt, serve it on the side.
Basil
Basil
Also called sweet basil, Genovese basil
- What it is
- A tender, big-leaved summer herb from the mint family. The Italian (Genovese) kind is the default.
- Tastes like
- Sweet, peppery and clove-like with a hint of anise.
- Use it for
- Pesto, tomato salads, pasta sauce (added at the end), pizza, Thai stir-fries (Thai basil).
The kinds you'll see
- Genovese (sweet) — The standard Italian basil.
- Thai — Purple stems, sturdier leaves, strong licorice flavor. Holds up to heat.
- Purple / opal — Pretty, slightly milder. Use like Genovese.
Out of it? Swap in
- Fresh mint plus parsleyFresh and aromatic; not the same, but works in salads.
- Dried basil1 teaspoon per tablespoon fresh, and only in long-cooked sauce. It tastes nothing like fresh.
Diet & allergens
BuyingBright, unbruised leaves with no black spots. A potted plant on the windowsill is often the best deal.
Nana's tip: Tear it or slice it into ribbons (chiffonade) just before using, with a sharp knife; a dull blade bruises it black.
Summer’s herb, and best when a tomato is involved. For pesto, use the freshest leaves and blanch them for 10 seconds if you want it to stay bright green.
Dill
Dill
Also called dill weed
- What it is
- Feathery fronds from the same plant that gives dill seed. A pillar of Ashkenazi, Eastern European, Persian and Scandinavian cooking.
- Tastes like
- Grassy, tangy and anise-light, with a cool, almost lemony finish.
- Use it for
- Chicken soup, gravlax and salmon, cucumber salad, potatoes, tzatziki, Persian rice (shevid polo), pickles.
Out of it? Swap in
- Fennel frondsSimilar feathery look and anise note, sweeter.
- Dried dillAbout 1 teaspoon per tablespoon fresh. Fine in dressings and dips that rest a while; weak in hot food.
Diet & allergens
BuyingPerky, bright green, with no yellowing.
Nana's tip: Add it right at the end of cooking; its aroma fades fast with heat. A whole bunch tied with string goes into chicken soup for the last 20 minutes.
A pillar of Ashkenazi cooking (chicken soup, cucumber salad, gefilte fish, potatoes) and of Persian rice. Its flavor fades fast with heat, so add it at the end.
Mint
Mint
Also called spearmint
- What it is
- Supermarket mint is almost always spearmint; peppermint is sharper and used more for sweets and tea.
- Tastes like
- Cool, sweet and bright. Spearmint is gentle; peppermint is menthol-strong.
- Use it for
- Tabbouleh, Middle Eastern salads, lamb, yogurt sauces, fruit salad, tea, mojitos and juleps.
Out of it? Swap in
- BasilSweet and aromatic, no cooling effect.
- Dried mintCommon and good in Middle Eastern and Persian cooking (sprinkled on yogurt or soups); about 1 teaspoon per tablespoon fresh.
Diet & allergens
BuyingBright, upright leaves with no dark spots.
Nana's tip: Slap a sprig once between your palms before garnishing a drink; it releases the aroma without shredding the leaves.
Mint is one of the few tender herbs that dries well; dried mint is classic in Middle Eastern and Persian cooking, sprinkled on yogurt, soups and salads (see The Mediterranean & Middle Eastern Pantry).
Thyme
- What it is
- A woody herb with tiny leaves on thin stems. The backbone of French and Mediterranean braises and roasts.
- Tastes like
- Earthy, lightly lemony and savory, with a gentle clove-like warmth.
- Use it for
- Roast chicken, braises, stews, soups, roasted vegetables, stuffing, marinades.
The kinds you'll see
- Common (English/French) — The default.
- Lemon thyme — Bright and citrusy. Lovely with fish and in baking.
Out of it? Swap in
- Dried thyme1 teaspoon dried per tablespoon fresh leaves. One of the herbs that dries well.
- Oregano or marjoramEarthier and bolder (oregano) or sweeter (marjoram).
Diet & allergens
BuyingGreen, fragrant sprigs with no dry brown leaves.
Nana's tip: Add whole sprigs to a braise and fish out the bare stems later. To strip leaves, pinch the top and run your fingers down against the grain.
If you keep one woody herb fresh, make it thyme. It goes with nearly everything savory and doesn’t bully other flavors.
Rosemary
- What it is
- A woody, needle-leaved evergreen herb. Strong and resinous, so a little goes a long way.
- Tastes like
- Piney, resinous and peppery, with a hint of eucalyptus.
- Use it for
- Roast potatoes, lamb, chicken, focaccia, white beans, infused oils and syrups.
Out of it? Swap in
- Dried rosemary1 teaspoon per tablespoon fresh; crumble it finely or it's like chewing pine needles.
- ThymeGentler and less piney. Use a bit more.
Diet & allergens
BuyingSupple, deep green needles that smell strong when you rub them.
Nana's tip: Chop it very fine, or add whole sprigs and remove them; big needles are unpleasant to bite. Sturdy stems make good skewers.
Strong and piney. Use whole sprigs in roasts and pull them out, or chop it very fine; a few needles go a long way.
The dried workhorses
Bay and oregano are almost always used dried, and both are better that way.
Bay leaves
Also called laurel, bay laurel
- What it is
- The dried leaves of the bay laurel tree, used whole and removed before serving.
- Tastes like
- On their own, subtle — herbal, piney and faintly floral. In a pot they add a background depth you notice only when it's missing.
- Use it for
- Stocks, soups, braises, brisket, beans and lentils, rice, tomato sauce, pickling brine and poaching liquid.
The kinds you'll see
- Turkish (Mediterranean) bay — The standard dried leaf. Gentle and well-rounded.
- California bay — A different tree; much stronger and more medicinal. Use half a leaf.
Out of it? Swap in
- A sprig of dried thymeDifferent flavor, but fills the same background role.
- Leave it outThe dish will be slightly flatter, but it won't fail.
Diet & allergens
BuyingTurkish bay leaves in a small jar or bag.
Nana's tip: Always fish them out before serving; the leaves stay stiff and sharp-edged even after hours of cooking.
Dried oregano
Also called Greek oregano, Mexican oregano
- What it is
- Leaves of a Mediterranean herb in the mint family, dried and crumbled. One of the few herbs that is as good dried as fresh.
- Tastes like
- Pungent, peppery and resinous with a warm, slightly bitter edge.
- Use it for
- Tomato sauce, pizza, Greek salad and chicken, roasted potatoes, beans, vinaigrettes, marinades and chili.
The kinds you'll see
- Greek / Mediterranean — Bold and earthy. Buy it dried on the stem if you see it.
- Mexican — A different plant, more citrusy and grassy. For salsa, beans, pozole and chili.
Out of it? Swap in
- Dried marjoram, a bit moreOregano's gentler, sweeter cousin.
- Fresh oregano, 3 times as muchBrighter and milder.
Diet & allergens
BuyingGreek oregano in a small jar; add Mexican if you cook Mexican food often.
Nana's tip: Crumble dried oregano between your palms as you add it; it releases the oils and wakes it up.
Checking leafy herbs for insects
Why kosher kitchens check herbs
The Torah forbids eating insects, and leafy herbs are a favorite hiding place for tiny ones like aphids and thrips, which can be the same color as the leaf. So it’s customary in kosher kitchens to wash and check leafy herbs before use. Kashrus agencies (the OU, Star-K, cRc and others) publish detailed methods, and they differ by herb and by agency. Follow the one your community uses, and ask your rabbi.
A typical method that most guides share, for parsley, cilantro, dill, mint and basil:
- Separate the leaves from thick stems, or the bunch into small sprigs.
- Soak in cold water with a few drops of dish soap or vegetable wash for a couple of minutes, which loosens insects’ grip.
- Agitate well, swishing the herbs through the water.
- Rinse thoroughly under running water, sprig by sprig.
- Check a sample against a light box or bright light, both sides of the leaves. If you find insects, repeat the process.
Some herbs are especially hard to check: curly parsley and dill have so many crevices that many agencies suggest using flat-leaf parsley, or buying certified pre-checked herbs (fresh or frozen) with a reliable hechsher. Frozen herb cubes with a hechsher are a practical option for cooking.
Woody herbs (thyme, rosemary, sage) are generally less prone; many agencies say a thorough rinse is enough. Dried herbs from a certified company have already been processed.
Common mistakes
- Cooking tender herbs too long. Gray, limp and tasteless. Add them in the last minute or off the heat.
- Adding woody herbs at the end. A raw rosemary needle is unpleasant, and thyme sprinkled on at the end tastes dusty. Give them heat and time.
- Chopping wet herbs. They bruise into mush. Dry them first.
- Chopping hours ahead. They darken and fade. Chop to order.
- Refrigerating basil. It goes black. Counter, in water.
- Trusting old dried herbs. If you can’t smell them, you can’t taste them.
- Throwing away cilantro and parsley stems. They have more flavor than the leaves; chop the tender ones in, and freeze the rest for stock.