A good pantry is not a big pantry. It’s a short list of things that keep for months, combine a hundred ways, and turn whatever fresh food you have into a meal. Stock the essentials below and you can cook pasta, soup, rice and beans, an omelet, or a pan of roasted something, any night of the week.
Start here. The Spice Drawer and Baking Shelf build on this list, and if you keep kosher, read Building a Kosher Pantry alongside it.
How this list works
Everything is ranked three ways, the same as the badges on each card:
| Tier | What it means | When to buy |
|---|---|---|
| Essential | You will use it every week. Running out stops dinner. | Now, and replace before it’s empty. |
| Nice to have | Makes food noticeably better, or opens up a whole style of dish. | Once you’ve cooked a recipe that needs it twice. |
| Splurge | A better version of something you already have. | When the basic version is a habit and you want more. |
Tap I have this on each card to keep track, and Add to list for anything you’re missing.
The essentials
Seasoning and fat
Salt, pepper, two oils and one vinegar season nearly everything you’ll cook.
Kosher salt
Also called koshering salt, coarse salt
- What it is
- Coarse, flaky salt crystals with no iodine. The name comes from koshering meat, where big crystals sit on the surface and draw out blood, not from the salt itself being more kosher than any other.
- Tastes like
- Clean and purely salty. Because the crystals are large and light, a pinch tastes milder than the same pinch of table salt.
- Use it for
- Everyday seasoning by hand, dry-brining meat and poultry, pasta water, salting vegetables before roasting.
The kinds you'll see
- Diamond Crystal — Hollow, crumbly flakes, about 2.8 g per teaspoon. Easy to pinch, dissolves fast, hard to oversalt. The one most chefs and recipe writers mean.
- Morton — Denser rolled flakes, about 4.8 g per teaspoon, nearly twice as salty by volume as Diamond. Contains an anticaking agent.
Out of it? Swap in
- Table salt, half the volume of Diamond Crystal (or about 3/4 of Morton)Same saltiness by weight; harder to sprinkle evenly and easy to overdo.
- Fine or coarse sea salt, by weightWorks the same; check the grain size before measuring by the spoon.
Diet & allergens
BuyingPick one brand and stick with it, so your hand learns the pinch. Nana keeps Diamond Crystal; if a recipe doesn't say which, assume Diamond.
Nana's tip: Season from about 10 inches above the food so the crystals scatter evenly instead of landing in one salty patch.
The one salt to cook with. Its big, flaky crystals are easy to pinch, so you season by feel instead of by measuring spoon. Brands differ a lot in saltiness by volume; see Salt: Kosher, Table, Flaky & Sea before you swap one for another.
Black pepper
Also called peppercorns, Tellicherry pepper
- What it is
- The dried, unripe berries of a tropical vine, fermented in the sun until black and wrinkled.
- Tastes like
- Freshly ground, it's hot, piney and a little citrusy; pre-ground pepper tastes mostly of dusty heat.
- Use it for
- Almost everything savory, plus steak au poivre, cacio e pepe, strawberries, and spice cakes.
The kinds you'll see
- Whole peppercorns (for a grinder) — The only way to buy it. Ground fresh, it's a different spice.
- Tellicherry — Larger, riper berries from India; more aromatic. A cheap upgrade.
- Coarse / cracked — For crusting steak or tuna; crush whole corns under a heavy pan.
Out of it? Swap in
- White pepperHotter, earthier and invisible in pale food; lacks the fruity aroma.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA bag of whole Tellicherry peppercorns and a good adjustable grinder. Skip the pre-ground tin.
Nana's tip: Grind it over the finished dish too, not only into the pot; pepper's aroma fades with long cooking.
Whole peppercorns and a grinder. Pre-ground pepper is a different, duller spice.
Extra-virgin olive oil
Also called EVOO, olive oil
- What it is
- Oil pressed from olives without heat or chemicals and not refined afterward, so it keeps the fruit's flavor. "Extra-virgin" is the top grade, with low acidity and no tasting defects.
- Tastes like
- Grassy, peppery and fruity when fresh, with a little bitterness and a cough-in-the-throat bite in the best ones.
- Use it for
- Salad dressings, finishing soups and beans, hummus, roasting vegetables, everyday sautéing, and frying eggs.
The kinds you'll see
- Everyday extra-virgin — A big tin or bottle for cooking. Mild, inexpensive, fine for heat.
- Finishing extra-virgin — A small bottle of a fresh, intensely flavored oil for drizzling raw. Check the harvest date.
- Pure or light olive oil — Refined olive oil with a splash of virgin oil. Neutral, higher smoke point. "Light" means light in flavor, not calories.
Out of it? Swap in
- Neutral oilFine for cooking; you lose the fruit and pepper in raw uses.
- Avocado oilButtery and mild, takes higher heat, no peppery bite.
Diet & allergens
BuyingDark glass or a tin, with a harvest date on it. Buy a size you'll finish in two or three months.
Nana's tip: Keep two oils, a cheap one for the pan and a good one for the table. Heat kills the flavor you paid for in the fancy bottle.
Your everyday cooking and finishing oil. Buy a decent one in a dark bottle or tin and use it up within a couple of months of opening, because oil goes stale with air and light.
Neutral oil
Also called vegetable oil, canola oil, grapeseed oil, avocado oil
- What it is
- Refined oils from seeds or fruit that have been filtered and deodorized until they taste of almost nothing and can take high heat.
- Tastes like
- Of nothing, which is the point. It carries other flavors without adding its own.
- Use it for
- Searing, stir-frying, deep- and shallow-frying, oil-based cakes, mayonnaise, and any dressing where olive oil would be too loud.
The kinds you'll see
- Canola — Cheap, mild, about 400°F (205°C) smoke point. The best all-rounder.
- Vegetable (usually soybean) — Same job as canola. Fine for frying.
- Avocado (refined) — Highest smoke point of the common oils, around 500°F (260°C). Pricier; worth it for hard sears.
- Grapeseed — Very clean flavor, good for mayonnaise and dressings. Goes rancid fairly fast.
- Peanut — The classic deep-frying oil. Highly refined peanut oil is generally not considered a major allergen in the US, but cold-pressed is; when cooking for someone with an allergy, skip it.
Out of it? Swap in
- Light (refined) olive oilNearly neutral and heat-tolerant.
- Melted refined coconut oilWorks in baking; solidifies when cool.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne big bottle of canola or vegetable oil for most cooking, plus a small bottle of avocado oil if you sear a lot.
Nana's tip: Fry with fresh oil. Strain used frying oil through a coffee filter and reuse it once or twice for the same kind of food, then let it go.
For high-heat searing, frying and baking, where you want no flavor at all. Canola, sunflower or grapeseed all work. More in Oils & Fats.
- What it is
- Red wine fermented a second time by acetic-acid bacteria until the alcohol turns to vinegar, usually 6 to 7 percent acidity.
- Tastes like
- Bold, fruity and sharp, with a faint tannic grip.
- Use it for
- Everyday vinaigrette, Greek salad, marinades for beef and chicken, pickled red onions, and brightening lentil soup or a braise.
Out of it? Swap in
- Sherry vinegarRounder and nuttier; use a touch less.
- White wine vinegarLighter and cleaner; won't tint the food pink.
- Apple cider vinegarFruitier and softer, fine in a pinch.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA mid-priced bottle. The cheapest ones are harsh and thin.
Nana's tip: For a basic vinaigrette, 1 part red wine vinegar to 3 parts olive oil, a dab of mustard, salt, and shake.
One vinegar, at minimum. A splash of acid at the end is the most common fix for food that tastes “flat” (see Too Salty, Spicy, Sweet or Sour?). Red wine vinegar is the most versatile; Vinegars covers the rest.
Cans and jars
Canned tomatoes
Also called tinned tomatoes, whole peeled tomatoes
- What it is
- Ripe tomatoes picked at peak season, peeled and packed in their own juice or purée, then heat-sealed in a can or carton.
- Tastes like
- Bright, sweet-tart and deeper than most supermarket fresh tomatoes; cheap brands taste tinny and sharp.
- Use it for
- Sauces, soups, braises, shakshuka, chili, curries, and any cooked dish where fresh tomatoes would be watery or out of season.
The kinds you'll see
- Whole peeled — The most versatile and usually the best fruit in the can. Crush by hand or with a spoon in the pot.
- Crushed — Thick and ready for quick sauces and soups. Quality varies a lot by brand.
- Diced — Treated with calcium chloride so the pieces stay firm; they won't break down into a smooth sauce. Good for chili and salsa.
- Purée / passata — Smooth, cooked or strained tomatoes. Fastest route to a smooth sauce or soup.
- San Marzano (DOP) — A specific plum variety from Campania. Sweet, less acidic, fewer seeds. Worth it for a plain marinara; wasted in chili.
Out of it? Swap in
- Fresh ripe plum tomatoes, peeled and cooked down (about 1¾ lb / 800 g per 28-oz can)Great in August, flat and watery the rest of the year, and it takes longer to cook down.
- Tomato purée thinned with a little waterFine for soup or a smooth sauce; you lose the chunky texture.
Diet & allergens
BuyingWhole peeled in juice (not purée) from a brand whose ingredients are just tomatoes, salt and maybe citric acid. Buy 28-oz (794 g) cans; a 14-oz can is half a recipe.
Nana's tip: Cook tomato sauce in a wide pan rather than a deep pot; more surface area means it reduces and sweetens in half the time.
Whole peeled tomatoes are the most useful can you can own. Keep two or three 28-ounce cans.
Tomato paste
Also called tomato concentrate
- What it is
- Tomatoes cooked for hours and strained until most of the water is gone, leaving a thick, brick-red concentrate.
- Tastes like
- Intensely savory, sweet and a little sharp straight from the tube; deep and almost meaty once browned in oil.
- Use it for
- Building the base of stews, braises, chili, soups and pan sauces; giving body and color to tomato sauce, gravy and marinades.
The kinds you'll see
- Tube — Keeps for weeks in the fridge and lets you squeeze out one tablespoon. My pick.
- Can (6 oz) — Cheaper per ounce, but you rarely use it all. Freeze leftovers in tablespoon blobs.
- Double-concentrated — Usually Italian, sold in tubes. Stronger; use about two-thirds as much.
Out of it? Swap in
- 3 Tbsp tomato purée or passata per 1 Tbsp paste, cooked downWorks, but needs extra reduction time and adds liquid.
- Ketchup, half the amountAdds sweetness and vinegar; okay in a pinch for chili or glaze, not for a delicate sauce.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA tube of plain tomato paste, ingredient list "tomatoes" (salt is fine).
Nana's tip: Fry it in the oil for 1–2 minutes, stirring, until it darkens from red to rust. That browning is where its savory depth comes from.
A tablespoon browned in oil gives soups, stews and sauces a savory backbone. Buy a tube; it keeps.
Stock & broth
Also called bouillon, consommé powder, soup base
- What it is
- Liquid made by simmering bones, meat or vegetables in water. Stock is made mostly from bones and has more body; broth is lighter and seasoned. On store shelves the names are used loosely.
- Tastes like
- Good stock tastes rich and round; boxed broth is mild and often salty; bouillon cubes and powders are salty and a little artificial.
- Use it for
- Soups, risotto, braising liquid, cooking rice and grains, pan sauces and gravy, thinning stews.
The kinds you'll see
- Boxed (carton) broth — Convenient and consistent. Buy low-sodium so you control the salt.
- Concentrated paste (jar) — Keeps for months in the fridge and tastes better than cubes. One teaspoon per cup of water.
- Bouillon cubes / consommé powder — Cheapest and longest-lasting; very salty. A kosher kitchen staple, especially the parve "chicken-flavored" kind.
- Homemade — Best by a mile, and it freezes for months. Worth doing whenever you have a chicken carcass.
Out of it? Swap in
- Water plus extra aromatics (onion, carrot, celery, a bay leaf) and more saltThinner flavor, but fine in a hearty soup or bean pot.
- Parve consommé powder for chicken brothKeeps a dish parve so it can be served with dairy; tastes saltier and less meaty.
Diet & allergens
BuyingLow-sodium boxed broth for everyday cooking, plus a jar of concentrate as backup. Two quarts on the shelf covers most weeks.
Nana's tip: Freeze homemade stock in a muffin tin, then pop the pucks into a bag. Each one is about half a cup.
Low-sodium broth for rice, soup and pan sauces, plus a jar of concentrate or cubes for backup.
Canned beans
Also called tinned beans, chickpeas, garbanzos
- What it is
- Dried beans soaked, cooked and sealed in salted water in the can, ready to use.
- Tastes like
- Creamy and mild; the best brands are tender but whole, cheap ones mushy or chalky and tinny.
- Use it for
- Hummus, soups, chili, salads, grain bowls, roasted crispy chickpeas, and quick protein for any weeknight skillet.
The kinds you'll see
- Chickpeas (garbanzos) — Nutty and firm. Hummus, stews, roasting, salads. The most useful can on the shelf.
- Cannellini / white beans — Creamy and mild. Italian soups, mashed on toast, with greens.
- Black beans — Earthy and dense. Tacos, burritos, soups, rice and beans.
- Kidney and pinto beans — Hearty. Chili, refried beans, cholent, baked beans.
Out of it? Swap in
- Dried beans, cooked (½ cup / 90 g dried ≈ one 15-oz can drained)Cheaper and better texture, but needs soaking and an hour or more of cooking.
- Another canned beanWhite, pinto and kidney beans swap freely; chickpeas are firmer and stay whole.
Diet & allergens
BuyingKeep four to six cans, mostly chickpeas plus one or two other types. Low-sodium lets you season them yourself.
Nana's tip: Rinse canned beans in a sieve to wash off the starchy, salty liquid, unless you're making hummus or soup, where a splash of it helps.
Chickpeas first, then whatever you like. Beans plus a can of tomatoes plus an onion is dinner.
Dry goods
Dried pasta
Also called pasta secca
- What it is
- Durum wheat semolina mixed with water, extruded through dies into shapes, then dried until hard.
- Tastes like
- Wheaty and lightly nutty; good pasta has a chewy, firm bite and a slightly rough surface that grips sauce.
- Use it for
- Weeknight dinners, baked pasta, soups, pasta salad, kugel (egg noodles), and stretching small amounts of anything into a meal.
The kinds you'll see
- Long (spaghetti, linguine) — For oil-based, tomato and creamy sauces that coat each strand.
- Short tubes (penne, rigatoni) — Catch chunky sauces and hold up in the oven.
- Twists and shells (fusilli, shells, orecchiette) — Trap little bits of vegetable, sausage or crumbs.
- Small (orzo, ditalini, pastina) — Soups and side dishes.
- Egg noodles — Softer, richer, quicker-cooking. Classic for kugel and chicken soup.
Out of it? Swap in
- Fresh pastaSilkier and cooks in 2–3 minutes, but softer and better with butter or cream than with chunky sauces.
- Gluten-free pasta (rice, corn or chickpea)Cooks fast and goes from al dente to mushy quickly; rinse less and sauce it right away.
Diet & allergens
BuyingBronze-die pasta (it says so on the bag) has a rough, matte surface that holds sauce far better. Keep one long and one short shape, 2 lb (900 g) total.
Nana's tip: Salt the water until it tastes pleasantly seasoned (about 1 Tbsp kosher salt per 4 qt), and save a mug of the starchy water before draining; it is what makes sauce cling.
One long shape, one short shape. Bronze-die pasta has a rough surface that holds sauce.
- What it is
- The seed of a cultivated grass, sold polished (white) or with its bran (brown). Grain length tells you how it will cook.
- Tastes like
- Mild and slightly sweet; jasmine smells floral, basmati nutty and buttery, brown rice earthy.
- Use it for
- Side dishes, pilaf and stuffed vegetables, fried rice, risotto, rice pudding, soups, and as the base for anything saucy.
The kinds you'll see
- Long-grain (basmati, jasmine, plain long-grain) — Fluffy, separate grains. Basmati for pilafs and Indian and Persian dishes; jasmine for Southeast Asian food.
- Medium-grain (Calrose, Arborio, Bomba) — Creamy and a little sticky. Arborio and Carnaroli for risotto; Bomba for paella.
- Short-grain (sushi rice) — Sticky and tender. Sushi, rice pudding, Japanese and Korean meals.
- Brown rice — Bran left on; chewier and nuttier, takes 40–45 minutes, and goes rancid sooner.
Out of it? Swap in
- Another long-grain riceJasmine and basmati swap easily; just expect a different aroma.
- Orzo, bulgur or quinoaDifferent texture and timing, but fine for a side dish or pilaf.
Diet & allergens
BuyingKeep one everyday long-grain (basmati is my pick) in a 5-lb (2.3-kg) bag, and add a specialty rice only when you cook that dish often.
Nana's tip: Rinse white rice in a few changes of water until it runs nearly clear; removing the loose surface starch is what keeps grains from clumping.
One long-grain rice you like; basmati is a good default. See Cooking Rice & Grains for ratios.
The fresh staples
These aren’t shelf-stable, but they keep for weeks and you’ll reach for them daily. Treat them as part of the pantry.
Yellow onion
Also called brown onion, Spanish onion, white onion, sweet onion
- What it is
- The all-purpose cooking onion, with papery golden skin. This card also covers white and sweet onions.
- Tastes like
- Sharp and eye-watering raw; turns deeply sweet and savory as it cooks, because heat drives off the sulfur compounds and browns its sugars.
- Use it for
- The base of almost every soup, stew, braise, sauce and sauté. Caramelized onions. Brisket.
The kinds you'll see
- Yellow — The default. Best balance of sweetness and pungency; keeps for months.
- White — Crisper and cleaner-tasting, a bit sharper. Mexican cooking, salsas, stir-fries. Doesn't keep quite as long.
- Sweet (Vidalia, Walla Walla, Maui) — Low in sulfur, high in water. Mild enough to eat raw; collapse when cooked; keep only a few weeks.
Out of it? Swap in
- ShallotsMore delicate and a little garlicky. Use about 3–4 shallots for one medium onion.
- Leeks (white and light green parts)Softer, sweeter, less browning. Great in soups.
- Onion powderAbout 1 tablespoon for a medium onion in a sauce or rub. No texture, and none of the sweetness of browned onion.
Diet & allergens
BuyingHard and heavy, with dry, rustling skins and no smell. Avoid soft necks.
Nana's tip: A medium onion is about 1 cup chopped (150 g); a large one is about 2 cups.
The start of most savory dishes. Keep 3 lb (1.4 kg) in a cool, dark, airy spot, away from potatoes, which make each other spoil faster.
- What it is
- A head of cloves from the onion family. Its sharp smell only appears when a clove's cells are cut and an enzyme makes allicin.
- Tastes like
- Raw, hot and pungent; gently cooked, nutty and sweet; roasted whole, soft, jammy and mellow; burnt, acrid and bitter.
- Use it for
- Nearly every savory cuisine. Sautés, sauces, marinades, dressings, roasts, garlic bread, toum and aioli.
The kinds you'll see
- Softneck — The supermarket kind. Many small cloves, long keeper.
- Hardneck — Fewer, bigger cloves, easy to peel, more complex flavor. Farmers' markets in summer and fall; keeps a few months.
- Pre-peeled cloves — Fine time-saver; keep in the fridge and use within 2 weeks.
- Jarred minced — Tinny and sour from preservatives. Skip it.
- Black garlic — Heads aged warm for weeks until soft, black and sweet, like balsamic and molasses. A condiment, not a swap.
Out of it? Swap in
- Garlic powderAbout ⅛ teaspoon per clove. Good in rubs and dry mixes; flat and toasted-tasting in sauces.
- Frozen garlic cubesOne cube per clove. Good enough for cooked dishes.
Diet & allergens
BuyingTight, heavy, firm heads with dry papery skin and no green shoots.
Nana's tip: The finer you cut it, the stronger it tastes; grated garlic is fierce, sliced is mild, whole crushed cloves are gentle.
Two or three whole heads. Skip the jarred minced garlic; it tastes sour and flat. More in The Onion Family.
Lemon
Also called Eureka lemon, Lisbon lemon
- What it is
- The everyday supermarket lemon, usually a Eureka or Lisbon. Bright yellow, thick-skinned and sharply sour.
- Tastes like
- Clean, high-pitched sourness in the juice; the zest is floral and sweet-smelling with almost no sour at all.
- Use it for
- Finishing soups, fish, roasted vegetables and dressings; lemon desserts; brightening anything that tastes flat.
The kinds you'll see
- Eureka / Lisbon — The standard. Sour, thick rind, plenty of zest.
- Meyer — A lemon-mandarin cross. Sweeter, floral, thin-skinned; winter only. Use less sugar if you swap it in.
Out of it? Swap in
- Lime juiceSame sourness, different perfume. Fine in dressings and marinades; noticeable in lemon desserts.
- White wine vinegarFor acidity in a savory dish only. You lose all the fruit aroma, so use about half as much.
- Bottled lemon juiceSour enough for cooking, but flat and slightly cooked-tasting. Never for finishing or desserts.
Diet & allergens
BuyingPick lemons heavy for their size with fine-pored, glossy skin; they give more juice. Buy organic or unwaxed if you zest a lot.
Nana's tip: Zest before you juice; you can't zest a squeezed-out half.
Juice and zest brighten almost anything. Two or three lemons in the fridge keep for weeks. See Citrus.
Eggs
Also called large eggs
- What it is
- Chicken eggs. Recipes assume US "large" eggs, about 50 g out of the shell (about 30 g white, 18 g yolk).
- Tastes like
- Mild and rich; yolks are buttery, whites almost neutral. Diet and freshness matter more than shell color.
- Use it for
- Binding, leavening, emulsifying, glazing, enriching; challah, cakes, custards, mayonnaise, shakshuka, kugel, breakfast.
The kinds you'll see
- Large — The recipe standard. Buy these.
- Extra-large / jumbo — Up to 25% bigger; weigh them in baking.
- Pasture-raised — Often deeper-colored yolks. A matter of taste and values, not safety.
Out of it? Swap in
- 1 tablespoon ground flaxseed plus 3 tablespoons water, rested 10 minutes (per egg)Binds muffins, brownies and cookies. No lift or richness; don't use for more than 2 eggs.
- 3 tablespoons aquafaba (chickpea liquid) per egg, or 2 per whiteWhips like egg white for meringue and mousse.
Diet & allergens
BuyingGrade A or AA large, uncracked, from the back of the cold case.
Nana's tip: Crack eggs on a flat counter, not the bowl's edge, so the shell breaks cleanly instead of pushing shards into the egg.
A dozen eggs is breakfast, binder, dinner (shakshuka, frittata, fried rice) and baking.
Unsalted butter
Also called sweet butter, sweet cream butter
- What it is
- Churned cream, about 80 to 82 percent fat, 16 to 18 percent water, and a little milk solids, with no added salt.
- Tastes like
- Sweet, creamy and milky; browned, it turns nutty and toffee-like.
- Use it for
- Baking, pan sauces, basting steak, scrambled eggs, cookies, pie crust, and finishing vegetables.
The kinds you'll see
- Standard American — At least 80 percent fat. Fine for nearly everything.
- European-style — 82 to 86 percent fat, often cultured. Flakier pastry, richer sauces.
- Salted — Varies by brand, roughly 1/4 teaspoon of table salt per stick. Great on bread; less control in baking.
- Cultured — Made from slightly soured cream. Tangier, more flavor.
Out of it? Swap in
- Salted butterCut the recipe's added salt by about 1/4 teaspoon per stick.
- Parve margarine or butter-flavored sticksThe kosher swap for meat meals. Similar in baking; less flavor, sometimes softer dough.
- Neutral oil, about 3/4 the amountWorks in muffins and quick breads. Can't cream it, so no use in cookies or pastry that need air or flakes.
Diet & allergens
BuyingPick one brand for baking and stick with it. 1 stick = 8 tablespoons = 1/2 cup = 113 g.
Nana's tip: "Room temperature" butter for creaming means about 65°F (18°C): it should dent with a finger but not look greasy or shiny.
Unsalted, so you control seasoning. Keep a spare pound in the freezer.
Kosher note
Several essentials decide whether a dish is meat, dairy or parve. Chicken and beef stock are meat; butter is dairy. Keep a carton of vegetable broth or a jar of parve consommé powder so a soup or rice can stay parve, and use oil instead of butter when a meal is fleishig. Kosher Basics explains the categories.
Nice to have
Add these one at a time as your cooking calls for them. Each one unlocks a lot.
Dijon mustard
Also called dijon
- What it is
- A smooth, pale mustard made from brown or black mustard seeds ground with white wine or verjuice, in the style of Dijon, France.
- Tastes like
- Sharp, clean heat that goes up the nose, with a winey tang. Much stronger than yellow ballpark mustard.
- Use it for
- Vinaigrettes (it holds the oil and vinegar together), pan sauces, glazes for salmon or chicken, sandwiches, potato salad, deviled eggs.
The kinds you'll see
- Smooth Dijon — The all-rounder. This is what "mustard" means in most good recipes.
- Whole-grain / grainy — Milder, with popping seeds. Better on sandwiches and in potato salad than in dressing.
- Yellow mustard — Mild, turmeric-colored and vinegary. Hot dogs, not vinaigrette.
Out of it? Swap in
- Whole-grain mustardGentler and seedy; still emulsifies a dressing.
- ½ tsp dry mustard powder per 1 Tbsp Dijon, mixed with water and a splash of wine vinegarGets the heat, loses the creamy body.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA real Dijon in a glass jar, with mustard seeds, wine or vinegar, and salt high on the list. One jar at a time; it loses punch.
Nana's tip: A teaspoon of Dijon in a vinaigrette is the difference between a dressing that separates in 30 seconds and one that stays creamy.
The secret to a vinaigrette that stays creamy (it’s an emulsifier), and the base of glazes and pan sauces.
Mayonnaise
Also called mayo
- What it is
- An emulsion of oil and egg yolk, sharpened with vinegar or lemon and salt. Store-bought uses pasteurized eggs.
- Tastes like
- Rich, creamy and tangy; good jarred mayo is balanced, cheap mayo is sweet.
- Use it for
- Sandwiches, salads (tuna, egg, potato, coleslaw), dips and aioli, coating fish or chicken before baking so it browns, and in moist chocolate cakes.
The kinds you'll see
- Regular / full-fat — The one to cook with. Creamy and stable when heated.
- Light — Thickened with starch; sweeter and breaks under heat.
- Japanese-style — Yolks only and rice vinegar; richer and tangier.
- Vegan / egg-free — Close in flavor; a good swap for egg allergies.
Out of it? Swap in
- Greek yogurt or sour creamTangier and lighter; turns a parve dish dairy.
- Homemade mayonnaiseBetter flavor, but made with raw yolk unless you use pasteurized eggs; keep it cold and use within 4 days.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne full-fat jar. Light mayo isn't worth it for cooking.
Nana's tip: Brush a thin layer on the outside of a grilled cheese or on fish fillets instead of butter; the oil and egg brown evenly and won't burn as fast.
Sandwiches and salads, yes, but also a coating that browns fish and chicken evenly in the oven.
Soy sauce
Also called shoyu, jiangyou
- What it is
- Soybeans (usually with roasted wheat) fermented with mold and brine for months, then pressed and strained.
- Tastes like
- Salty and deeply savory, with a roasted, slightly sweet, almost meaty finish.
- Use it for
- Stir-fries, marinades, dipping sauces, fried rice, braises, dressings, and a splash in soups, gravies and chili for depth.
The kinds you'll see
- All-purpose (Japanese koikuchi) — The standard bottle. If a recipe just says "soy sauce", use this.
- Chinese light soy sauce — Thinner and saltier. The main seasoning soy in Chinese cooking; "light" means color, not low sodium.
- Chinese dark soy sauce — Aged longer, often with molasses. Thick, less salty, used mostly for color in braises and noodles.
- Tamari — Made with little or no wheat; richer and smoother. Look for "gluten-free" on the label if that matters.
- Reduced-sodium — About 40% less salt. Fine for dipping; you may need extra salt in cooking.
Out of it? Swap in
- Tamari or coconut aminosTamari is nearly identical. Coconut aminos is sweeter and much less salty.
- Salt plus a little Worcestershire (check that it's fish-free for meat dishes)In a pinch for a marinade; no fermented depth.
Diet & allergens
BuyingLook for "naturally brewed" on the label. Avoid "hydrolyzed soy protein" sauces, which are made chemically and taste thin and harsh.
Nana's tip: Add soy sauce early in a marinade and again at the end of a stir-fry. The early dose seasons; the late splash gives aroma that cooking drives off.
Salt with savory depth. It earns a place in more than Asian cooking: marinades, gravy, even tomato sauce. The The East Asian Pantry goes further.
Honey
Also called raw honey
- What it is
- Nectar concentrated by bees into a thick syrup, mostly fructose and glucose with about 17 percent water. Flavor depends on the flowers.
- Tastes like
- Floral and rounded. Clover is mild; wildflower is fuller; buckwheat is dark, malty and almost molasses-like.
- Use it for
- Honey cake and Rosh Hashanah baking, glazes and marinades, dressings, tea, and drizzling on cheese, yogurt or challah.
The kinds you'll see
- Liquid (clover, orange blossom, wildflower) — The everyday kind for cooking and baking.
- Creamed or whipped — Crystallized on purpose into a spread. For toast, not for measuring.
- Raw — Strained but not heated. Crystallizes faster. Save it for drizzling, where its aroma shows.
Out of it? Swap in
- Maple syrup, same amountThinner, less sweet, with a different flavor.
- Silan (date syrup)Darker and fruitier. Traditional on Rosh Hashanah in many Sephardi homes.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA mild clover or wildflower for baking; a small jar of something special for the table.
Nana's tip: Oil or spray your measuring cup first and the honey slides right out. Crystallized honey melts back in a bowl of warm water.
Glazes, dressings, tea, and the sweet note that balances acid or heat.
Dried lentils
Also called lentils
- What it is
- Small, flat seeds of a legume plant, sold dried. Unlike beans they need no soaking and cook in 15–45 minutes.
- Tastes like
- Earthy and a little peppery; red lentils sweet and mild, French green lentils mineral and nutty.
- Use it for
- Soups, dal, salads, lentil-and-rice dishes like mujadara, vegetarian "meat" sauces, and stretching ground meat.
The kinds you'll see
- Brown — The supermarket default. Soft, earthy, 20–30 minutes. Soups and stews.
- Green (French / du Puy) — Hold their shape, 25–35 minutes. The one for salads and side dishes.
- Red / yellow (split) — Hulled and split; melt into a purée in 15–20 minutes. Dal and creamy soups.
- Black (beluga) — Small, glossy, firm. Salads and elegant sides.
Out of it? Swap in
- Another lentil typeBrown and green swap freely; red falls apart, so don't use it where you want whole lentils.
- Canned lentils, drainedQuick for salads and soups, but softer.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne 1-lb (450-g) bag each of green and red covers most recipes. Pick through for small stones before cooking.
Nana's tip: Salt lentils near the end of cooking and add acid (vinegar, lemon, tomato) only once they're tender; acid keeps them firm.
Faster than beans and no soaking. Red lentils melt into soup in 20 minutes; green ones stay whole for salads.
Panko
Also called Japanese breadcrumbs
- What it is
- Japanese-style breadcrumbs made from crustless bread baked by electric current, then shredded into airy flakes and dried.
- Tastes like
- Neutral; the point is texture. Panko fries up light and shatteringly crisp and soaks up less oil than fine crumbs.
- Use it for
- Breading cutlets and schnitzel, fish, crispy toppings for baked pasta and gratins, and binding meatballs and fish cakes.
The kinds you'll see
- Plain panko — Buy this and season it yourself.
- Seasoned / Italian-style panko — Has dried herbs, garlic and often cheese. Check whether it's dairy.
- Regular dried breadcrumbs — Fine and sandy; denser coating, better for binding meatballs and meatloaf.
Out of it? Swap in
- Regular dried breadcrumbsDenser, less crunchy coating.
- Crushed cornflakes or matzo mealCornflakes give a sweeter, crunchier crust; matzo meal is the classic kosher-for-Passover coating.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne box or bag of plain panko. That's enough for several schnitzel nights.
Nana's tip: Toast panko in a dry skillet with a spoonful of oil until golden before sprinkling it on pasta or roasted vegetables; it stays crunchy instead of going soggy.
Crisp coatings for schnitzel and fish, and crunchy toppings for anything baked.
Parmesan
Also called Parmigiano-Reggiano
- What it is
- A hard, aged cow's-milk cheese. True Parmigiano-Reggiano is made in a protected Italian region and aged at least 12 months.
- Tastes like
- Nutty, salty and deeply savory, with little crunchy crystals in older wheels.
- Use it for
- Pasta, risotto, pesto, Caesar dressing, roasted vegetables, eggplant parmesan, soups (with the rind).
The kinds you'll see
- Parmigiano-Reggiano — The real thing, 12–36 months. Best flavor.
- Grana Padano — Similar, younger, milder, cheaper. A fine everyday choice.
- Domestic "parmesan" — Varies widely. Kosher versions are usually this kind.
- Pre-grated in a can — Contains anti-caking agents and tastes flat. Skip it.
Out of it? Swap in
- Pecorino RomanoSaltier and sharper (sheep's milk). Use a little less.
- Nutritional yeast plus a pinch of saltA parve stand-in for savory flavor. Not cheesy in texture.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA wedge, and grate it yourself. A Microplane gives fluffy snow; the box grater's small holes give denser crumbs.
Nana's tip: Freeze the rinds and drop one into soup or tomato sauce; it adds deep savory flavor. Fish it out before serving.
A wedge, not the green can. It keeps for weeks wrapped in parchment and turns pasta, soup and roasted vegetables into a dish.
Hot sauce
Also called pepper sauce
- What it is
- Chiles blended with vinegar, salt and sometimes garlic or fruit, either fermented (aged) or fresh.
- Tastes like
- Anywhere from tangy and mild (cayenne sauces) to sharp and fiery (Tabasco) to garlicky-sweet (sriracha).
- Use it for
- Eggs, beans, soups, marinades, wings, Buffalo sauce, dressings, and a dash in anything that tastes flat.
The kinds you'll see
- Louisiana-style (cayenne) — Vinegary, medium heat. Buffalo sauce, eggs, the all-purpose bottle.
- Tabasco-style (fermented) — Thin, sharp and hot. A few drops in soups, eggs and Bloody Marys.
- Sriracha — Thick, garlicky and a little sweet. Noodles, rice, mayo dip.
- Habanero / fruity sauces — Very hot with tropical fruit notes. Fish tacos, grilled chicken.
Out of it? Swap in
- Pinch of cayenne plus a few drops of vinegarGets heat and tang; no body or fermented depth.
- Red pepper flakes or chili crispHeat without vinegar; adds texture.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne vinegary bottle and one sriracha-style covers most needs.
Nana's tip: Add hot sauce at the end or at the table; long cooking flattens its bright vinegar note.
A few drops wake up eggs, beans and soup.
Capers
Also called caperberries
- What it is
- The unopened flower buds of a Mediterranean bush, cured in brine or packed in salt.
- Tastes like
- Salty, sour and floral-mustardy, like a briny little burst; fried capers taste nutty and crisp.
- Use it for
- Piccata, tartar sauce, salsa verde, puttanesca, tuna and egg salads, smoked salmon, roasted cauliflower and fish.
The kinds you'll see
- Nonpareil (in brine) — The smallest and most delicate. The everyday choice.
- Salt-packed — Firmer and more floral. Soak 10–15 minutes and rinse before using.
- Caperberries — The fruit, the size of a grape, with a stem. For cheese plates and martinis.
Out of it? Swap in
- Chopped green olivesBriny and salty, less sharp.
- Chopped dill pickle or cornichonsBrighter vinegar tang, crunchier, a bit sweeter.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne small jar of nonpareil capers in brine.
Nana's tip: Pat drained capers dry and fry them in a little hot oil for a minute until they bloom open and crisp; scatter over fish, eggs or pasta.
Salty, sour little bursts for fish, pasta and salads.
Anchovies
Also called anchovy fillets, anchovy paste
- What it is
- Small oily fish, salt-cured for months and sold as fillets in oil, whole in salt, or ground into paste.
- Tastes like
- Straight from the tin, intensely salty and fishy; melted into a dish, they turn into pure savory depth without tasting of fish.
- Use it for
- Caesar dressing, puttanesca, salsa verde, pan sauces, roasted vegetables, bagna cauda, and the base of a lamb or tomato braise.
The kinds you'll see
- Fillets in olive oil (tin or jar) — The everyday choice. Jars reseal better.
- Salt-packed whole — Best flavor and texture; rinse and fillet before using.
- Anchovy paste (tube) — Convenient, keeps for months; about ½ tsp per fillet. Saltier and flatter.
- White anchovies (boquerones) — Lightly vinegar-cured, mild and fresh. A different thing; eat them on toast, don't melt them.
Out of it? Swap in
- ½ tsp anchovy paste per filletNearly the same in cooked dishes.
- Miso, capers, or a dash of Worcestershire or fish sauceAdds savory depth without fish (miso, capers); flavor isn't identical.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA small jar of fillets in olive oil from a brand with a hechsher, or a tube of paste if you only use them now and then.
Nana's tip: Start a sauce by mashing two fillets into the warm olive oil until they dissolve before adding garlic; nobody will know they're there.
Melted into oil, they’re pure savory depth, and nobody tastes fish. Note the kosher point on the card about fish and meat.
Worcestershire sauce
Also called Worcester sauce
- What it is
- A thin, dark, fermented English sauce of vinegar, molasses, tamarind, onion, garlic, spices and, traditionally, anchovies.
- Tastes like
- Salty, tangy, sweet and deeply savory, with a spiced, slightly fishy back note that disappears into food.
- Use it for
- Burgers, meatloaf, marinades, gravy, Bloody Marys, Caesar dressing, deviled eggs and cheese toasts.
Out of it? Swap in
- Soy sauce plus a few drops of vinegar and a pinch of sugarGets the salty-savory-tangy balance; loses the spice and tamarind.
- Fish-free (vegetarian) WorcestershireNearly the same flavor, and the answer for meat dishes in a kosher kitchen.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne small bottle lasts a year. If you keep kosher and cook meat, buy a fish-free brand.
Nana's tip: Add a few dashes to ground meat before forming burgers; you won't taste it, but they'll taste meatier.
A dash makes burgers, gravy and marinades taste meatier.
Splurges
Only once the basics are habits. Each is a better version of something above.
- A finishing olive oil. A small bottle of fresh, peppery single-origin oil for drizzling on soup, beans and bread. Keep cooking with the everyday bottle.
- Flaky salt. A pinch on top of a steak, a salad or a chocolate chip cookie, for the crunch.
- San Marzano tomatoes (DOP). Noticeably sweeter in a plain marinara. Wasted in chili.
- Sherry vinegar or a real aged Balsamic vinegar. Deep, nutty and round; a teaspoon finishes a dish.
- Good canned fish (tuna in olive oil, sardines). A no-cook dinner on toast with lemon and capers.
How much to buy
Buy enough that you’re never caught short, not so much that things go stale.
| Item | Keep on hand | Replace when |
|---|---|---|
| Kosher salt | 1 box (3 lb / 1.4 kg) | Half empty |
| Olive oil | 1 bottle (500 ml–1 L) | Down to a quarter |
| Neutral oil | 1 bottle (1 L) | Down to a quarter |
| Canned tomatoes | 2–3 large cans | You open the last one |
| Canned beans | 4–6 cans | You’re down to two |
| Pasta | 2 lb (900 g) in two shapes | One box left |
| Rice | 2–5 lb (1–2.3 kg) | A week’s worth left |
| Broth | 2 quarts + concentrate | One carton left |
| Onions | 3 lb (1.4 kg) | Three left |
| Garlic | 2–3 heads | One head left |
| Eggs | 1 dozen | Four left |
How to store it all
Pantry food lasts a long time, but only if it’s kept cool, dry and dark. Heat, light, air and moisture are what make things go stale, rancid or buggy.
- Cupboard: cool and away from the stove, dishwasher and oven, because heat speeds up staling and makes oils go rancid. Cans, dry pasta, rice, beans, lentils, unopened broth, honey, vinegar.
- Airtight containers: decant opened rice, lentils, panko and pasta into jars with tight lids. It keeps out moisture and pantry moths, and you can see when you’re running low.
- Fridge door: opened mustard, mayo, capers, anchovies, tomato paste tube, hot sauce (especially sriracha), soy sauce if you use it slowly.
- Freezer: extra butter, brown rice, homemade stock, leftover tomato paste in tablespoon blobs, and nuts.
- Counter, out of the sun: onions and garlic in a basket with air flow; never in plastic bags, which trap moisture and cause rot.
Food safety
Throw out any can that is bulging, leaking, rusted through, or badly dented along a seam, and anything that spurts when opened; these can be signs of dangerous bacteria. Once opened, move canned food to a glass or plastic container and refrigerate it. USDA guidance: opened high-acid foods like tomatoes keep 5–7 days, low-acid foods like beans 3–4 days. Unopened, high-acid cans keep 12–18 months and low-acid cans 2–5 years. Cooked food shouldn’t sit between 40°F and 140°F (4°C–60°C) for more than 2 hours.
Nana's tip
Put new cans and boxes behind the old ones. First in, first out, and nothing hides at the back for three years.
Shopping strategy
- Shop the list, not the aisle. Keep a running list on the fridge (or use the Add to list buttons) and add things when they’re half gone, not when they’re empty.
- Buy the best version of the few things you taste most. Olive oil, canned tomatoes, Parmesan and pasta show up in the finished dish. Salt, neutral oil, rice and canned beans are fine as store brands.
- Buy small when it fades. Spices, nuts, flour and good oil lose flavor once opened. A small fresh bottle beats a big stale one.
- Buy big when it doesn’t. Salt, rice, dry pasta, canned goods and vinegar keep for a year or more. Stock up when they’re on sale.
- One new thing at a time. Add a “nice to have” only after you’ve wanted it twice. That’s how a pantry fills with things you use instead of things you bought once.
What to skip
- Garlic salt, onion salt, “seasoned salt”. You’re paying for salt. Buy the garlic powder and the salt separately and control each one.
- Jarred minced garlic. Sour and flat. A head of fresh garlic keeps for weeks.
- Bottled lemon juice. Tastes cooked and bitter. One lemon gives about 3 Tbsp juice.
- Pre-ground pepper. Grinder only.
- A dozen vinegars, a dozen oils. Start with one of each kind and add when a recipe you love needs another.
- Light mayonnaise and “lite” sauces. They add starch and sugar to make up for fat and don’t cook well.
- Giant bargain tubs of spices you’ll use once a year. See the The Spice Drawer.
Passover note
Many everyday staples change at Passover. Pasta and panko are chametz. Rice, beans, lentils and some oils are kitniyot, which most Ashkenazim avoid and most Sephardim eat; follow your family’s custom and ask your rabbi. Most other items (canned tomatoes, oil, vinegar, mayonnaise, spices) are sold certified kosher for Passover. See The Passover Kitchen.
Cook from the pantry
Chickpeas and a can of tomatoes, a box of pasta, a few eggs: here’s what the site’s cooks make with them.