Canned tomatoes
Photo: benketaro, CC BY 2.0 · Flickr

Canned tomatoes

Also called tinned tomatoes, whole peeled tomatoes

Essential
What it is
Ripe tomatoes picked at peak season, peeled and packed in their own juice or purée, then heat-sealed in a can or carton.
Tastes like
Bright, sweet-tart and deeper than most supermarket fresh tomatoes; cheap brands taste tinny and sharp.
Use it for
Sauces, soups, braises, shakshuka, chili, curries, and any cooked dish where fresh tomatoes would be watery or out of season.

The kinds you'll see

  • Whole peeled — The most versatile and usually the best fruit in the can. Crush by hand or with a spoon in the pot.
  • Crushed — Thick and ready for quick sauces and soups. Quality varies a lot by brand.
  • Diced — Treated with calcium chloride so the pieces stay firm; they won't break down into a smooth sauce. Good for chili and salsa.
  • Purée / passata — Smooth, cooked or strained tomatoes. Fastest route to a smooth sauce or soup.
  • San Marzano (DOP) — A specific plum variety from Campania. Sweet, less acidic, fewer seeds. Worth it for a plain marinara; wasted in chili.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Fresh ripe plum tomatoes, peeled and cooked down (about 1¾ lb / 800 g per 28-oz can)Great in August, flat and watery the rest of the year, and it takes longer to cook down.
  • Tomato purée thinned with a little waterFine for soup or a smooth sauce; you lose the chunky texture.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreUnopened in a cool, dry cupboard. Once opened, move to a glass or plastic container and refrigerate.
KeepsUnopened 12–18 months (high-acid food); opened, 5–7 days in the fridge, or freeze for 2 months.
Toss whenThe can is bulging, leaking, deeply dented on a seam, or spurts when opened; or the contents smell fermented or show mold.

BuyingWhole peeled in juice (not purée) from a brand whose ingredients are just tomatoes, salt and maybe citric acid. Buy 28-oz (794 g) cans; a 14-oz can is half a recipe.

Nana's tip: Cook tomato sauce in a wide pan rather than a deep pot; more surface area means it reduces and sweetens in half the time.

Cook with it

634 recipes on Nana's Fogón use canned tomatoes.

See all 634 →