Vinegar is wine, cider or another alcohol that bacteria have turned sour, converting the alcohol into acetic acid. Acid is the most overlooked seasoning in home cooking: when a soup, stew or salad tastes flat and more salt doesn’t fix it, a spoonful of vinegar usually does. The base it’s made from decides the flavor; the acidity decides how hard it hits.
The vinegars at a glance
| Vinegar | Typical acidity | Flavor | Strength | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rice vinegar | about 4–4.5% | Mild, slightly sweet | Gentlest | Sushi rice, Asian dressings, cucumber salads |
| Apple cider vinegar | 5% | Fruity, apple-y | Medium | Slaw, barbecue, pickles, marinades |
| Distilled white vinegar | 5% | Sharp, plain | Medium, harsh | Canning, sour pickles, poaching eggs, cleaning |
| White wine vinegar | 5–7% | Clean, crisp | Medium | Delicate dressings, butter sauces, fish |
| Red wine vinegar | 6–7% | Bold, fruity | Strong | Everyday vinaigrette, marinades, braises |
| Balsamic vinegar (IGP) | about 6% | Sweet-sour, figgy | Medium, softened by sugar | Tomatoes, roasted vegetables, glazes |
| Sherry vinegar | 7–8% | Nutty, deep, oaky | Strong | Gazpacho, bitter greens, pan sauces, lentils |
| Malt vinegar | 5% | Malty, toasty | Medium | Fish and chips |
Higher acidity tastes sharper, but sugar and age soften the bite. A well-aged balsamic tastes gentler than its numbers suggest.
What to buy
Nana’s ranking:
- Red wine vinegar. The everyday salad vinegar.
- Apple cider vinegar. Slaw, pickles, barbecue, and a parve buttermilk swap.
- Distilled white vinegar. A jug for canning, pickling and cleaning.
- Everyday balsamic. For tomatoes, glazes and roasted vegetables.
- Rice vinegar. If you cook Asian food or like gentle dressings.
- Sherry vinegar. The splurge that pays off; a teaspoon wakes up a pot of lentils.
Skip: flavored vinegars (raspberry, fig) you’ll use once, and white balsamic unless you love it.
Red wine vinegar
Bold and fruity, with enough acidity to stand up to olive oil, garlic and oregano. It’s the base of most vinaigrettes and a good partner for beef, lentils and beans.
- What it is
- Red wine fermented a second time by acetic-acid bacteria until the alcohol turns to vinegar, usually 6 to 7 percent acidity.
- Tastes like
- Bold, fruity and sharp, with a faint tannic grip.
- Use it for
- Everyday vinaigrette, Greek salad, marinades for beef and chicken, pickled red onions, and brightening lentil soup or a braise.
Out of it? Swap in
- Sherry vinegarRounder and nuttier; use a touch less.
- White wine vinegarLighter and cleaner; won't tint the food pink.
- Apple cider vinegarFruitier and softer, fine in a pinch.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA mid-priced bottle. The cheapest ones are harsh and thin.
Nana's tip: For a basic vinaigrette, 1 part red wine vinegar to 3 parts olive oil, a dab of mustard, salt, and shake.
White wine and champagne vinegar
Cleaner and more delicate than red. Use it where you don’t want pink-tinted food: potato salad, dressings for tender lettuces, pickled shallots, and butter sauces like béarnaise and beurre blanc. Champagne vinegar is gentler still.
White wine vinegar
Also called champagne vinegar
- What it is
- Vinegar made from white wine, about 5 to 7 percent acidity. Champagne vinegar is a gentler version made from champagne-style wine.
- Tastes like
- Clean, crisp and lightly fruity; softer than red wine vinegar.
- Use it for
- Delicate vinaigrettes, béarnaise and beurre blanc, pickling shallots, potato salad, and fish.
Out of it? Swap in
- Rice vinegarMilder and sweeter; use a little more.
- Red wine vinegarStronger and pink-tinted; use a little less.
- Lemon juiceBrighter and more floral.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOptional if you have red wine and rice vinegar. Champagne vinegar is worth it if you make a lot of salads.
Nana's tip: Soak sliced shallots in it with a pinch of salt for 10 minutes before making a dressing. They lose their harsh bite and you use the vinegar in the dressing.
Apple cider vinegar
Fruity and soft, the American farmhouse vinegar. It’s the right acid for coleslaw, pulled chicken or brisket sauce, quick pickles and braised red cabbage. Raw, cloudy versions with the “mother” taste a bit more of apple; filtered is fine for cooking.
Apple cider vinegar
Also called cider vinegar, ACV
- What it is
- Fermented apple cider turned to vinegar, usually 5 percent acidity. Sold filtered and clear, or raw and cloudy with the mother.
- Tastes like
- Bright, fruity and a little sweet, with a soft apple finish.
- Use it for
- Coleslaw, barbecue sauce and pulled meats, quick pickles, braised cabbage, chicken marinades, and souring plant milk for parve "buttermilk".
The kinds you'll see
- Filtered — Clear and consistent. For cooking and pickling.
- Raw, unfiltered, with the mother — Cloudy, more apple flavor. Fine for dressings; no reason to pay extra for cooking.
Out of it? Swap in
- White wine vinegarCrisper and less fruity.
- Distilled vinegar plus a pinch of sugarSharper and flat-tasting, but works for pickles.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA big bottle; you'll use it more than you think.
Nana's tip: For a parve buttermilk swap, stir 1 tablespoon into a cup of soy or oat milk and let it sit 5 minutes.
Distilled white vinegar
Sharp and plain, made from distilled grain alcohol. Its flavor is nothing special, but its consistent 5 percent acidity makes it the standard for canning.
Distilled white vinegar
Also called white vinegar, spirit vinegar
- What it is
- Vinegar fermented from distilled grain alcohol (in the US, usually corn), diluted to 5 percent acidity. Clear, cheap and consistent.
- Tastes like
- Sharp, sour and nothing else.
- Use it for
- Canning and pickling, poaching eggs, sour pickles, hot sauce, and kitchen cleaning.
The kinds you'll see
- 5 percent — The standard for cooking and the only strength tested canning recipes assume.
- Cleaning vinegar (6 percent and up) — For cleaning only. Not labeled or sold as food.
Out of it? Swap in
- Apple cider vinegarFruitier, slightly colored. Fine for pickles if the label says 5 percent.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA gallon jug, between pickling and cleaning.
Nana's tip: A tablespoon in the poaching water helps egg whites set before they spread.
Food safety
For canned pickles, use a vinegar labeled 5 percent acidity and a tested recipe, and never dilute the vinegar more than the recipe says. The acid is what makes shelf-stable pickles safe. Homemade vinegar’s acidity is unknown, so don’t use it for canning (National Center for Home Food Preservation). Refrigerator pickles are more forgiving.
Balsamic: three very different things
The word “balsamic” covers a two-dollar bottle and a hundred-dollar one. Here’s how to read the label.
| Grade | Made from | Aged | Texture | Use |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional Balsamic Vinegar DOP (Modena or Reggio Emilia) | Cooked grape must only | At least 12 years; “extra vecchio” 25+ | Thick, syrupy | A few drops on cheese, strawberries, risotto. Never cooked |
| Condimento | Usually must, sometimes wine vinegar | Varies | Medium to thick | Drizzling; quality varies, taste first |
| Balsamic Vinegar of Modena IGP | Cooked must plus wine vinegar, caramel allowed | At least 60 days; “invecchiato” 3+ years | Thin to medium | Everyday dressings, glazes, marinades |
| Balsamic glaze | Reduced balsamic, often thickened and sweetened | — | Syrupy | Drizzling; easy to overdo |
Buying everyday balsamic: look for grape must (“mosto d’uva”) listed first, and IGP on the label. If it’s very cheap and thin, it’s mostly wine vinegar with coloring.
Make your own glaze: simmer 1 cup of everyday balsamic until reduced by half and it coats a spoon, 10 to 15 minutes. It thickens more as it cools. Open a window; it’s sharp while it simmers.
Balsamic vinegar
Also called aceto balsamico, balsamic glaze
- What it is
- Italian vinegar from cooked grape must, aged in wood. Everyday balsamic is must blended with wine vinegar; the traditional kind is must alone, aged for at least 12 years.
- Tastes like
- Sweet-sour, dark, and figgy; the aged ones are thick, mellow and almost syrupy.
- Use it for
- Dressing tomatoes and greens, glazing roasted vegetables and chicken, strawberries, drizzling over cheese, and finishing grilled meat.
The kinds you'll see
- Balsamic Vinegar of Modena IGP — The everyday grade. Must and wine vinegar, aged at least 60 days; "invecchiato" means 3 years or more.
- Traditional Balsamic DOP (Modena or Reggio Emilia) — Cooked must only, aged 12 to 25+ years, sold in tiny bottles. A few drops at a time, never cooked.
- Condimento — An unregulated middle grade. Quality varies; taste before you buy.
- Balsamic glaze — Balsamic reduced and often thickened and sweetened. Handy, but easy to overuse.
Out of it? Swap in
- Red wine vinegar plus a little honey or brown sugarRight sweet-sour balance, no depth.
- Pomegranate molasses, thinned with a little vinegarFruity and tart, a good parve dressing swap.
Diet & allergens
BuyingAn IGP bottle with grape must listed first and no caramel color for everyday use. Skip the cheapest thin, harsh bottles.
Nana's tip: Make your own glaze by simmering 1 cup of everyday balsamic until it's reduced by half and coats a spoon, about 10 to 15 minutes. It thickens more as it cools.
Sherry vinegar
Made from sherry and aged in oak, it’s nutty and round with a long finish, and strong (often 7 to 8 percent). It’s the secret in good gazpacho and the best vinegar for deglazing a pan after chicken or mushrooms. Use a little less than you would red wine vinegar.
Sherry vinegar
Also called vinagre de Jerez
- What it is
- Spanish vinegar made from sherry and aged in oak barrels, often 7 to 8 percent acidity.
- Tastes like
- Nutty, round and deep, with a long, slightly sweet finish; sharper than balsamic, mellower than red wine vinegar.
- Use it for
- Gazpacho, vinaigrettes for bitter greens, deglazing a pan after chicken or mushrooms, lentils, and brightening roasted vegetables.
The kinds you'll see
- Vinagre de Jerez — Aged at least 6 months.
- Reserva — Aged 2 years or more. Rounder; for dressings.
Out of it? Swap in
- Red wine vinegarThinner and less nutty.
- Red wine vinegar with a few drops of balsamicClose in body and depth.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne bottle, if you make salads and pan sauces often. It's the one Nana splurges on.
Nana's tip: A teaspoon stirred into a pot of lentils, beans or mushroom soup at the end does what extra salt can't.
Rice vinegar
Mild and slightly sweet, with the lowest acidity of the common vinegars. Buy unseasoned for general cooking; seasoned rice vinegar has sugar and salt added for sushi rice.
Rice vinegar
Also called rice wine vinegar, komezu
- What it is
- Vinegar fermented from rice wine. Mild, around 4% acidity compared with 5% or more for most Western vinegars.
- Tastes like
- Soft, clean and gently sweet, with none of the sharp bite of white vinegar.
- Use it for
- Sushi rice, quick pickles, slaws, cucumber salads, dipping sauces, dressings and sweet-sour sauces.
The kinds you'll see
- Unseasoned (plain) — Buy this one. You control the sugar and salt.
- Seasoned rice vinegar — Has sugar and salt added for sushi rice. Fine for slaws; cut the sugar in the recipe if you use it.
- Chinese black vinegar (Chinkiang) — Dark, malty and smoky, from glutinous rice and grains. For dumpling sauces and braises; not interchangeable.
Out of it? Swap in
- Apple cider vinegar or white wine vinegar, cut with a splash of water and a pinch of sugarClose enough for dressings and pickles.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA plain, unseasoned bottle. The label should say rice and water, maybe salt.
Nana's tip: For fast pickles, dissolve 1 tablespoon sugar and 1 teaspoon salt in 1/2 cup (120 ml) rice vinegar and pour over sliced cucumbers or radishes. Ready in 20 minutes.
Which vinegar for which job
| Job | First choice | Also good |
|---|---|---|
| Everyday green salad | Red wine | Sherry, white wine |
| Tomato salad | Balsamic | Red wine, sherry |
| Coleslaw | Apple cider | Distilled plus sugar |
| Potato salad | White wine | Apple cider |
| Quick pickled onions | Red wine or apple cider | Rice |
| Canned pickles | Distilled (5%) | Apple cider (5%) |
| Asian dressings and slaws | Rice | — |
| Pan sauce for chicken or mushrooms | Sherry | White wine |
| Brisket, barbecue sauce | Apple cider | Red wine |
| Lentils, beans, bean soup | Sherry | Red wine |
| Roasted vegetables | Balsamic | Sherry |
| Poaching eggs | Distilled | White wine |
How to use vinegar
- The 3-to-1 vinaigrette. 3 parts oil to 1 part vinegar, a little mustard to hold the Emulsion, salt and pepper. Use 2 to 1 for milder vinegars like rice or a good balsamic.
- Finish with it. A teaspoon stirred into soup, stew, beans or a braise right before serving brightens everything. Add, stir, taste, repeat.
- Tame raw onion. Soak sliced shallots or red onion in vinegar with a pinch of salt for 10 minutes before making a dressing.
- Balance sweetness. A splash fixes a too-sweet sauce or glaze; see Too Salty, Spicy, Sweet or Sour?.
- Use nonreactive pans. Vinegar reacts with bare aluminum and cast iron, turning food metallic and gray. Use stainless, enameled or glass for long simmering or marinating.
Nana's tip
If your soup tastes like it’s missing something and salt didn’t fix it, it’s missing acid. Start with half a teaspoon of vinegar for a big pot.
Kosher note
Wine-based vinegars (red wine, white wine, champagne, sherry and balsamic) are grape products, and most authorities require them to be made from kosher wine, so they need a reliable hechsher. Kosher balsamic, including aged grades, is easy to find; kosher sherry vinegar is harder, so check. Other vinegars also need a hechsher, since they’re often made on the same equipment. Passover: distilled vinegar is often made from grain alcohol (chametz) or corn (kitniyot for Ashkenazim), and malt vinegar is made from barley; use only vinegars certified kosher for Passover. Ask your rabbi where customs differ.
Storing vinegar
Vinegar preserves itself. Keep it capped in a cupboard; no fridge needed. Flavor is best within a couple of years of opening, but it doesn’t spoil. A cloudy, jelly-like disc called a mother sometimes forms in wine and cider vinegars. It’s harmless live vinegar culture; strain it out, or use it to start your own vinegar.
Common mistakes
- Only using it in salad. Vinegar belongs in soups, stews, beans and sauces too, at the end.
- Cooking fine aged balsamic. Heat drives off what you paid for. Drizzle it.
- Substituting seasoned rice vinegar for plain. It adds sugar and salt you didn’t plan for.
- Canning with homemade or low-acid vinegar. Unsafe. Use 5 percent commercial vinegar and a tested recipe.
- Marinating in aluminum or cast iron. Metallic taste and off color. Use glass or stainless.
- Marinating fish too long. Acid “cooks” the surface and turns it mushy in under an hour.