In a recipe, sugar does at least five jobs: it sweetens, holds onto water so things stay moist, browns in the oven, softens gluten so baked goods are tender, and helps butter trap air when you cream it. Change the sugar and you change all five. That’s why swapping honey for sugar doesn’t just make a cake taste different; it makes it darker, denser and moister.
The sweeteners at a glance
| Sweetener | Water | Sweetness vs. sugar | Grams per cup | Texture it gives | Flavor |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Granulated sugar | 0% | Baseline | 200 g | Crisp edges, light crumb, spread | Clean |
| Brown sugar, light | about 2% | About the same | 213 g packed | Soft, chewy, moist | Caramel |
| Brown sugar, dark | about 3% | About the same | 213 g packed | Chewier, moister | Deep toffee, slight bitterness |
| Powdered sugar | 0% (has starch) | About the same | about 120 g | Smooth, tender, short | Clean, faintly chalky raw |
| Honey | about 17% | Sweeter | about 340 g | Dense, moist, browns fast | Floral |
| Maple syrup | about 32% | Less sweet | about 315 g | Moist, soft | Caramel, woody |
| Molasses | about 20–25% | Much less sweet | about 330 g | Dense, soft, dark | Bittersweet, smoky |
| Silan (date syrup) (date syrup) | about 20–25% | Less sweet | about 330 g | Moist, dark | Fruity, raisiny |
The liquids are heavy: a cup of honey weighs over 1 1/2 times a cup of sugar. Swap by the chart below, not by guessing.
What sugar does in baking
- Moisture. Sugar grabs and holds water. More sugar, or wetter sugar, means a softer cake that stays fresh longer.
- Tenderness. Sugar gets between flour proteins and keeps gluten from tightening. Cut the sugar in half and a cake turns tough and bready.
- Browning. Sugars caramelize and feed the Maillard reaction. Honey and maple brown faster than white sugar; see Browning: Maillard vs. Caramelization.
- Spread. In cookies, white sugar melts and lets dough spread thin and crisp. Brown sugar’s moisture keeps them thicker and chewier.
- Air. Sharp sugar crystals cut tiny pockets into butter during Creaming. Liquid sweeteners can’t do that; see Creaming & Folding.
Granulated sugar
The baseline. White sugar is pure sucrose, dry and neutral, so recipes are written around it. Superfine (caster) dissolves faster for meringues and drinks; pulse granulated in a food processor for 30 seconds to make your own. Turbinado and demerara are big golden crystals for crunchy tops, not for creaming.
Granulated sugar
Also called white sugar, sugar, caster sugar, superfine sugar
- What it is
- Refined sucrose from sugarcane or sugar beets, in fine, dry crystals.
- Tastes like
- Pure, clean sweetness with nothing else behind it.
- Use it for
- Nearly all baking, creaming with butter, meringue, caramel, syrups, jam, and balancing acid in tomato sauce and dressings.
The kinds you'll see
- Granulated — The everyday crystal. 200 g per cup.
- Superfine (caster) — Finer crystals that dissolve fast. Best for meringue and cocktails. Pulse granulated in a food processor for 30 seconds to make it.
- Turbinado or demerara — Large golden crystals with a light molasses flavor. For crunchy tops on muffins and challah, not for mixing in.
Out of it? Swap in
- Light brown sugar, packed, same weightSofter, chewier, more caramel flavor, slightly darker.
- Honey, about 3/4 the amountSee the sweeteners guide; you need to cut liquid and lower the oven.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA 4- or 5-pound bag. Store-brand cane or beet sugar works the same.
Nana's tip: Creaming butter and sugar for a full 3 to 5 minutes, until pale, is what makes a cake light; the sharp crystals punch air into the fat.
Brown sugar, light and dark
Brown sugar is white sugar with molasses stirred back in, about 3.5 percent for light and 6.5 percent for dark. That small amount of molasses makes it moist, soft, slightly acidic and caramel-flavored.
- Light brown: the default for chocolate chip cookies, crumbles and glazes.
- Dark brown: for gingerbread, barbecue sauce, baked beans and anything where you want molasses flavor in front.
- They’re interchangeable cup for cup; dark gives deeper flavor and a little more chew.
Measure it packed: press it into the cup firmly so it holds the cup’s shape when turned out.
DIY brown sugar
| You want | Mix |
|---|---|
| 1 cup light brown sugar | 1 cup (200 g) granulated + 1 Tbsp (20 g) molasses |
| 1 cup dark brown sugar | 1 cup (200 g) granulated + 2 Tbsp (40 g) molasses |
Work it together with a fork or your fingertips, or a few pulses in a food processor, until no streaks remain.
Brown sugar
Also called light brown sugar, dark brown sugar
- What it is
- White sugar with molasses mixed back in, about 3.5 percent for light and 6.5 percent for dark. The molasses makes it moist, soft and slightly acidic.
- Tastes like
- Caramel and toffee; dark brown tastes deeper and slightly bitter, like a mild molasses.
- Use it for
- Chewy cookies, sticky glazes for salmon and chicken, barbecue sauce, oatmeal, crumb toppings and spice cakes.
The kinds you'll see
- Light brown — The default. Measure it firmly packed, about 213 g per cup.
- Dark brown — Twice the molasses. Gingerbread, baked beans, rich glazes.
Out of it? Swap in
- DIY brown sugar1 cup granulated plus 1 tablespoon molasses for light, 2 for dark. Mix with a fork or your fingers until even.
- Granulated sugar, same weightCrisper, paler, flatter cookies with less flavor.
- Coconut sugarSimilar caramel flavor, drier and grainier.
Diet & allergens
BuyingLight brown is enough for most kitchens; add dark if you make gingerbread or barbecue sauce.
Nana's tip: Rock-hard brown sugar softens overnight sealed with a slice of bread, or in 20 to 30 seconds in the microwave under a damp paper towel.
Nana's tip
Brown sugar turned into a rock? Seal it overnight with a slice of bread, or cover it with a damp paper towel and microwave 20 to 30 seconds. Store it airtight and it won’t happen again.
Powdered sugar
Powdered sugar is granulated sugar milled to dust, with about 3 percent starch to keep it from caking. It dissolves instantly, which makes it the only sugar for smooth uncooked frosting and glaze. It also makes shortbread and some cookies extra tender. Always sift it; lumps never beat out.
DIY: blend 1 cup granulated with 1 tablespoon cornstarch (or potato starch) in a blender for about a minute, then let the dust settle before you open the lid.
Powdered sugar
Also called confectioners' sugar, icing sugar, 10X sugar
- What it is
- Granulated sugar ground to a fine powder, with about 3 percent starch mixed in so it doesn't cake.
- Tastes like
- Sweet with a faint chalky finish from the starch, noticeable in uncooked frosting.
- Use it for
- Frosting and glaze, dusting cakes and rugelach, whipped cream that holds, and tender shortbread.
Out of it? Swap in
- DIY powdered sugarBlend 1 cup granulated with 1 tablespoon cornstarch (or potato starch) in a blender until fine, about 1 minute. Let the dust settle before opening.
- Superfine sugarFor whipped cream only. Doesn't make frosting.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA 2-pound bag. Look for "potato starch" on the label before Passover.
Nana's tip: Always sift it for frosting and glaze. It weighs about 120 g per cup unsifted, so measure by weight if you can.
Liquid sweeteners
Honey
Honey is sweeter than sugar, about 17 percent water, and browns quickly because it’s mostly fructose and glucose. Honey cakes are dark, dense and moist for that reason, and they get better after a day or two wrapped up.
Honey
Also called raw honey
- What it is
- Nectar concentrated by bees into a thick syrup, mostly fructose and glucose with about 17 percent water. Flavor depends on the flowers.
- Tastes like
- Floral and rounded. Clover is mild; wildflower is fuller; buckwheat is dark, malty and almost molasses-like.
- Use it for
- Honey cake and Rosh Hashanah baking, glazes and marinades, dressings, tea, and drizzling on cheese, yogurt or challah.
The kinds you'll see
- Liquid (clover, orange blossom, wildflower) — The everyday kind for cooking and baking.
- Creamed or whipped — Crystallized on purpose into a spread. For toast, not for measuring.
- Raw — Strained but not heated. Crystallizes faster. Save it for drizzling, where its aroma shows.
Out of it? Swap in
- Maple syrup, same amountThinner, less sweet, with a different flavor.
- Silan (date syrup)Darker and fruitier. Traditional on Rosh Hashanah in many Sephardi homes.
Diet & allergens
BuyingA mild clover or wildflower for baking; a small jar of something special for the table.
Nana's tip: Oil or spray your measuring cup first and the honey slides right out. Crystallized honey melts back in a bowl of warm water.
Food safety
Never give honey, raw or cooked into food, to a baby under 12 months old. It can carry botulism spores that a baby’s gut can’t handle (CDC). This is not a concern for older children and adults.
Maple syrup
Pure maple syrup is maple sap boiled down about 40 to 1. It’s thinner and less sweet than honey. The darker grades (Dark Robust, Very Dark Strong) carry more flavor through the oven. “Pancake syrup” is flavored corn syrup and is not a substitute.
Maple syrup
Also called pure maple syrup
- What it is
- Sap from sugar maples boiled down about 40 to 1 into syrup. Nothing added.
- Tastes like
- Caramel and vanilla with a woody edge; darker grades taste stronger.
- Use it for
- Pancakes and waffles, glazing roasted squash and sweet potatoes, salmon glaze, vinaigrettes, granola, and parve baking.
The kinds you'll see
- Golden, delicate taste — The lightest. For the table.
- Amber, rich taste — The all-rounder.
- Dark, robust taste — The best for baking and cooking; flavor survives the oven.
- Very dark, strong taste — Almost molasses-like. Use in small amounts.
Out of it? Swap in
- Honey, same amountSweeter and floral, no maple.
- Brown sugar plus a little waterFor glazes only.
Diet & allergens
BuyingPure maple, never "pancake" or "table" syrup, which is flavored corn syrup.
Nana's tip: For baking, swap maple syrup for up to half the sugar, and cut the recipe's liquid by about 3 tablespoons per cup of syrup.
Molasses
Molasses is what’s left after sugar is crystallized out of cane juice. It’s bittersweet, dark and acidic, so recipes heavy in molasses lean on baking soda for lift. Buy unsulphured; skip blackstrap unless a recipe names it.
Molasses
Also called treacle, blackstrap
- What it is
- The thick dark syrup left behind when sugar is crystallized out of boiled cane juice. Each extra boil leaves it darker and less sweet.
- Tastes like
- Bittersweet, smoky and dark, with a mineral edge in the darker grades.
- Use it for
- Gingerbread, gingersnaps, baked beans, barbecue sauce, pumpernickel and rye bread, and making your own brown sugar.
The kinds you'll see
- Light (mild) — From the first boil. Sweetest.
- Dark (robust, full) — From the second boil. The usual baking molasses.
- Blackstrap — From the third boil. Bitter and strong; don't swap it in for regular unless a recipe asks.
- Unsulphured vs. sulphured — Buy unsulphured. Sulphured has a harsher, chemical edge and contains sulphites.
Out of it? Swap in
- Dark brown sugarAbout 3/4 cup packed per 1/4 cup molasses, plus a little liquid. Less depth.
- Silan or dark honeyDifferent flavor, similar body.
Diet & allergens
BuyingOne small jar of unsulphured mild or dark molasses.
Nana's tip: Molasses is acidic, so recipes heavy in it rely on baking soda for lift. Don't swap in baking powder alone.
Silan (date syrup)
Silan is a thick, dark syrup cooked from dates, long used in Middle Eastern Jewish kitchens and a Rosh Hashanah favorite in many homes alongside honey. It’s fruity and less sweet than honey. Use it in glazes, dressings, on tahini, and in place of honey or molasses in most recipes.
Silan (date syrup)
Also called date syrup, date honey, dibs
- What it is
- Dates cooked down and pressed into a dark, thick syrup. Usually nothing added.
- Tastes like
- Deep caramel and dried fruit, less sweet and more mellow than honey, with a hint of molasses.
- Use it for
- Drizzled over tahini, yogurt and pancakes, in marinades for chicken and roasted vegetables, salad dressings, and baking for Rosh Hashanah.
Out of it? Swap in
- HoneySweeter and more floral; use about three-quarters as much.
- Maple syrup with a little molassesThinner, but close in color and depth.
Diet & allergens
BuyingPure silan lists only dates. Avoid "date-flavored" syrups padded with glucose.
Nana's tip: A tahini-and-silan drizzle (equal parts) over vanilla ice cream or a sliced banana is an Israeli staple dessert in under a minute.
Corn syrup, agave and others
- Light corn syrup is mostly glucose. It keeps candy, caramel and sorbet from turning grainy because it gets in the way of sugar crystals. A tablespoon or two in caramel is insurance.
- Agave is thin and very sweet; fine in drinks, rarely worth baking with.
- Coconut sugar behaves like a slightly drier brown sugar.
How to swap one for another
| Swap | For 1 cup of the original, use | Also do | What changes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brown for white sugar | 1 cup packed brown | Nothing | Softer, chewier, darker, more caramel |
| White for brown sugar | 1 cup white + 1 Tbsp molasses (or skip the molasses) | — | Without molasses: crisper, paler, flatter |
| Honey for sugar | 3/4 cup honey | Cut other liquid by 3 Tbsp; add 1/4 tsp baking soda; lower oven 25°F (15°C) | Denser, moister, browns faster, floral |
| Maple for sugar (up to half the sugar) | 3/4 cup maple per cup sugar replaced | Cut liquid by 3 Tbsp per cup of syrup; lower oven 25°F | Moister, softer, maple flavor |
| Silan for honey | 1 cup silan | Nothing | Darker, fruitier, less sweet |
| Maple for honey | 1 cup maple | Expect a thinner batter | Less sweet, browns less |
| Powdered for white sugar | Don’t, in cakes | — | The starch and fine texture change the crumb |
Why it works
Liquid sweeteners bring water, so you take some out elsewhere. Honey and maple are acidic, so a pinch of baking soda balances them and helps the rise. They brown faster than sugar, so a slightly cooler oven keeps the outside from darkening before the middle is done.
Cutting sugar: most cake and cookie recipes tolerate a 20 to 25 percent cut. Beyond that, expect drier, tougher, paler results that go stale sooner, because you’ve cut the moisture and tenderness too.
Kosher note
Sugars and syrups are parve. Honey is kosher even though bees aren’t; the Talmud explains that bees store nectar rather than make honey from their bodies. Buy honey, maple and syrups with a hechsher where you can, since processing equipment and additives matter. Passover: regular powdered sugar contains cornstarch, which is kitniyot for most Ashkenazim; Passover powdered sugar is made with potato starch. Corn syrup is kitniyot too. Customs vary; ask your rabbi.
Storing sugars
- White and powdered: airtight, in a dry cupboard. They last indefinitely.
- Brown sugar: airtight, with the air pressed out. Never in the fridge, which dries it.
- Honey and molasses: cupboard. Crystallized honey melts back in a bowl of warm water.
- Maple syrup: fridge once opened, or it can mold.
Common mistakes
- Not packing brown sugar. Loose brown sugar can be a quarter short, and cookies turn out dry and cakey.
- Swapping honey cup for cup without changing anything. Batter too wet, cake too dark outside and gummy inside.
- Cutting the sugar in half to make it less sweet. You get a dry, tough, pale bake. Cut by a quarter, at most.
- Creaming with liquid sweeteners. They can’t hold air. Cream butter with the dry sugar first, then beat in the honey.
- Skipping the sift for powdered sugar. Lumpy frosting doesn’t smooth out.
- Using pancake syrup in a recipe for maple. It’s corn syrup with flavoring and bakes up flat-tasting.
If a cake or cookie still disappoints, start with Baking Troubleshooting.