Vanilla extract
Also called vanilla, vanilla sugar, vanilla bean paste
- What it is
- Cured vanilla orchid pods soaked in alcohol and water until the alcohol draws out their flavor. Imitation vanilla is synthetic vanillin.
- Tastes like
- Warm, floral, creamy and sweet-smelling; it rounds out sugar, chocolate and eggs and makes desserts taste "finished."
- Use it for
- Nearly every cake, cookie, custard, whipped cream, frosting and French toast; a drop in hot chocolate or fruit compote.
The kinds you'll see
- Pure extract — The everyday choice; best in uncooked or lightly cooked things like whipped cream and custard.
- Imitation / vanillin — Cheaper and honestly fine in cookies and cakes baked at high heat, where the subtle notes bake off anyway.
- Vanilla bean / paste — Speckled and most aromatic. For ice cream, panna cotta, crème brûlée. 1 bean ≈ 1 Tbsp paste ≈ 1 Tbsp extract.
- Vanilla sugar — Sugar flavored with vanilla, sold in small packets. Common in Israeli and European recipes; one 10-g packet ≈ 1 tsp extract plus 2 tsp sugar.
Out of it? Swap in
- Imitation vanilla, same amountFlatter in custard and cream; hard to tell apart in baked goods.
- Vanilla sugar (one 10-g packet per tsp extract; reduce sugar by 2 tsp)Works well in batters and doughs.
- Bourbon, brandy or dark rum, same amountA different warmth, but it fills the gap in a pinch.
Diet & allergens
No major allergens
StoreTightly capped, in a dark cupboard away from heat.
KeepsPure extract keeps for years; the alcohol preserves it. Vanilla sugar about 1 year.
Toss whenThe aroma has faded to mostly alcohol, or a vanilla bean has gone brittle and scentless.
BuyingA 4-oz (118-ml) bottle of pure extract with a hechsher. Prices swing with the vanilla harvest; imitation is a reasonable backup for cookies.
Nana's tip: Add vanilla once a custard or sauce is off the heat; its aroma is volatile and boils away.