Vanilla extract
Photo: bert_m_b, CC BY 2.0 · Flickr

Vanilla extract

Also called vanilla, vanilla sugar, vanilla bean paste

Essential
What it is
Cured vanilla orchid pods soaked in alcohol and water until the alcohol draws out their flavor. Imitation vanilla is synthetic vanillin.
Tastes like
Warm, floral, creamy and sweet-smelling; it rounds out sugar, chocolate and eggs and makes desserts taste "finished."
Use it for
Nearly every cake, cookie, custard, whipped cream, frosting and French toast; a drop in hot chocolate or fruit compote.

The kinds you'll see

  • Pure extract — The everyday choice; best in uncooked or lightly cooked things like whipped cream and custard.
  • Imitation / vanillin — Cheaper and honestly fine in cookies and cakes baked at high heat, where the subtle notes bake off anyway.
  • Vanilla bean / paste — Speckled and most aromatic. For ice cream, panna cotta, crème brûlée. 1 bean ≈ 1 Tbsp paste ≈ 1 Tbsp extract.
  • Vanilla sugar — Sugar flavored with vanilla, sold in small packets. Common in Israeli and European recipes; one 10-g packet ≈ 1 tsp extract plus 2 tsp sugar.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Imitation vanilla, same amountFlatter in custard and cream; hard to tell apart in baked goods.
  • Vanilla sugar (one 10-g packet per tsp extract; reduce sugar by 2 tsp)Works well in batters and doughs.
  • Bourbon, brandy or dark rum, same amountA different warmth, but it fills the gap in a pinch.

Diet & allergens

No major allergens
StoreTightly capped, in a dark cupboard away from heat.
KeepsPure extract keeps for years; the alcohol preserves it. Vanilla sugar about 1 year.
Toss whenThe aroma has faded to mostly alcohol, or a vanilla bean has gone brittle and scentless.

BuyingA 4-oz (118-ml) bottle of pure extract with a hechsher. Prices swing with the vanilla harvest; imitation is a reasonable backup for cookies.

Nana's tip: Add vanilla once a custard or sauce is off the heat; its aroma is volatile and boils away.

Cook with it

1748 recipes on Nana's Fogón use vanilla extract.

See all 1748 →