Parve margarine & plant-based butter
Photo: Kagor, CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Parve margarine & plant-based butter

Also called pareve margarine, vegan butter, nondairy margarine

Essential
What it is
A spreadable fat made from vegetable oils and water, made without milk so it can go into meat meals and parve baking.
Tastes like
Neutral to mildly buttery, depending on the brand. None taste quite like real butter.
Use it for
Pie crusts, cookies, cakes and kugels for a meat meal, sautéing where you want a butter flavor, and spreading on challah at a meat dinner.

The kinds you'll see

  • Sticks (baking margarine) — About 80% fat, close to butter. The one to bake with.
  • Tubs and spreads — More water and air, sometimes as little as 40% fat. Fine for toast; makes cookies spread and pastry soggy.
  • Plant-based butter sticks — Usually blends of coconut, palm and other oils. Behave most like butter in baking; check for a parve hechsher.

Out of it? Swap in

  • Refined coconut oilFirm and flaky in crusts, but sets harder when cold and melts faster. Use about 20% less.
  • Neutral oil (3/4 cup for each 1 cup margarine)Fine in cakes and muffins; won't cream or make flaky pastry.

Diet & allergens

Soy
StoreRefrigerate. Sticks freeze well.
Keeps3 to 4 months in the fridge; 6 months or more frozen.
Toss whenIt smells sour or stale or has darkened and gone translucent at the edges.

BuyingSticks with a clear parve symbol and at least 80% fat (check that it's sold as margarine, not "spread").

Nana's tip: For pie crust, cut the sticks into cubes and freeze them for 15 minutes first. Margarine softens faster than butter, and cold fat is what makes flakes.

Cook with it

212 recipes on Nana's Fogón use parve margarine & plant-based butter.

See all 212 →