Parve margarine & plant-based butter
Also called pareve margarine, vegan butter, nondairy margarine
- What it is
- A spreadable fat made from vegetable oils and water, made without milk so it can go into meat meals and parve baking.
- Tastes like
- Neutral to mildly buttery, depending on the brand. None taste quite like real butter.
- Use it for
- Pie crusts, cookies, cakes and kugels for a meat meal, sautéing where you want a butter flavor, and spreading on challah at a meat dinner.
The kinds you'll see
- Sticks (baking margarine) — About 80% fat, close to butter. The one to bake with.
- Tubs and spreads — More water and air, sometimes as little as 40% fat. Fine for toast; makes cookies spread and pastry soggy.
- Plant-based butter sticks — Usually blends of coconut, palm and other oils. Behave most like butter in baking; check for a parve hechsher.
Out of it? Swap in
- Refined coconut oilFirm and flaky in crusts, but sets harder when cold and melts faster. Use about 20% less.
- Neutral oil (3/4 cup for each 1 cup margarine)Fine in cakes and muffins; won't cream or make flaky pastry.
Diet & allergens
Soy
StoreRefrigerate. Sticks freeze well.
Keeps3 to 4 months in the fridge; 6 months or more frozen.
Toss whenIt smells sour or stale or has darkened and gone translucent at the edges.
BuyingSticks with a clear parve symbol and at least 80% fat (check that it's sold as margarine, not "spread").
Nana's tip: For pie crust, cut the sticks into cubes and freeze them for 15 minutes first. Margarine softens faster than butter, and cold fat is what makes flakes.