Ingredients
- 1 ½ pounds bone-in beef short rib
- 2 ½ pounds beef shank or oxtail
- 2 pounds beef knucklebones or neck bones, or a combination of both (or add 1 more pound beef shank or oxtail)
- 2 tablespoons extra-virgin olive oil About extra-virgin olive oil →
- 2 tablespoons tomato paste About tomato paste →
- ¼ cup apple cider vinegar About apple cider vinegar →
- 3 carrots, peeled and coarsely chopped
- 3 celery stalks, coarsely chopped
- 2 onions, halved and peeled About yellow onion →
- 1 (14.5-ounce) can tomatoes (they can be whole, peeled or diced)
- 1 head garlic, excess skins removed, top chopped off to expose the cloves About garlic →
- 2 bay leaves About bay leaves →
- 1 bunch fresh flat-leaf parsley About parsley →
- ½ bunch fresh thyme About thyme →
- ¼ ounce dried shiitake mushrooms About shiitake mushrooms →
- 1 tablespoon black peppercorns Peppery, not chile heat. Swap: White pepper
Prep first
Get these done before you turn on the heat. Cooks call it mise en place.
Steps
-
1
Heat oven to 350 degrees. Place meat and bones in a roasting pan or on a large rimmed baking sheet. Drizzle with olive oil, turning to coat, then brush all over with tomato paste. Roast until browned, 30 to 35 minutes. They don’t need to cook all the way through but to just develop some color.
-
2
Put roasted meat and bones in a 12-quart stockpot and add vinegar and enough cold water to cover by 3 inches (about 6 quarts). Bring to a boil, then reduce to a low simmer, uncovered, for 2 to 3 hours. While simmering, occasionally skim fat and foam from the top using a ladle.
-
3
Add all the remaining ingredients. Continue to simmer, uncovered, for a minimum of 3 hours. If using knucklebones, simmer overnight, 9 to 15 hours, so the knucklebones have sufficient time to break down.
-
4
Remove meat and bones with a slotted spoon or tongs; reserve meat for another use (such as soup). Pour broth through a fine-mesh strainer into a large heatproof bowl. Once broth has cooled, store in the refrigerator in an airtight container.
Flavor map
How Nana pairs flavors →This one is savory, garlicky and herby.
Goes well with
Serve it with
Polish Lazanki
67% flavor match
The cider vinegar and tomato cut through the cream; shiitake mushroom with oyster mushroom is a natural match.
Serve it with
Quail on Toast by Ed Szymanski
67% flavor match
Bay leaf and thyme are a classic pair; they share thyme and olive oil.
Then
Chicken Lo Mein
52% flavor match
Both lean on carrot and garlic; shiitake mushroom with napa cabbage is a natural match.
Then
Chop Suey
52% flavor match
Shiitake mushroom loves shaoxing wine; they share celery and carrot.
Finish with
Red-Wine Roasted Pears With Cardamom Crumble
58% flavor match
A fresh pear finish; star anise loves bay leaf.
Log in to tell Nana which pairings are good. Your votes improve the map.
More about this recipe
Nutrition
1 of 3 servings · about 1295 g Whole recipe · about 3884 g · High confidence
| % DV* | ||
|---|---|---|
| Total Fat | 183 g | 235% |
| Saturated Fat | 72.5 g | 363% |
| Trans Fat | 0 g | |
| Cholesterol | 596 mg | 199% |
| Sodium | 633 mg | 28% |
| Total Carbohydrate | 28.3 g | 10% |
| Dietary Fiber | 8.5 g | 30% |
| Total Sugars | 11.8 g | |
| Protein | 167 g | 334% |
| Vitamin D | 0.005 mcg | 0% |
| Calcium | 242 mg | 19% |
| Iron | 22.2 mg | 123% |
| Potassium | 3960 mg | 84% |
* % Daily Value is based on a 2,000-calorie diet.
- Carbs 5%
- Fat 68%
- Protein 28%
Vitamins & minerals
| Vitamin A | 694 mcg | 77% |
|---|---|---|
| Vitamin C | 74.6 mg | 83% |
| Vitamin D | 0.005 mcg | 0% |
| Vitamin E | 3.2 mg | 21% |
| Vitamin K | 370 mcg | 308% |
| Thiamin (B1) | 0.93 mg | 77% |
| Riboflavin (B2) | 1.4 mg | 111% |
| Niacin (B3) | 32.3 mg | 202% |
| Pantothenic acid (B5) | 3.4 mg | 68% |
| Vitamin B6 | 3.8 mg | 221% |
| Folate | 146 mcg DFE | 36% |
| Vitamin B12 | 28.8 mcg | 1202% |
| Choline | 29 mg | 5% |
| Calcium | 242 mg | 19% |
| Iron | 22.2 mg | 123% |
| Potassium | 3960 mg | 84% |
| Magnesium | 243 mg | 58% |
| Phosphorus | 1700 mg | 136% |
| Zinc | 38.1 mg | 347% |
| Copper | 0.89 mg | 99% |
| Manganese | 1.1 mg | 50% |
| Selenium | 147 mcg | 267% |
Fats & carbs in detail
| Monounsaturated fat | 81.9 g | |
|---|---|---|
| Polyunsaturated fat | 7.4 g | |
| Omega-3 | 1.8 g | 115% |
| Omega-6 | 5.5 g | 33% |
| Starch | 0.9 g | |
| Net carbs | 19.8 g | |
| Omega-6 : Omega-3 ratio | 3.0 : 1 |
Amino acids (protein building blocks)
| Histidine | 5.7 g | |
|---|---|---|
| Isoleucine | 7.5 g | |
| Leucine | 13.1 g | |
| Lysine | 13.7 g | |
| Methionine | 4.2 g | |
| Cystine | 1.9 g | |
| Phenylalanine | 6.5 g | |
| Tyrosine | 5.5 g | |
| Threonine | 7.3 g | |
| Tryptophan | 1.9 g | |
| Valine | 8.1 g |
How we calculated this
| Ingredient | Counted as | g | kcal |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 ½ pounds bone-in beef short rib | Beef, rib, shortribs, separable lean only, choice, raw | 680 | 1191 |
| 2 ½ pounds beef shank or oxtail | Beef, rib, eye, small end (ribs 10-12), separable lean and fat, trimmed to 0" fat, choice, raw | 1134 | 3107 |
| 2 pounds beef knucklebones or neck bones, or a combination of both (or add 1 more pound beef shank or oxtail) | Beef, rib, eye, small end (ribs 10-12), separable lean and fat, trimmed to 0" fat, choice, raw | 907 | 2486 |
| 2 tablespoons extra-virgin olive oil | Oil, olive, salad or cooking | 27 | 239 |
| 2 tablespoons tomato paste | Tomato products, canned, paste, without salt added (Includes foods for USDA's Food Distribution Program) | 33 | 27 |
| ¼ cup apple cider vinegar | Vinegar, cider | 60 | 13 |
| 3 carrots, peeled and coarsely chopped | Carrots, raw | 183 | 75 |
| 3 celery stalks, coarsely chopped | Celery, raw | 120 | 17 |
| 2 onions, halved and peeled | Onions, raw | 220 | 88 |
| 1 (14.5-ounce) can tomatoes (they can be whole, peeled or diced) | Tomatoes, red, ripe, raw, year round average | 411 | 74 |
| 1 head garlic, excess skins removed, top chopped off to expose the cloves | Garlic, raw | 3 | 4 |
| 2 bay leaves | Spices, bay leaf | 1 | 3 |
| 1 bunch fresh flat-leaf parsley | Parsley, fresh | 60 | 22 |
| ½ bunch fresh thyme | Thyme, fresh | 30 | 30 |
| ¼ ounce dried shiitake mushrooms | Mushrooms, white, raw | 7 | 2 |
| 1 tablespoon black peppercorns | Spices, pepper, black | 7 | 19 |
Matched to the USDA FoodData Central database (SR Legacy). Amounts are converted with USDA portion weights where they exist, otherwise typical sizes. Open in the analyzer to adjust a match →
Estimated from the ingredient list — brands, exact sizes and cooking losses vary. Not medical advice.
Allergens
-
Apple
In: ¼ cup apple cider vinegar
-
Red meat (alpha-gal) › Beef & veal
In: 1 ½ pounds bone-in beef short rib; 2 ½ pounds beef shank or oxtail; 2 pounds beef knucklebones or neck bones, or a combination of both (or add 1 more pound beef shank or oxtail)
Mammalian meat and by-products. Alpha-gal syndrome, often from a tick bite, causes delayed reactions to beef, pork, lamb and gelatin; some people also react to dairy.
-
Black & white pepper
In: 1 tablespoon black peppercorns
-
Carrot
In: 3 carrots, peeled and coarsely chopped
-
Celery
In: 3 celery stalks, coarsely chopped
Celery stalks, leaves, seeds and celeriac (a major allergen in Europe).
-
Onion & garlic family › Garlic
In: 1 head garlic, excess skins removed, top chopped off to expose the cloves
Onions, shallots, garlic, leeks, scallions and chives, including powders.
-
Mushrooms & fungi
In: ¼ ounce dried shiitake mushrooms
-
Onion & garlic family › Onion & shallot
In: 2 onions, halved and peeled
Onions, shallots, garlic, leeks, scallions and chives, including powders.
-
Nightshades › Tomato
In: 2 tablespoons tomato paste; 1 (14.5-ounce) can tomatoes (they can be whole, peeled or diced)
Tomato, potato, peppers (sweet and hot), eggplant, tomatillo and goji. Sweet potatoes are not nightshades.
Found by reading the ingredient names. Brands and "may contain" warnings vary, so always check the label.
Questions about this recipe
- Can I make this bone broth ahead of time?
- Yes, you can prepare it in advance and store it in the refrigerator in an airtight container once it has cooled.
- How do I store or freeze the broth?
- Store it in an airtight container in the fridge, or freeze it in portions for easy use in future soups and stews.
- What can I use if I can't find oxtail or knucklebones?
- You can substitute these with additional beef shank or any combination of beef marrow and joint bones available at your butcher.
- How do I know when the broth is done?
- The broth is ready after a minimum of 5 to 6 hours of simmering; however, if using knucklebones, it is done after 9 to 15 hours when the bones have sufficiently broken down.
- What should I serve with this broth?
- While satisfying on its own, it serves as an excellent base for hearty beef soups, stews, or as a rich addition to risotto.
My notes
Log in to keep private notes on recipes.
Learn while you cook
Learn library →- Ingredient Deep-Dives · 7 min read Fresh Herbs Tender herbs go in at the end and live in a jar of water; woody herbs go in early and live in a damp towel. Use 1 part …
- Ingredient Deep-Dives · 8 min read The Onion Family Yellow onions for cooking, red for raw, shallots for sauces; the finer you cut garlic or onion, the stronger it gets, a…
Words in this recipe
- Reduce
- To simmer a liquid so water evaporates, concentrating flavor and thickening it. Learn more
- Simmer
- Liquid just below a boil, about 185 to 205°F, with small bubbles rising gently.
- Skim
- To remove foam, scum or fat from the surface of a simmering liquid.
Handy for this recipe Safe Cooking TemperaturesSubstitution Finder