A crowd isn’t hard to feed; it just needs arithmetic and a timeline. Decide how much to buy, choose one thing that can be cooked ahead and held, then fill in with quick items from the grill. Most of the work should be done before the first guest arrives.
How much to buy
For a meal with sides, plan on 4-6 oz (115-170 g) of cooked boneless meat per adult. That’s about 6-8 oz (170-225 g) raw, because meat loses water in cooking. Bone-in needs roughly a third more. Large smoked or slow-cooked cuts lose 25-35% of their weight, so buy accordingly.
Nana's tip
Round up for teenagers and hungry men, round down when there are lots of sides and kids. Add a couple of extra servings of the main course in any case. Leftover brisket is never a problem.
| Food | Per adult | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Burgers | 1-2 patties of 4-6 oz (115-170 g) | 1½ on average |
| Chicken pieces | 1-2 pieces; about 12 oz (340 g) bone-in | Thighs and legs go further than breasts |
| Ribs | ½-1 lb (225-450 g) | Roughly 3-4 ribs; more if they’re the only meat |
| Brisket | 8-10 oz (225-285 g) raw, trimmed weight | Loses about a third in cooking |
| Pulled meat (shoulder) | 8-10 oz (225-285 g) raw, bone-in | Plus 1 bun each |
| Sausages or hot dogs | 1-2 each | 2 for kids |
| Side dishes | 3-4 types; about ½ cup (120 ml) each | 4-6 oz total each |
| Salad | 1-1½ cups (240-360 ml) | |
| Bread or buns | 1½ per person | |
| Dessert | 1 serving, 2 options for 10+ guests | |
| Drinks | 2-3 per person for the first hour, then 1 per hour | Plus water |
Pick the menu
The best crowd menu has one make-ahead centrepiece plus quick things from the grill. A brisket, pulled pork or a tray of braised chicken is cooked the day before, or hours earlier, and held hot. It frees the grill and the cook. Then grill the fast items to order: sausages, burgers, corn, vegetables. Add cold sides that improve while they sit, like slaws, bean and potato salads and pickles.
Avoid a menu where everything needs the grill at the same moment. A kettle grill holds about 8-10 burgers at once; more than that and you’re juggling.
The timeline
The day before - Shop, and thaw anything frozen in the fridge. - Season the meat, then cook the centrepiece if it’s a slow cut; chill it if you’re reheating, or hold it hot overnight. - Make the slaws, salads, dressings and sauces. Bake the dessert. - Set up the tables, plates, cutlery, ice, coolers and trash bags.
The morning of - Load the drinks into coolers with ice, in the shade. - Start the slow cut now if it needs the day (see Low-and-Slow, Start to Finish). - Chop vegetables, shape patties, thread skewers and slice onions. - Check the gas or charcoal.
The hour before - Light the grill early; it needs to be properly hot. - Move the centrepiece to its holding spot. - Set out cold sides last, over ice. - Put out the sauces and utensils. - Have a separate station for anything that needs its own space (see below).
Holding food hot
Hot food stays safe at 140°F (60°C) or above. USDA’s “danger zone” is 40-140°F (4-60°C), where bacteria multiply fast. Don’t hold below 140°F (60°C). Options:
- A towel-lined insulated cooler. Wrap a large cooked cut in foil, put it in a cooler lined with towels, and close the lid. If it starts at 140°F (60°C) or higher, it can stay safe for several hours. Check it with a thermometer before you serve.
- An oven at 170-200°F (75-95°C). Tent loosely with foil, and add a splash of liquid to stop it drying out.
- Chafing dishes with fuel cans or a warming tray, kept topped up.
Don’t forget to check the temperature and don’t rely on feel. See Cookout Food Safety for more.
Keeping cold food cold
- Set bowls on ice, in a bigger tray or bowl, not just next to ice.
- Put out small amounts and refill from the fridge or cooler, instead of one large bowl that sits for hours.
- Time limit: perishable food shouldn’t sit out for more than 2 hours, or 1 hour when it’s 90°F (32°C) or hotter.
- Mayonnaise and dairy salads are the ones to watch.
Food safety
Time matters as much as temperature. If you can’t tell how long a dish has been out, throw it away. It costs you less than a stomach upset for 20 guests.
The serving line
- Put plates first, then cold sides, then hot, then meat last, so nothing gets cold while people load up.
- Serve from both sides of a table to double the speed.
- Slice meat in advance and keep it hot in its juices.
- Label everything with a small card: name, and whether it contains nuts, dairy, gluten or meat.
- Place drinks away from the food so the line doesn’t clog.
Dietary needs
Plan these at the start, not at the table:
- Vegetarian: give them their own grilled main (portobellos, stuffed peppers, halloumi or veggie burgers), not just sides.
- Gluten-free: gluten-free buns and a sauce that’s labelled gluten-free.
- Allergies: label ingredients, and put them at the start of the line. Keep serving spoons with their own dish.
- Kosher or halal guests: ask in advance what they need. Cook theirs first on clean foil or in a foil pan, with separate tongs, and keep it covered and clearly labelled. Many keep a wholly separate setup; see Grilling Kosher Meat.
- Use separate utensils for every dish and every diet. One spoon in two bowls ruins the work.
Leftovers
Cool and refrigerate within 2 hours (1 hour if it’s 90°F / 32°C or hotter outside). Divide large amounts into shallow containers so they chill quickly; a deep pot of brisket in the fridge cools slowly in the middle. Plan for takeaway containers or foil trays so guests can take some home, and label them with the date. Reheat to 165°F (74°C) before serving.