Nihari (Pakistani Beef Stew)
Printed from nanasfogon.com/recipe/nihari-pakistani-beef-stew · Original: https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/nihari-pakistani-beef-stew
- Total
- About 3 hr 20 min
Ingredients
Dairy-free version. Swapped:
ghee → olive oil or dairy-free plant butter
Good for vegan, lactose-free and kosher meat meals. Check labels: some plant butters and creamers aren't certified parve or contain nuts or coconut.
- 10 green cardamom pods About cardamom →
- 3 black cardamom pods About cardamom →
- 3 black long pepper pods Can't find it? 1 tsp black pepper + a pinch of nutmeg or cinnamon per tsp
- 10 whole cloves
- 1 3"-long cinnamon stick About cinnamon →
- 1 star anise pod About star anise →
- ⅓ cup coriander seeds About coriander seed →
- ⅓ cup fennel seeds
- 2 Tbsp. cumin seeds About cumin →
- 1 Tbsp. black cumin seeds About cumin →
- 1 tsp. black peppercorns About black pepper →
- 4 Tbsp. Kashmiri chile powder Mild (1,000–2,000 SHU). Swap: 3 parts sweet paprika + 1 part cayenne, same total amount
- 2 Tbsp. cayenne pepper Hot (30,000–50,000 SHU). Swap: Hot sauce, a few dashes
- 1 Tbsp. Diamond Crystal or 1¾ tsp. Morton kosher salt About kosher salt →
- 1 tsp. ground turmeric About turmeric →
- 2 heads of garlic, cloves separated, peeled About garlic →
- 1 2" piece ginger, peeled About fresh ginger →
- 3 Tbsp. vegetable oil About neutral oil →
- 5 lb. English-style bone-in beef short ribs
- 2 Tbsp Diamond Crystal or 1 Tbsp. plus ½ tsp. Morton kosher salt About kosher salt →
- 3 Tbsp. ghee or vegetable oil About ghee →
- 2 medium onions, thinly sliced About yellow onion →
- 2 bay leaves About bay leaves →
- Cilantro leaves with tender stems, thinly sliced serrano chile, thinly sliced ginger, store-bought fried onions, toasted naan or country-style bread, and lime wedges (for serving) About cilantro →
Out of something?
- Garlic
- for 1 clove, use 1/8 tsp garlic powder, or 1/2 tsp jarred minced garlic. Powder is mellow and toasty, not pungent; fine in rubs and soups, poor in aioli or garlic bread.
- Ginger
- for 1 tbsp grated, use 1/4 tsp ground ginger. Warm and dusty, not bright and juicy. Fine in baking and braises; weak in stir-fries.
- Onion
- for 1 medium, use 1 tbsp dried minced onion or 1 tsp onion powder. Flavor only, no texture or sweetness from browning.
- Bay leaf
- for 1, use 1/4 tsp dried thyme, or just leave it out. Bay's contribution is subtle; you'll miss it only in long braises and stocks.
Prep first
Get these done before you turn on the heat. Cooks call it mise en place.
Steps
-
1
Nihari Masala
-
2
Toss 10 green cardamom pods, 3 black cardamom pods, 3 black long pepper pods, 10 whole cloves, one 3"-long cinnamon stick, 1 star anise pod, ⅓ cup coriander seeds, ⅓ cup fennel seeds, 2 Tbsp. cumin seeds, 1 Tbsp. black cumin seeds, and 1 tsp. black peppercorns in a small bowl to combine.
-
3
Heat a dry medium skillet over medium. Toast spice mixture, stirring constantly, until fragrant, about 1 minute. Add 4 Tbsp. Kashmiri chile powder, 2 Tbsp. cayenne pepper, 1 Tbsp. Diamond Crystal or 1¾ tsp. Morton kosher salt, and 1 tsp. ground turmeric and toast, stirring constantly, until combined and fragrant, about 10 seconds. Transfer spices back to bowl and let cool.
-
4
Transfer spices to a spice mill or small blender and pulse to a fine powder. Do Ahead: Nihari masala can be made 2 months ahead. Store airtight at room temperature.
-
5
Nihari and Assembly
-
6
Place a rack in middle of oven; preheat to 350°. Blend 2 heads of garlic, cloves separated, peeled, one 2" piece ginger, peeled, and 3 Tbsp. vegetable oil in a small blender until smooth. Set garlic paste aside. (Alternatively, you can blend in a tall container or measuring glass with an immersion blender.)
-
7
Season 5 lb. English-style bone-in beef short ribs all over with 2 Tbsp Diamond Crystal or 1 Tbsp. plus ½ tsp. Morton kosher salt. Heat 3 Tbsp. ghee or vegetable oil in a large ovenproof Dutch oven or other heavy pot over medium-high. Working in batches if needed, cook short ribs, meaty side down, until a deeply browned crust forms, about 6 minutes per batch. Transfer to a plate with tongs, leaving fat in pot.
-
8
Cook 2 medium onions, thinly sliced, in same pot, stirring occasionally, until softened and golden, 10–12 minutes. Reduce heat to medium, add reserved garlic paste and cook, stirring often, until paste is beginning to stick to bottom of pot but not burning, about 4 minutes. Add 2 bay leaves and 3 Tbsp. nihari masala; cook, stirring constantly, until fragrant, about 1 minute.
-
9
Pour in 6–7 cups water (there is little risk of the pot running dry, and you can adjust the sauce consistency at the end, so no need to be exact here) and bring to a simmer, stirring and scraping up browned bits stuck to bottom of pot. Nestle short ribs back into pot and return liquid to a simmer. Cover pot, transfer to oven, and braise until meat is tender, and liquid is thickened, 2½–3 hours. If the braise seems too soupy for your liking, uncover and simmer until sauce thickens slightly, 20–30 minutes. You can also add a little more water to loosen if needed.
-
10
Skim as much fat from surface as possible; discard. Ladle nihari among bowls and top with cilantro leaves with tender stems, thinly sliced serrano chile, thinly sliced ginger, and store-bought fried onions. Serve with toasted naan or country-style bread and lime wedges for squeezing over.
Flavor map
How Nana pairs flavors →This one is warmly spiced, garlicky and spicy.
Goes well with
Serve it with
Rajma
90% flavor match
Mace loves black cumin; both lean on star anise and fennel seed.
Serve it with
Rajma Recipe (Rajma Masala)
87% flavor match
Both lean on ghee and turmeric; garam masala with turmeric is a natural match.
Start with
Oil free Dal Tadka - Restaurant style Lentil soup
91% flavor match
Same Indian roots; garam masala with turmeric is a natural match.
Finish with
Moong Dal Payasam (Paruppu Payasam)
89% flavor match
The ghee cools things down after the heat; a classic Indian finish: payasam.
Pour
Vegan Coquito
95% flavor match
A classic Indian pour: chai; both taste like winter.
Pour, alcohol-free
Thandai Masala
85% flavor match
A classic Indian pour: thandai; cold melon against the heat.
Log in to tell Nana which pairings are good. Your votes improve the map.
More about this recipe
Nutrition
1 of 8 servings · about 343 g Whole recipe · about 2741 g · High confidence
| % DV* | ||
|---|---|---|
| Total Fat | 40.8 g | 52% |
| Saturated Fat | 16.3 g | 81% |
| Trans Fat | 0.028 g | |
| Cholesterol | 180 mg | 60% |
| Sodium | 1195 mg | 52% |
| Total Carbohydrate | 12.1 g | 4% |
| Dietary Fiber | 4.8 g | 17% |
| Total Sugars | 1.7 g | |
| Protein | 56.3 g | 113% |
| Vitamin D | 0 mcg | 0% |
| Calcium | 115 mg | 9% |
| Iron | 10 mg | 56% |
| Potassium | 1298 mg | 28% |
* % Daily Value is based on a 2,000-calorie diet.
- Carbs 8%
- Fat 57%
- Protein 35%
Vitamins & minerals
| Vitamin A | 105 mcg | 12% |
|---|---|---|
| Vitamin C | 4 mg | 4% |
| Vitamin D | 0 mcg | 0% |
| Vitamin E | 2.3 mg | 15% |
| Vitamin K | 20.4 mcg | 17% |
| Thiamin (B1) | 0.32 mg | 27% |
| Riboflavin (B2) | 0.51 mg | 39% |
| Niacin (B3) | 10.5 mg | 65% |
| Pantothenic acid (B5) | 1 mg | 21% |
| Vitamin B6 | 1.3 mg | 74% |
| Folate | 25.4 mcg DFE | 6% |
| Vitamin B12 | 9.6 mcg | 400% |
| Choline | 7 mg | 1% |
| Calcium | 115 mg | 9% |
| Iron | 10 mg | 56% |
| Potassium | 1298 mg | 28% |
| Magnesium | 102 mg | 24% |
| Phosphorus | 598 mg | 48% |
| Zinc | 14.2 mg | 129% |
| Copper | 0.35 mg | 39% |
| Manganese | 1.1 mg | 46% |
| Selenium | 43.2 mcg | 78% |
Fats & carbs in detail
| Monounsaturated fat | 16 g | |
|---|---|---|
| Polyunsaturated fat | 4.7 g | |
| Omega-3 | 0.54 g | 33% |
| Omega-6 | 4.1 g | 24% |
| Starch | 0 g | |
| Net carbs | 7.3 g | |
| Omega-6 : Omega-3 ratio | 7.7 : 1 |
Amino acids (protein building blocks)
| Histidine | 1.9 g | |
|---|---|---|
| Isoleucine | 2.5 g | |
| Leucine | 4.3 g | |
| Lysine | 4.5 g | |
| Methionine | 1.4 g | |
| Cystine | 0.62 g | |
| Phenylalanine | 2.1 g | |
| Tyrosine | 1.8 g | |
| Threonine | 2.4 g | |
| Tryptophan | 0.61 g | |
| Valine | 2.7 g |
How we calculated this
| Ingredient | Counted as | g | kcal |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 green cardamom pods | Spices, cardamom | 6 | 19 |
| 3 black cardamom pods | Spices, cardamom | 2 | 6 |
| 3 black long pepper pods | Not found — no matching food | ||
| 10 whole cloves | Spices, cloves, ground | 1 | 3 |
| 1 3"-long cinnamon stick | Spices, cinnamon, ground | 1 | 1 |
| 1 star anise pod | Spices, anise seed | 0 | 2 |
| ⅓ cup coriander seeds | Spices, coriander seed | 29 | 86 |
| ⅓ cup fennel seeds | Fennel, bulb, raw | 29 | 9 |
| 2 Tbsp. cumin seeds | Spices, cumin seed | 15 | 55 |
| 1 Tbsp. black cumin seeds | Spices, cumin seed | 7 | 28 |
| 1 tsp. black peppercorns | Spices, pepper, black | 2 | 6 |
| 4 Tbsp. Kashmiri chile powder | Spices, chili powder | 32 | 91 |
| 2 Tbsp. cayenne pepper | Spices, pepper, black | 15 | 37 |
| 1 Tbsp. Diamond Crystal or 1¾ tsp. Morton kosher salt | Salt, table | 18 | 0 |
| 1 tsp. ground turmeric | Spices, turmeric, ground | 3 | 9 |
| 2 heads of garlic, cloves separated, peeled | Garlic, raw | 6 | 9 |
| 1 2" piece ginger, peeled | Ginger root, raw | 6 | 5 |
| 3 Tbsp. vegetable oil | Oil, soybean, salad or cooking | 41 | 361 |
| 5 lb. English-style bone-in beef short ribs | Beef, rib, shortribs, separable lean only, choice, raw | 2268 | 3969 |
| 2 Tbsp Diamond Crystal or 1 Tbsp. plus ½ tsp. Morton kosher salt | Not found — no matching food | ||
| 3 Tbsp. ghee or vegetable oil | Butter oil, anhydrous | 38 | 337 |
| 2 medium onions, thinly sliced | Onions, raw | 220 | 88 |
| 2 bay leaves | Spices, bay leaf | 1 | 3 |
| Cilantro leaves with tender stems, thinly sliced serrano chile, thinly sliced ginger, store-bought fried onions, toasted naan or country-style bread, and lime wedges (for serving) | Not counted — no amount (to taste / garnish) |
Matched to the USDA FoodData Central database (SR Legacy). Amounts are converted with USDA portion weights where they exist, otherwise typical sizes. Open in the analyzer to adjust a match →
Estimated from the ingredient list — brands, exact sizes and cooking losses vary. Not medical advice.
Allergens
-
Red meat (alpha-gal) › Beef & veal
In: 5 lb. English-style bone-in beef short ribs
Mammalian meat and by-products. Alpha-gal syndrome, often from a tick bite, causes delayed reactions to beef, pork, lamb and gelatin; some people also react to dairy.
-
Black & white pepper
In: 1 tsp. black peppercorns
-
Cardamom
In: 10 green cardamom pods; 3 black cardamom pods
-
Nightshades › Hot chili peppers
In: 4 Tbsp. Kashmiri chile powder; 2 Tbsp. cayenne pepper; Cilantro leaves with tender stems, thinly sliced serrano chile, thinly sliced ginger, store-bought fried onions, toasted naan or country-style bread, and lime wedges (for serving)
Tomato, potato, peppers (sweet and hot), eggplant, tomatillo and goji. Sweet potatoes are not nightshades.
-
Cinnamon
In: 1 3"-long cinnamon stick
-
Clove
In: 10 whole cloves
-
Coriander & cilantro
In: ⅓ cup coriander seeds; Cilantro leaves with tender stems, thinly sliced serrano chile, thinly sliced ginger, store-bought fried onions, toasted naan or country-style bread, and lime wedges (for serving)
-
Cumin
In: 2 Tbsp. cumin seeds; 1 Tbsp. black cumin seeds
-
Fennel, anise & licorice
In: 1 star anise pod; ⅓ cup fennel seeds
-
Onion & garlic family › Garlic
In: 2 heads of garlic, cloves separated, peeled
Onions, shallots, garlic, leeks, scallions and chives, including powders.
-
Ginger
In: 1 2" piece ginger, peeled; Cilantro leaves with tender stems, thinly sliced serrano chile, thinly sliced ginger, store-bought fried onions, toasted naan or country-style bread, and lime wedges (for serving)
-
Citrus › Lemon & lime
In: Cilantro leaves with tender stems, thinly sliced serrano chile, thinly sliced ginger, store-bought fried onions, toasted naan or country-style bread, and lime wedges (for serving)
-
Milk / dairy
In: 3 Tbsp. ghee or vegetable oil
Cow's milk and anything made from it: butter, cream, cheese, yogurt, whey, casein, ghee.
-
Onion & garlic family › Onion & shallot
In: 2 medium onions, thinly sliced; Cilantro leaves with tender stems, thinly sliced serrano chile, thinly sliced ginger, store-bought fried onions, toasted naan or country-style bread, and lime wedges (for serving)
Onions, shallots, garlic, leeks, scallions and chives, including powders.
-
Turmeric
In: 1 tsp. ground turmeric
-
Gluten › Wheat
In: Cilantro leaves with tender stems, thinly sliced serrano chile, thinly sliced ginger, store-bought fried onions, toasted naan or country-style bread, and lime wedges (for serving)
Wheat, barley, rye and oats (oats are often cross-contaminated). Celiac disease and wheat allergy are different — pick just Wheat if only wheat is the problem.
Found by reading the ingredient names. Brands and "may contain" warnings vary, so always check the label.
Questions about this recipe
- Can I make this stew ahead of time?
- Yes, Nihari often tastes better the next day. Store it in the refrigerator and reheat gently on the stove, adding a splash of water if the sauce has thickened too much.
- How do I store or freeze the leftovers?
- Store in an airtight container in the freezer for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge before reheating on the stovetop.
- What can I use if I can't find Kashmiri chile powder?
- You can substitute it with a mix of paprika and a pinch of cayenne pepper to achieve a similar mild heat and deep red color.
- How do I know when the beef is perfectly done?
- The beef is ready when it is tender enough to pull apart easily with a fork and the sauce has reduced to a rich, thick consistency.
- What is the best way to serve this dish?
- Serve it hot with toasted naan or crusty bread for dipping, topped with fresh ginger, cilantro, green chiles, and a squeeze of lime to cut through the richness.
My notes
Log in to keep private notes on recipes.
Learn while you cook
Learn library →- Techniques · 6 min read Braising Brown tough, well-marbled meat, half-submerge it in flavorful liquid, cover, and cook low (300–325°F) until a fork slid…
- Ingredient Deep-Dives · 8 min read The Onion Family Yellow onions for cooking, red for raw, shallots for sauces; the finer you cut garlic or onion, the stronger it gets, a…
- Ingredient Deep-Dives · 7 min read Fresh Herbs Tender herbs go in at the end and live in a jar of water; woody herbs go in early and live in a damp towel. Use 1 part …
Words in this recipe
- Reduce
- To simmer a liquid so water evaporates, concentrating flavor and thickening it. Learn more
- Simmer
- Liquid just below a boil, about 185 to 205°F, with small bubbles rising gently.
- Braise
- To brown food, then cook it slowly, partly covered by liquid, in a covered pot. Turns tough, collagen-rich cuts tender. Learn more
- Skim
- To remove foam, scum or fat from the surface of a simmering liquid.
Handy for this recipe Safe Cooking TemperaturesSubstitution Finder